6 ms·
Zelle finally caves after years of refusing to refund scam victims
- cgb223 3y agoI was scammed out of a few grand in a moving scam a few years ago over Zelle, via my bank Does this mean I can get that money back? Who do I talk to/where do I go to do so? My bank? Zelle itself?
- itake 3y agoAre you able to sue them in small claims court? If not, why not?
- fooker 3y agoYou need to prove that you were able to serve them a notice. Works for businesses or neighbors, sure. But random scammer online--no way.
- ceejayoz 3y agoAbsolutely not. The clawback mechanism will work on scales of a few days, weeks perhaps. Retroactive for years? No way in hell.
- chihuahua 3y agoYes, it would be a disaster for a payment mechanism where nothing is ever final, and a year after you sold a MacBook to someone for $1500, suddenly that $1500 gets clawed back because someone social engineered Zelle. It would be a useless system if you never know if you are going to keep the money or if it could suddenly disappear one day.
- jxi 3y agoWhat was the scam?
- sylvainkalache 3y agoI hate Zelle; in South Florida, that's all the rage. No one wants to use Venmo or other more user-friendly apps.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI hate PayPal (Venmo). I see no reason to give an unnecessary middleman control of my funds, or see my transactions.
- olyjohn 3y agoI hate all of them. They all let people get away with scams (just different ones), and give no shits about their customers as long as they are taking fuckloads of your money.
- lxgr 3y agoTo be fair, a bank presumably makes no money at all (except in that it might slightly increase their non-interest-bearing checking account deposit base) from offering Zelle. Dispute arbitration does cost money, though (especially if banks would step in to make customers whole in case fraudsters are already out of their reach), which is why we're in this mess in the first place.
- throwawaysleep 3y agoPeople hate it for the same reason it can be used for scams. It is trivially refundable to someone if they complain, even if the transaction is legitimate.
- lxgr 3y agoZelle's usability is entirely down to your bank's app. I've seen both atrocious and pretty usable integrations. Other than that, Zelle has one huge advantage over the competition: The money is available in the recipient's bank account immediately. Venmo, Cash App etc. charge quite a bit of money for instant payouts.
- underwater 3y ago> Zelle has said that 99.9 percent of money transfers go through as users intended, without a fraud or scam report ... Zelle usage has grown significantly since its launch, from 247 million transactions in 2017 to 1.8 billion in 2021. Their defense is that they only process two million fraudulent transactions a year?
- sib 3y ago"Only two million reported fraudulent transactions per year" :)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- swatcoder 3y agoThat's the same defense used for all recent failings of Big Tech at scale: "Well, when you sell as many apples as we do, of course you'll sell a few billion rotten ones. You can't expect us to check them all at this volume!"
- jacquesm 3y agoNot really. Fraud is a function of all payment systems because of human nature, not because of the tech. You could implement all of this with paper and sliderules and there would still be fraudulent transactions.
- LeifCarrotson 3y agoThe difference is that in big tech, the fraud is expected because of the scale, it's an amoral faceless algorithm. If you had a human verifying each transaction, you could blame (or at least appeal to) the human.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat human would likely do much worse than the algorithms. This is a real problem and as far as I know there is no way to get this resolved because the main reason the algorithm is able to outperform the human is because it enables a larger volume and so you have more data to work with. This is the same reason why a PSP will always give you better fraud protection than rolling your own, they look at so much more data than you ever will that they will be able to better tell friend from foe. Fewer false positives and fewer false negatives. Still too much, but the theory is that in order to be able to detect fraud you will have to have some fraud!
- Cody-99 3y agoOne of the main benefits of zelle was it couldn't be clawed back. Scams suck but paypal and other related apps have a major problem where the money gets clawed back after a legitimate transaction/deal is complete. Hopefully steps are taken to ensure this type of fraud doesn't become an issue.
- vkou 3y agoZelle could always place a high bar for clawbacks, like, say, requiring a police report.
- bastawhiz 3y agoA police report is a high bar for a $20 transaction (perhaps even way too high) but too low for, say, a series of transactions adding up to $10,000. Having a police report is easy if, say, you're employed by the police.
- vkou 3y agoThere's nothing that stops Zelle from doing further diligence around a $10,000 fraud, the police report is just there to significantly raise the barrier for a fraudster disputing charges. It's tough to do fraud at scale when you have to show up to a police station, give them all your info, and leave a detailed paper trail.
- tantalor 3y agoOnce the money is frozen you could go straight to small claims court for those $10k disputes. Anything bigger call the lawyers.
- grepfru_it 3y agoThis is basically the paypal model. No one has time for small claims court
- 3y ago
- pxmpxm 3y agoRIP free money transfer is what that means - the service can't be both free and liable for people falling for scams.
- lxgr 3y agoWhere are you hearing this from? The article claims no such thing: It suggests that banks will attempt clawing back the money in case of disputes. That obviously can't be the entire truth, though – unless there's some mechanism to arbitrate claims, it would effectively make Zelle unusable for many of its current uses.
- pxmpxm 3y agoAny money transfer mechanism where the sender has recourse means the transfer agent is looking at a liability - both by having to have a whole dispute department like any credit card processor and/or paypal and an actual dollar liability where they have to refund someone that got scammed without being able to recover the money. The obvious conclusion is they'll have to start charging everyone transfer fees to pay for the people that fall for stupid scams.
