4 ms·
> Adding to the challenge is Vermont’s housing shortage. [Name of large Vermont company desperate for blue-collar workers] has contracted with a local college t
by bell-cot 3y ago
> Adding to the challenge is Vermont’s housing shortage. [Name of large Vermont company desperate for blue-collar workers] has contracted with a local college to use unoccupied dormitories to house temporary workers brought in from other states and — on guest-worker visas — from other countries.
THIS. If your goal is to have actual workers, for sub-$250K/year jobs - then maybe that is in conflict with your other goal, of fast-track gentrification via ever-upward housing costs?
[Added details] From a quick check on Zillow:
> Vermont Key Takeaways
> Typical Home Values: $384,155
> 1-year Value Change: +5.8%
> (Data through October 31, 2023)
...so if $New_To_Vermont_Worker somehow manages to snag a no-major-work needed home for a mere $250K, and wipes out their savings to put 20% down...then the interest alone on their 30-year mortgage (at current rates) will be $16K/year. Add insurance, property taxes, utilities, repairs... Pretty obvious why young workers aren't flocking to Vermont.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoSounds like a screaming deal for low income workers. What exactly is the 16k number looking to demonstrate?
- bell-cot 3y agoEven with some really optimistic assumptions...just the $16K/year interest will soak up $8/hour of after-tax income from a full-time job. So "sounds really good" hourly wages really aren't - unless you're gonna live in your mom's basement or something.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 3y agoIt's not like Vermont is lacking in space for new construction, so it's turtles all the way down with a shortage of construction workers as well. In this case I don't even know if it's purely the economics of the housing bubble being prohibitive, or rather the societal aspiration to get in on the housing bubble that does it. A sibling commenter acted as if $16k/yr in interest was no big deal. And I guess it's not if one mentally accounts for it as a cost to be carried while the "investment" line goes up-right ("stonks!"). But if the housing bubble ever gets reformed in the slightest, very few places in Vermont are going to be appreciating like that. So that's $2400/mo rent mostly just going down the drain for a depreciating asset? I'd say that deal only makes sense for people planning to retire in that same house.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoHousing will end up like daycare or long term care: too expensive for the free market, only widely available with policy and government economic support. We under built for too long and as structural demographics squeezes the participation rate, labor costs will exceed what affordable housing can tolerate due to the median wage. A labor light cone if you will. Existing home inventory in the aggregate has a labor cost profile built into them that no longer exists.
- mindslight 3y agoI'm generally predisposed against looking at government for quick fixes. But I can't not think similar to you on housing. The government has already been dumping trillions of dollars into the housing bubble over the past several decades mainly just bidding up existing stock, putting us here. (the greatest trick Nixonite/Reaganite looters ever pulled was convincing us money "loaned" into the financial industry is distinct from "government spending") Rather than the disastrous approach of goal-blind subsidized mortgages, that government money needs to be directed to projects that accomplish deliberate policy goals. What VT would seem to need here is low-frills, semi-shared style housing for younger people that haven't really chosen a path in life but will be attracted by the low rent. The market just can't build something like that in VT - if nobody comes, it will be worth nothing. Whereas building the same thing outside Los Angeles will practically guarantee popularity (despite the permit pain), or even just a few hundred miles south as part of the Northeast Megalopolis will be a much surer thing (although more sprawling beige boxes on overwrought postage stamp lawns is still a surer bet, and predictability is the main need of leveraged money) Also, I feel like there's an analog to your comment about wages in general. General wages were held down so long by MBA cogification, over-management, classism, govt inflation treadmill, etc that now labor in general is too expensive for the free market. Nobody knows how much say working in a chocolate factory should actually pay. And if you're interested in chocolate, you'll probably be more successful starting a website drop shipping someone else's chocolate with your own branding...
- toomuchtodo 3y agoIt's possible when there is political will. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38117223 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38117223
- devwastaken 3y agoYoung workers will go anywhere. Often to war. The truth is few are hiring, and the wages are poor. Corps are trained to lie, so they do.
- bell-cot 3y ago> Often to war. True. OTOH, actually going to war pushes uber-strong emotional buttons in a lot of people. Vs. moving to Vermont, and taking an hourly job in the Packing & Shipping Dept. of a big cheese factory - maybe not so much.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoAnd the military offers far better pay and upward movement potential (especially the healthcare subsidies for a whole family).