3 ms·
> Within a capitalist system I really hate these lines. Not because capitalism doesn't have loads of problems but rather that it is missing underlying principl
by godelski 3y ago
> Within a capitalist system
I really hate these lines. Not because capitalism doesn't have loads of problems but rather that it is missing underlying principles and incentives that exist to create these structures and incentives. They are coupled with the economic systems but not strictly dependent on them. These issues aren't fundamentally broken because the privatization nor nationalization of capital resources. Many of these issues exist because of metric hacking which exist due to bureaucratization and politicization. So in that sense it doesn't matter if your society is capitalist, socialist, feudal, monarchistic, anarchistic, or whatever. It has to do with how humans fundamentally organize structures, delegate, and evaluate. It is a crisis of the 21st century because only now have we had such scale and such specialization. But as complexity has been increasing at an exponential rate we are simplifying our metrics and decreasing trust.
- ricardobeat 3y agoMetrics hacking is the beating heart of every corporation. Private corporations are the core of capitalism. How did you come to the conclusion that is a result “bureaucratization and politicization” instead?
- godelski 3y agoBecause bureaucracies and politics also existed under every communist regime. They exist in anarchist communities. They exist in households. But the difference is the degree of separation you are from those in power structures. And before you say that anarchism doesn't have a power structure (and there's many forms of anachism, just as there are many forms of socialism, communism, libertarianism, capitalism, liberalism, etc) if a power structure isn't explicit it is implicit. Which is rather well known in anarchist literature. We saw metric hacking in The Soviet Union, in The US, in China, in The UK, in Germany, France, Cuba, Colonial Korea, Colonial India (hell, we even got a stats term that everyone now knows out of that one), Feudal Europe, and far back into the Greeks, Ancient China, and as far back as we have literature. Which last I checked, most of those things predate capitalism but do not predate bureaucrats nor politics. I hate to break it to you, but not everything is about economics.
- ricardobeat 3y agoYour answer implied that science is not hindered by the incentives that exist within a capitalist society, as the parent suggested. Was science hindered in the same way in the soviet union, in early US history, China, UK, Germany, France, ancient greece and so on? I don't recall having heard about the greeks complaining on how they had to fine-tune their treaties for the review board or journal acceptance.
- godelski 3y ago> Your answer implied that science is not hindered by the incentives that exist within a capitalist society Weird take considering I'm complaining about things that happen in America and I'm not sure of anyone who would claim America isn't capitalist (well... at least not communist, but let's not get in the weeds there). Of course science is hindered by incentives driven by capitalism. But science is also hindered by incentives driven by communism. That's my entire point. > I don't recall having heard about the greeks complaining on how they had to fine-tune their treaties for the review board or journal acceptance. Sure. But I do recall ancient Greeks murdering people who "believed" in irrational numbers. Idk about you, but I'd call this a step up. You're acting like there's a system that has no flaws or that if a flaw doesn't exist in one area we can ignore all other flaws. Which, ironically is metric hacking Weird take...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tsunamifury 3y agoWoof if you don’t think metric hacking wasn’t a huge part of Russian communist bureaucracy your don’t know your history. Like my dude quota systems were at the heart of all successful capitalist, socialist, communist, and fascist nations. I can give examples. My man your logic is deeply flawed.
- ricardobeat 3y agoWhat logic? I made no logical statements, in fact I was asking a question.
- tsunamifury 3y agoBecause it’s wildly obvious that bureaucracies are the organizational form of control whether you choose a capitalist, fascist or socialist or communist system, it’s been proven over and over in everything from the NHS to shareholder capitalism to communist industrialism. They all relied on metric measured bureaucracies. I mean it’s a part of basic history here that you seem to be entirely missing. If you want a hyper explicit example it would be the cybersin project in socialist Chile.
- js8 3y agoNo, this is untrue. Metric hacking doesn't really exist in alternative systems of doing science. For example, it didn't exist in the Eastern Europe during communism. There, being an authority in research was more based on nepotism than on merit, but to a large extent even fringe people were allowed to pursue research. It is also not a feature of a tenure system, which existed in the West during the Cold War. The idea that we need to continuously monitor people for performance (measure them), rather than (for example) accept them into a community and just let them evolve there (for better or worse), is very intimately tied to capitalism. Also, all the KPI systems based on objective metric ignore a really simple metric, that you can simply ask every scientist an opinion (for example, who are the leading people in your field) and use that as a metric, as a recommendation what kind of research is to be financed more and what kind is to be financed less. Again, this is because capitalism cannot trust employees by default, it has to put some other authority in charge of them.
- godelski 3y ago> Metric hacking doesn't really exist in alternative systems of doing science. For example, it didn't exist in the Eastern Europe during communism. I'd like to make you aware of this little known thing called The 5 Year Plans.
- js8 3y agoI was talking about science, not planned economy in general. Planned economy is problematic for many of the same reasons for which capitalist production in large corporations is problematic. (And capitalist system which wouldn't have many large hierarchically controlled corporations doesn't exist.) My point is, there existed different systems of doing science, which weren't measured as much (to the extent that would cause overproduction of articles that no scientist has time to read), because they had different preference than "scientific efficacy by an objective metric". For example, preference for somebody being authority in a scientific field for life. Or preference for academia to be a place for outcasts. Or preference for democratic decision making about what to scientifically pursue. These are all non-capitalist preferences.
- satvikpendem 3y agoI agree. Every time I see such a phrase as "in a capitalist system," I ask whether it would not happen in a communist or socialist system as well, and in the vast majority of cases, it would, simply because human nature does not differ regardless of what layer is added on top at a societal level.
- godelski 3y agoYeah like I'm totally fine with the phrase when it is actually something that doesn't happen in a socialist system but it's just become a standin for "bad". But there's things that are bad that are divorce of capitalism and socialism. I mean... what I referred to is more a result of the human condition and specialization. And I'm not sure why every response is always followed up with a great assumption that I'm capitalist. I'll dunk on capitalism and I'll dunk on communism, but they aren't really related to the topic at hand and don't need to be ham fisted into everything. Weren't we literally complaining about politization and bureaucratization? Those definitely exist in literally all forms of governments, from anarchist to dictatorships. Can we just talk about the thing we're actually trying to talk about? SMH
- satvikpendem 3y agoExactly. It's just "capitalism = bad" now, there's no nuance of understanding of the pros and cons. Ultimately, human organization is the same everywhere and there will always be bureaucracy, as you say.