2 ms·
Except for Intel, the others, like AMD or NVIDIA, cut features that reduce the performance without having a software impact, and which indeed correspond to real
by adrian_b 3y ago
Except for Intel, the others, like AMD or NVIDIA, cut features that reduce the performance without having a software impact, and which indeed correspond to real reductions in the manufacturing cost, i.e. the number of cores, the size of the cache memories and the maximum clock frequencies.
Only Intel has always disabled features that have negligible impact on the manufacturing cost, but which force various expenses upon the customers, like the disabling of various instructions or of internal peripherals. Due to this Intel policy, there are still plenty of programs that run slower than they should on the latest CPUs, because they may have been built for instruction sets that have become obsolete more than a decade ago, like SSE.
The 10% memory throughput reduction is not negligible. There are 2 main scenarios for using a cheap Sapphire Rapids SKU, one would be to use it to host a very large number of SSDs, and the other would be to host some application that cannot be distributed over multiple servers and which wants a lot of memory. In the latter case, if the application has a performance dependent on the amount of memory, it is likely that it would also benefit from a faster memory, but with Sapphire Rapids if you want a 10% faster memory, which costs nothing extra in the price of the DIMMs, you may need to pay double or triple for the CPU.
- zamadatix 3y agoI think you'd be surprised by how many identical style limitations others Nvidia has done over the years, from slightly lower clocked memory all the way down to programs that run slower than they should on other vendors because Nvidia code used by games was intentionally deoptimized for other platforms. AMD too, though to a lesser extent since it's been a while since it had its time in the sun from a market penetration perspective. 10% memory bandwidth is actually extremely negligible, particularly for the lower core count SKUs in the tier. The desktop gear you mentioned this all for has 1/3 the memory bandwidth, 1/4 if you plan on putting lots of RAM in, and can get away with a great deal many more tasks than you're describing something with 10% less memory bandwidth as able to do. We're talking a maximum worst case difference, for going between the lowest end Xeon to highest end Xeon, of 10% for the "my workload is to benchmark memory bandwidth only" use case. The reasoning for why it's supposed to be bad seems more focused with the starting assumption anything Intel does must somehow be bad than actually explaining what actual workload impact is had vs other options, and that's the red flag for me here.