4 ms·
It may be to China's benefit to encourage moves in both directions.
by ceejayoz 3y ago
It may be to China's benefit to encourage moves in both directions.
- makingstuffs 3y agoDivision is everything. It is immeasurably more difficult to control and manipulate a unified mass than it is to manipulate multiple different fragments of said mass. This applies to pretty much everything from flat-pack furniture to society.
- ketzo 3y agoIt is psy-op 101 to push people to any extreme you can; left, right, up, down, doesn’t matter as long as they’re mad as fuck.
- _huayra_ 3y agoIt's pretty telling how effective China thinks it is, given their restrictions on Douyin ("internal Chinese TikTok"). iirc kids can only use it for <1 hour / day.
- hwillis 3y agoThat's absolutely evidence of the opposite. If china thought they could use the app's algorithms to promote national unity, they would do that. They have their own exclusive app. China thinks its effective at wasting time. Children also aren't allowed to play video games monday through friday, and are limited to 1 hour per day otherwise- a law which existed before douyin limits: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-58384457 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-58384457 The country that is obsessive about its children and their productivity, the country famous for kids competing in chess and abacus and piano... that country is just banning douyin because it's a time waster.
- ketzo 3y agoI think that is kind of orthogonal to the point I don't think encouraging national unity and encouraging strife and polarization are the same thing at all, and in fact I would bet the latter is easier at scale Maybe they're restricting Douyin because it's a timewaster, maybe because it much more naturally encourages discord than unity. Maybe both. Probably both, frankly.
- hoseja 3y agoThey also don't peddle fentanyl within their borders.
- HeartStrings 3y agoHonestly, that’s pretty great. We have limitations on online casinos, because of social harm. How is TikTok and vidya different? They do objectively harm prodouctivity and implement addictive dark patterns, loot boxes, consuming over producing. Sometimes limiting personal freedom actually can be for one’s own good.
- hbbio 3y agoYes, until civil war. I dunno if TikTok should be banned, but Nepal motives are truthful.
- jlmorton 3y agoCan we please stop pretending China, as a national entity, is doing anything at all with TikTok USA? It is absurd and not worthy of a board like this. I'm sure many you know people that work at TikTok? This just isn't happening, at all. The sum total of what China is doing with TikTok is restricting what people in China see, which is what China is worried about.
- aaomidi 3y ago> It is absurd and not worthy of a board like this. I'm sure many you know people that work at TikTok? This just isn't happening, at all. Honestly, I feel like you're right. But at the same time, it'd be a genius strategy to destabilize a country. We'd be getting beat at our own game we pull on other countries.
- xyzelement 3y agoWhat justifies the strength of your confidence? From game-theoretic point of view: is China a geopolitical adversary? Yes. Does China control TikTok? Yes. Is TikTok a tool to tweak how citizens of your adversary think? Yes. Is that powerful? Yes. So the facts our - our adversary is in control of a tool which can influence how we think, which is valuable to them. We don't know for sure that they use the tool but... why wouldn't they?
- hwillis 3y ago> Does China control TikTok? Yes. No. Not in any meaningful way. The data and employees are in the US. Every intelligence agency in the US is watching those buildings and reading their data. The US has no laws against inspecting every single packet sent internationally, the employees are subject to US laws, and tiktok has distanced itself from china. https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/07/tech/tiktok-leaving-hong-kong-intl-hnk/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/07/tech/tiktok-leaving-hong-kong... They are not meaningfully different from any other US company. It's not like they don't give data to china: https://www.businessinsider.com/google-gave-user-data-to-hong-kong-authorities-last-year-2021-9 https://www.businessinsider.com/google-gave-user-data-to-hon... Tiktok is just the new banana republic, the new gulf war, etc. The US government is aggressively anti-competitive with non-domestic corporate threats to its largest industries. It has always attempted to destroy competition and maximize domestic control of furs, then produce, then oil, and now social media and advertising.
- AlexandrB 3y agoLet's be real. It's not TikTok, it's social media. Twitter had a reputation as a cesspool where people yell increasingy extreme political opinions at each other long before TikTok was popular. Gamergate was before TikTok. TikTok is just the most refined version of the same rotten medium.
- stjohnswarts 3y agoObviously they want social chaos in the USA, pitting right against left is one way of doing that, so maybe just have a self adjusting algo that detects which way they lean and then slowly increase the ratio of right to neutral/left ideas(videos). Slowly push the person in that direction a bit at a time over months. I've been thinking about signup up for a mysudo account and playing with the algos to see how long it takes to become a full on Marxist and also a MAGA extremist.