3 ms·
This insightful analysis describes a natural tendency, but we don't have to leave communities to their own devices. Look at the various mechanisms incorporated
by esafak 3y ago
This insightful analysis describes a natural tendency, but we don't have to leave communities to their own devices. Look at the various mechanisms incorporated into Slashdot, Wikipedia, and StackExchange to address these problems. Their design is what set them apart and above forums, whose quality was more sensitive to that of their moderators.
The next step is to devise mechanisms to counteract the decay. Does anyone know any literature on this subject? It could be about physical expert communities.
- kibwen 3y agoIf you want a sustainable community, then you need new members to counteract the inevitable loss of existing members. To get new members, you first need to help them find your community somehow, then you need to give them a reason to stay, then you need to have a process where the old guard can pass the torch to the new. For "helping them find your community", that means that you need to not be precious about the platform that you're currently on; you need to be where young people are. That means somehow convincing the old guard to be willing to change platforms to accommodate the possibility of new members. In practice this probably just means forking your community onto every new platform and convincing a sustainable core of experienced users to populate the new venue, leaving the rest behind; but forking small communities often means death as they lose the critical mass of users necessary for long-term appeal. For "giving them a reason to stay", that means that your community has to be welcoming to new users. But also, since new users will probably be young-ish, the topic of the community itself needs to be something that young people have a reason to care about. If you're a community of Victrola and vintage phonograph enthusiasts, I'm afraid you're not going to appeal to the youth no matter what you do; if your topic isn't perennially cool, then you might have already lost the battle for longevity. For "having a process to pass the torch", this means you need at least a little bit of a formal structure. If you have a forum, then who runs it, who sets the rules, who enforces the rules? If the answer is "one random guy", and then that random guy gets run over by a zeppelin, then you've lost. Basically, creating sustainable, long-lasting, intergenerational communities is extremely difficult. Anything that you come up with to solve the problem is going to start looking like either a religion or a bureaucracy.
- kiba 3y agoForums are perfectly fine and has been around forever.
- kibwen 3y agoI love forums, they're great. However, the number of forums that have persisted without declining for more than ten to fifteen years are utterly dwarfed by those that have faded away into nothingness. The longevity of digital spaces is not just a technical challenge, but a social challenge is as well.
- noirscape 3y agoWikipedia relies literally on "fuck you we are the first/sidebar result on Google" to keep a fresh editor flow. The moderation policy of Wikipedia literally states it's better to just indiscriminately ban all people in an argument because new users will inevitably show up to fix the issues in a more level-headed manner. Most communities do not have the luxury Wikipedia has. For most of them that approach is unsustainable.
- howenterprisey 3y ago>The moderation policy of Wikipedia literally states it's better to just indiscriminately ban all people in an argument because new users will inevitably show up to fix the issues in a more level-headed manner. I call... baloney? Which policy, may I ask?
- noirscape 3y agoTldr; it's a combination of wikipedia policies and practical execution; WP:SEALION lays it out in practical terms. ArbComm and Administrators are by design incapable of blocking users based on disputes over page content. This is fine on paper, but it has resulted in the side effect that if an argument arises, the main thing that Wikipedia ends up policing is less the accuracy of what's being edited (because no authority on Wikipedia may comment on that) but rather the civility of the editors involved. In practical terms, it's basically impossible to edit or comment on the site without breaking a policy somewhere - Wikipedia's massive list of policies and essays are self-contradicting, meaning that if you complain about a policy violation, a different editor can complain about you breaking another policy. This means that should a discussion get to the point where administrators (let alone ArbComm) has to be involved, the default outcome is basically that both involved parties will get sanctioned; ArbComm and ANI closure notes have openly stated in the past that they've just given a page/topic ban (or worse) by community consensus to all editors involved because "it might put fresh editors on the page instead". It's an issue further amplified by the Randy in Boise problem (aka the "fuck experts" policy), where a "sock" user can just behave in extremely polite and civil ways, yet says things that hold absolutely zero ground to the frustration of all involved. All with the goal of eventually escalating it to AN/I or ArbComm so that when their sock gets banned, at least the article is down an expert editor. Wikipedia largely gets away with this policy on the basis that they'll accrue new editors with time anyway.