Author of HashBackup here. I don't see how any kind of hash tree would be effective at de-duplicating VM machine images, other than the degenerate case of an e

Author of HashBackup here. I don't see how any kind of hash tree would be effective at de-duplicating VM machine images, other than the degenerate case of an exact copy, which is easy to detect with a single file hash. Most OSes use 4K block sizes. To get the best dedup you have to hash every 4K block and lookup each one individually in a dedup table. Two VM images could both contain an identical 4GB file, but every 4K block of that file could be stored at different offsets in the VM images. A tree hash wouldn't let you dedup anything but identical sections stored at identical offsets, whereas a dedup table and 4K blocks allows you to dedup the entire file.