2 ms·
Describing anything complicated to a general audience is tough. Most people fundamentally misunderstand the issues around fission and its economic viability ev
by Retric 3y ago
Describing anything complicated to a general audience is tough.
Most people fundamentally misunderstand the issues around fission and its economic viability even though there’s hundreds of nuclear reactors. No base load power isn’t inherently a good thing, it was actually coined to describe a downside. Clarifying just that misunderstanding gets info market forces, investments, and engendering to a non trivial level but you essentially need to condense it down to an infographic or people will lose interest. I have no idea how you could pull that off in an interesting manner.
IMO, the trick is to narrowly address the common misconceptions. Flat paper airplane wings provide lift, therefore Bernoulli’s principle isn’t why wings work. However that doesn’t extend to actually explaining complex topics.
- antonvs 3y agoIn the fusion case though, hype has been raised to the point of being outright false or even fraudulent. It’s not just a question of “describing something complicated”. It’s very easy to tell people that the latest experiment only produced 1% of the power that was put into it. Instead, they were told that the “net energy gain” was positive, and that this was a major breakthrough that brings viable commercial fusion power significantly closer. I suppose, when you have experiments costing tens of billions of dollars being funded by the public, that this kind of corruption of the truth is inevitable. But that quite understandably undermines public trust in science communication.
- Retric 3y agoThose experiments have basically nothing to do with fusion power and everything to do with validating computer simulations of nuclear reactions. The fig leaf of nuclear power generation is why you get the seemingly ridiculous Q factors based on energy in the pellets. Otherwise the obvious suggestion to cancel the program if ITER demonstrates Q = 10 while these things are Q = 0.01 could gain steam.
- antonvs 3y agoRight. But that’s not what the reporting or even the press releases said.
- Retric 3y agoYea, continuing a long tradition of secret government programs lying about what’s going on. I would be cautious at take anything they’re saying at face value.
- antonvs 3y agoThere are plenty of ways to put out press releases that don’t claim world-changing results where none exist.
- Retric 3y agoThe press release didn’t suggest this was directly capable of being turned into a power plant.
- antonvs 3y agoEnergy Secretary Granholm said the following at a press conference: “This milestone moves us one significant step closer to the possibility of zero-carbon abundant fusion energy powering our society.” That statement is false on its face. The press release contained more of the same. Some examples (from https://www.llnl.gov/archive/news/lawrence-livermore-national-laboratory-achieves-fusion-ignition https://www.llnl.gov/archive/news/lawrence-livermore-nationa... ): > “This astonishing scientific advance puts us on the precipice of a future no longer reliant on fossil fuels but instead powered by new clean fusion energy.” > “This monumental scientific breakthrough is a milestone for the future of clean energy.” > “This significant advancement showcases the future possibilities for the commercialization of fusion energy.” As I said, there are plenty of ways to put out press releases that don’t claim world-changing results where none exist. The idea that this was a necessary cover for the weapons applications is laughable.