5 ms·
The US Supreme Court says it is adopting a code of ethics for the first time
- jdworrells 3y ago[flagged]
- gnicholas 3y agoDoes the ethics code have removal as a consequence? Does it apply retroactively to past events? If not, then it would seem no one is going anywhere.
- vaidhy 3y agoThis is creating an internal struggle between the cynic in me vs the optimist in me. Will people rise above their self interest?
- calamari4065 3y agoNot until we cure the societal ills that more or less force people to consider themselves above anything else. So, probably not in our lifetimes
- ulizzle 3y agoYeah, not with our culture. Things are likely to get worse until they collapse like empires usually do
- Amorymeltzer 3y agoThe document itself: https://www.supremecourt.gov/about/Code-of-Conduct-for-Justices_November_13_2023.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/about/Code-of-Conduct-for-Justi... >For the most part these rules and principles are not new: The Court has long had the equivalent of common law ethics rules, that is, a body of rules derived from a variety of sources, including statutory provisions, the code that applies to other members of the federal judiciary, ethics advisory opinions issued by the Judicial Conference Committee on Codes of Conduct, and historic practice. The absence of a Code, however, has led in recent years to the misunderstanding that the Justices of this Court, unlike all other jurists in this country, regard themselves as unrestricted by any ethics rules. To dispel this misunderstanding, we are issuing this Code, which largely represents a codification of principles that we have long regarded as governing our conduct. ---- From a quick scan, I think the inclusion of spouses in some of the suggestions for recusal are probably among the most notable. Also: >A Justice may attend a “fundraising event” of law- related or other nonprofit organizations, but a Justice should not knowingly be a speaker, a guest of honor, or featured on the program of such event. In general, an event is a “fundraising event” if proceeds from the event exceed its costs or if donations are solicited in connection with the event. Is maybe interesting, especially re: Federalist Society and Leonard Leo. At any rate, it says "should" and "may" rather than "must" so YMMV.
- barryrandall 3y agoThere are no consequences and no requirements in the code. It accomplishes nothing. This is absolutely, positively worthless.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoYep. This might as well be a poem about squirrels for all the effect it will have on justices' behavior.
- jcranmer 3y agoOne of the noticeable lacks I see is that there's a mention that a justice shouldn't be a member of a civic or charitable organization if it's going to be engaged in litigation before the court, but there's no corresponding mention for legal organizations that may be engaged in litigation. Given that one of the issues is the role of the Federalist Society in the many seeming conflicts of interests it produces, this does seem like an intentional oversight.
- justrealist 3y agoI think at that point you'd run into the infringement of first amendment rights for the judges themselves. You'd really say they aren't allowed to openly be a member of the ACLU or whatever?
- moate 3y agoI missed the part discussing enforcement and consequences, because surely this wouldn’t just be a mealy mouthed list of suggestions without recourse. What would the point of that be other than a fig leaf over Clarence Thomas? Oh wait…
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- depereo 3y agoEh, if it doesn't have consequences it's a bit pointless.
- sonicanatidae 3y agoAhh, but they can wave around a sheet of paper and talk up a good game, and that's all that seems to matter in US politics.
- HumblyTossed 3y ago[flagged]
- ilovetux 3y agoNothing is binding. They are all exempt. This is just theater and means nothing.
- apozem 3y agoThis is a fine gesture, but it does not solve the fundamental problem that Supreme Court justices are an unelected super-government with lifetime appointments and zero accountability. The whole institution is absurd and undemocratic and, as Clarence Thomas has proved [0], ripe with opportunities for corruption. A non-binding code of ethics doesn't change that. [0]: https://www.propublica.org/series/supreme-court-scotus https://www.propublica.org/series/supreme-court-scotus
- EGreg 3y agoAre you proposing we do a Netanyahu-style reform?
- boxed 3y ago> and zero accountability They can be impeached?
- remmargorp64 3y agoBy us?
- numbsafari 3y agoSCOTUS impeachment is a virtual function from the electorate through their elected officials. Hopefully the receiver isn't a null object...
- meepmorp 3y agoImpeachment is a political solution, though. Conviction in the house is a simple majority, but removal from office (or other forms of punishment) requires a 2/3 majority in the senate. That's not going to happen in the current environment, no matter how unsuitable an individual might be for office. It's accountability, but in theory only.
- boxed 3y ago> It's accountability, but in theory only. That's true for much more than the Supreme Court though.
