4 ms·
Isn't something special about HN? I think so. First, it has survived for long. I don't know in the future but I was here since 2009 and it is a community that a
by wslh 3y ago
Isn't something special about HN? I think so. First, it has survived for long. I don't know in the future but I was here since 2009 and it is a community that always delight me. Not saying that you cannot find issues in HN but it continues to provide a lot of value.
I can compare with other communities that I participate. For example, some subreddits were incredible but "suddenly" something happened that changed the rules of the game and you find yourself as an alien when before you felt at home.
Most probably dang, the moderator, [1] adds a lot of value here?
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34920400 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34920400 | https://archive.is/czYVG https://archive.is/czYVG
- matheusmoreira 3y agoHN is special because of the people who participate in it. I see lots of actual hackers here. Lots of programmers, many employed at the big corporations, it gets to the point people joke about HN being their Google support channel. Lots of entrepeneurs. Lots of people from many other fields. Here you find comments from people who worked on stuff like Oracle database describing what that's like. The creator of an algorithm shows up to explain it. No idea if such things happen on other sites.
- baq 3y agoThis also happened on Reddit before it decided to IPO thus enshittify to the gills. Maybe it still happens, but I stopped going there.
- stuartjohnson12 3y agoI made a post asking something about Django and the creator of Django showed up and answered. The fact that's possible here when Django is a massive framework adopted by millions is such a great signal - the density of expertise on Hacker News is just remarkable.
- keyle 3y agoWhat keeps me coming back to HN is the value of the comments. When people actually add insight, whatever the quality of the article highlighted almost becomes secondary in value. That's why I recommend upvoting valuable comment "TIL", and actively sending down the yolo/kneejerks/meh/me2 comments that don't add value/different perspective, to keep the comment section valuable for the next gal/guy. If I don't agree, I tend to leave it alone... I value someone not agreeing if they have a point and bring a different perspective. It's ok to disagree, but always attack the argument, not the person! That's a healthy debate.
- PumpkinSpice 3y agoWell, HN isn't a forum with a well-defined "expert" scope. It's a link aggregator for nerdy news. If you get bored with Rust, you talk about ChatGPT. Or CPU design. Or biotech. Almost anything goes. I think this makes it immune to the patterns described in the article, although there are other ways for such communities to die. The decline of Slashdot is a cautionary tale.
- hliyan 3y agoMy theory is that a lot of the moderation happens privately and in a civil manner, with dang and others politely reaching out to first time offenders, explaining the nature of the forum and asking them to voluntarily edit their comments. This leads to three things: 1) Well-intentioned violators are more likely to respond positively (since the audience effect is not present) and modify their behaviour. 2) For new visitors, all members of the forum appear to be mature and self-regulating (since the moderation is invisible), and they tend to hold themselves to that high standard. 3) It is easy to detect bad-faith violators -- they are the ones who respond negatively to private moderator messages or continue to offend.
- vasco 3y agoSounds stupid but my favorite thing is the lack of jokes. Not having to scroll or collapse tree after tree of the same basic jokey pun comments is such a great feeling. Here on HN instead of collapsing jokes you need to collapse tree after tree of cynical rebuttals, which is still better.
- n6242 3y agoWhile I personally really enjoy jokes I agree that they can add a lot of noise in online communities. I'd love to find a bunch of other "serious only" communities for other topics I enjoy, I'd then read the no-jokes ones during breakfast and the joke-filled ones in the evening. But it seems quite unlikely, unless I build an extension that filters content based on sentiment analysis or something similar.
- Kye 3y agoI try to keep my jokes here a few levels above memes.[0] I save most of the puns for social media where they're appreciated. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38244086 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38244086
- krapp 3y agoOn the one hand I get it, but on the other hand, humor has a long and distinguished tradition within hacker and nerd culture, and a preference for the constant drivel of midwit cynicism and rancor over even a single joke out of a fear of being contaminated by "Redditness" is one of the more toxic aspects of this community.
- vasco 3y agoEveryone likes to laugh. The problem is that joking in real life during a whiteboarding session here and there in a lull or a in a difficult moment is a cut from the norm and everyone loves it. But in an online message board you have the problem that jokes are understood by everyone, whereas a deep insightful comment isn't understood by everyone, so jokes tend to go to the top, and people tend to cluster jokes on jokes in joke trees and suddenly what started as "a joke here and there lightens the mood up" turns into people trying to one-up each other on jokes instead of reading the damn article and sharing some actual insight. It's hard to control "how much" online. HN actually has lots of jokes in absolute numbers, usually only the best ones are tolerated, it's just that on a relative basis you won't enter a thread with 20 comments where 18 are jokes, which is what I would hate.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rft 3y ago> Isn't something special about HN? I think so. One of the core advantages of HN, imo, is the absence of any of the common monetization models. The site itself and the moderation are run by a company making money in another field. Of course HN serves a function for that company, at least marketing, recruiting and community building. But, HN is not optimized to keep me "engaged", because engagement leads to more ad impressions. Things like the noprocrast feature would never make it to Reddit etc. Another important difference is moderation is paid for and not based on volunteers. This means there is no regular way for someone to become a moderator and getting their own little fiefdom. For as long as I am following this site, dang has been the moderator here and with this consistency also comes consistency in decisions. Sure, dang does not set the tone directly, but at least we don't get "hostile takeovers" followed by a purge of supporters of the old moderation team. Maybe it is also the topics of HN. They are at the same time really niche, but also very broad. You can find deep dives on esoteric programming languages, some social/political issues, biology research papers, history and even some gaming here. Sure, all of these topics have dedicated subreddits, Discord servers or boards, but here we get all of these topics more or less in 30 links on a single page. Maybe having a space to interact with many different topics and thus people is what keeps this interesting. I don't know whether these things are due to something like a master plan or are just happy little accidents. No matter, it seems to work. P.S. some comments mention the lack/low amount of humor. I agree that meme spamming is not great, but I like that we occasionally get a bit of snark or sarcasm mixed in. And without any shiny medals like Reddit gold or a point score attached to such a comment, it is easy to just skip over.
- NoboruWataya 3y agoI think a big part of the problem is that maintaining an expert community is expensive. In addition to hosting costs, moderation in particular takes a lot of time and effort to ensure quality of contributions remains high. Eventually, the people who host such a community need to get paid one way or the other, otherwise they simply won't be able to keep it up. Such communities will eventually die due to poor moderation (because moderators aren't compensated, so don't bother moderating at all or are driven by ulterior motives such as ego) or due to attempts to monetise the platform which kill the user experience. In that context HN is different in that it has a lot of resources dedicated to it, including a very diligent moderator, without any apparent need for the site to break even or turn a profit. I'm not sure how YC views HN in the context of their business model, but it seems that HN is effectively subsidised by its broader business which IMO is why it has managed to thrive for so long.