- lxgr 3y ago> an actual dollar liability where they have to refund someone that got scammed without being able to recover the money I think you're being much more optimistic about what banks will actually be doing than me. I hope it's not, but based on the article, it might just be "we'll try to claw back your transfer with no questions asked; if the money is still in the recipient's account, you get it back; otherwise you get nothing". From the article: > Zelle simply "implemented a mechanism that allows banks to claw back funds from the recipient's account and return them to the sender."
- lxgr 3y agoThis can obviously not be the entire fraud prevention mechanism: > Zelle simply "implemented a mechanism that allows banks to claw back funds from the recipient's account and return them to the sender." I'm curious to see what the prerequisites for such a clawback are, both on the side of the payer (a police report? a signed statement? a click in an app?) and the payee (what happens if the money isn't in their account anymore?).
- chatmasta 3y agoIt's possible there are no real protections to ensure a clawback is "legit," other than shifting the burden of verification from the customer to the bank. Now fraudsters need to convince the bank that a payment was invalid, compared to convincing a customer that an address is what they expected.
- lxgr 3y agoPossibly, but I highly doubt that banks would want to get into the weeds of dispute arbitration for a free P2P payments system.
- the_svd_doctor 3y agoIs that any different than for, say, checks?
- chatmasta 3y agoYeah, they don't want to, which is why they spent 5+ years avoiding it until the FTC forced their hand...
- bl4kers 3y agoZelle is like a bank consortium, no? They should have a vested interest in both identifying fraudulent transactions as well as customers using their accounts for fraud so they can close them down
- eclipticplane 3y ago> CFPB may no longer be considering new protections, because Zelle's recent changes "have so far satisfied the agency." At least codify what the banks agreed to implement -- otherwise they will just go back on this when it costs them too much money and they think no one is looking.
- lxgr 3y agoAs described in the article, this might just cost them nothing: > Zelle simply "implemented a mechanism that allows banks to claw back funds from the recipient's account and return them to the sender." I highly doubt that that's true, though. For one thing, this would trivially fail in case the recipient account has already cashed out the funds.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> I highly doubt that that's true, though. For one thing, this would trivially fail in case the recipient account has already cashed out the funds. Being banks (not that you can't otherwise, but still) it's also entirely possible for them to overdraw your account to do so. And then if you don't care about that, close your account and report it to Chex Systems, which will make opening any bank or CU account quite difficult.
- lxgr 3y agoI don't know the details of Zelle scams, but my guess would be that the payee accounts usually aren't under the control of people that care about keeping them open in the long term (i.e. have either been taken over by fraudsters or have been opened fraudulently).
- nneonneo 3y agoCanada has had eTransfer for several years now, which is functionally the same as Zelle (irreversible, instant, free bank-to-bank transfers), but somehow I haven’t heard the same level of complaining about fraud. I wonder why that is?
- BobaFloutist 3y agoProbably because Canada has a tenth the population, a tenth the GDP, and I would assume considerably less than a tenth of the media dominance of the United States.
- mschuster91 3y agoScammers focus on countries where they have already established ways of getting the money out. Indian callcenter scams are mostly focused on the US for that reason, here in Germany it's mostly Turkish callcenters if you go by police raid reports. Another part of the reason is how "legacy" phone carriers operate... the US up until a year or two ago allowed pretty much everyone and their dog to spoof phone numbers using VoIP, which made life for scammers incredibly easy as they didn't need much of a local presence beyond some money mules. Here in Germany, it's way harder to get access to line trunks that allow caller ID spoofing, and on top of that we have strict regulations on what banks need to do to to verify customer identities so it's harder for scammers to open up bank accounts, and so our scammers have to rely on actual people picking up money from the scam victims (e.g. the "fake policeman" scam).
- donatj 3y agoWhat is the actual mechanism of the scam? Just not providing goods or services paid for?
- brewdad 3y agoPretty much any scam you could think of. Previously, Zelle was like cash. Once it’s handed over it’s gone. Any recourse lies outside of Zelle. Now it sounds like you may be able to work with Zelle to get your cash back in some cases.
- the_svd_doctor 3y agoProbably something like (1) Scammer sends check / something like that, showing a larger than expected deposit (2) Check is cached by victim (3) Victim is asked to reimburse the difference using Zelle or other "irreversible" method (best being Bitcoin, I guess, but Zelle also works apprently..) (4) Check bounces (5) Victim looses the money send by Zelle
- donatj 3y agoWe should have Scam class in school that teaches the most basic scams. Every time anyone asks you to send money back, it’s a scam. Always.
- throw7 3y agoZelle is ok for known people (face to face), friends, and family, but i don't trust using it for complete stranger's email or phone number. I wonder if Zelle could be feeling competition from fednow?
- mixmastamyk 3y agoHow does one use fednow? I looked twice and haven’t found a bank implementing it.
- cmurf 3y agoClawback. There's an innovation.
- bhewes 3y agoZelle is owned by Bank of America, Truist, Capital One, JPMorgan Chase, PNC Bank, U.S. Bank, and Wells Fargo. They probably have enough data now to know what banks are backing zelle scammers and who in their own networks are scammers.
- exabrial 3y agoZelle owes you nothing if you send money some place stupid. If you’re selling items online, meet in person, pay cash. Simple as that.