- archildress 3y agoHeadline ought to be re-written as "Supreme Court forced to codify once-unwritten rules due to rampant abuse by Justice Thomas."
- ImJamal 3y agoYou may want to read the article since others have issues as well. >Many of those stories focused on Justice Clarence Thomas and his failure to disclose travel and other financial ties with wealthy conservative donors including Harlan Crow and the Koch brothers. But Justices Samuel Alito and Sonia Sotomayor also have been under scrutiny.
- archildress 3y agoRoughly equivalent to "all news networks are biased", overlooking the "but not to equivalent degrees."
- ImJamal 3y agoFrankly you are making a massive assumption. We don't know how deep this behavior goes with the other justices. In 2018, Ginsburg had more trips paid for by others than any other justice for example. Since 2004, Bryer had more trips than any other justice. The fact that people are only calling out one person seems very telling to me. This problem is far deeper than one guy or one side. https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2019/06/scotus-justices-rack-up-trips/ https://www.opensecrets.org/news/2019/06/scotus-justices-rac...
- addicted 3y agoFrankly those are trips that were disclosed and Thomas’s trips weren’t. That’s one of the biggest problems with what Thomas did (and shows that he knew what he did wouldn’t pass muster). Of course, that’s assuming you’re not one of the people who believes that he truly thought a trip on a private plane does not need to be disclosed because the seat would have otherwise been taken by someone else so it wasn’t actually a benefit.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 3y agoThis is an interesting attempt to ward off the growing skepticism of judicial supremacy in some groups. There is a fascinating struggle between judicial supremacy and constitutional supremacy in America with a long history. Obviously there are pros and cons to each view, and who is for or against one or the other often changes depending on the social issue at hand. I don't think a code of ethics will be very effective. A more substantial move would be to introduce term-limits.
- virtue3 3y agoAgreed. The most "long term" effect a US president has is nominating supreme court justices. I also fail to see how a "code of conduct" might change the way individual justices interpret the current constitution. Worse yet, who is writing the code of ethics? Is it going to be a constitution v2? Constitution-lite?
- mikepurvis 3y agoAs a foreigner who isn't in the know, what does constitutional supremacy look like in practical terms? Isn't it still the judges who have the last word on how the constitution is to be interpreted and applied?
- beezlebroxxxxxx 3y agoJudicial supremacy is the idea that the judiciary is the sole arbiter of constitutional meaning. Lincoln, reacting to a ruling that upheld that black slaves “had no rights which the white man was bound to respect" said: > The candid citizen must confess that if the policy of the Government upon vital questions affecting the whole people is to be irrevocably fixed by decisions of the Supreme Court, the instant they are made in ordinary litigation between parties in personal actions the people will have ceased to be their own rulers, having to that extent practically resigned their Government into the hands of that eminent tribunal. Which is actually more nuanced than just "you can ignore the supreme court whenever." Instead, it's articulating the idea that the SC has to be balanced with congress and elected officials. The idea that the SC is the sole arbiter of constitutional meaning grates against the democratically elected power of congress and the executive. An SC that constantly rejects congress risks overstepping and delegitimizing it's very power and role. For instance, congress might simply ignore a ruling, or strip its jurisdiction over certain matters, or it might change the size of the court. This of course could equally backfire on congress and the president. It's, as always, a balancing act of checks and balances rather than just the SC always getting what they want. Constitutional supremacy then is more like the argument that sometimes the judiciary has to be saved from itself. The debate has a fascinating history in American politics.
- alphazard 3y agoThe founders clearly didn't envision the court becoming as politicized as it is now. They basically hand-waved away the problem of how to interpret laws. If the laws were written in some kind of unambiguous formal system, then there wouldn't be a need for a court. But no such system exists, so we have this read-time political power corresponding to the write-time political power of the Legislative branch. It's pretty clear the founders wanted some magic box to tell everyone how the laws applied in a given situation, and designed the rest of the system around that. They attempted to create that with the Judicial branch. It's clear from the lack of term limits that they thought the Justices would be apolitical. However, there is no mechanism forcing the justices to interpret the laws in the simplest, most literal way. Instead we have increasingly stretched interpretations used to affect political change sans representative legislature.
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- mike503 3y ago"Laws for thee, not for me"
- xracy 3y agoThis has to be the most disappointing band-aid they possibly could've trotted out to the American Public. And by "Band-aid", I mean, "Piece of scotch tape they're slapping on a gaping wound and saying it's 'fixed'." My biggest fear is that the American public is going to look at this and say to themselves "oh look, they fixed the problem!"