4 ms·
The real question is more why it became popular anywhere else. Currency denominations seem to be efficient* when they follow roughly half-an-order-of-manitude
by crazygringo 3y ago
The real question is more why it became popular anywhere else.
Currency denominations seem to be efficient* when they follow roughly half-an-order-of-manitude increases -- e.g. $0.05 to $0.25 to $1 to $5 to $20 to $100.
Adding mere doublings in there just complicates things for no good reason. There's already no particularly good functional reason for dimes or $10 bills, except we seem to want a denomination for every power of 10 -- it's more of an aesthetic thing.
But there's absolutely no practical reason for a $2. There's no functional reason and no aesthetic reason either.
* Finding a practical balance between carrying a minimal number of bills for any given total value (where powers of 2 would win), versus minimizing infrastructure like sizes of cash registers (where powers of 10 would save space in layout).
(Edit: maybe the case is different for heavy coins though? E.g. $10 in $2 coins will weigh significantly less than in $1 coins in your pocket. On the other hand, the US already mainly uses bills for $1, which is why $2 makes no sense in the US.)
- epolanski 3y agoI don't know, we have 2€ coins and they aren't such of an issue, they are handy.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoWould it be any less useful if the coin were 2,5 Euros?
- epolanski 3y agoIt would definitely complicate mental math for most people.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoHow so? Prices are rarely fixed even integers so people are used to floats anyway.
- epolanski 3y agoYou need to understand how people do math mentally, especially cashiers. When someone pays, say 6.80 euros and gives you a 10 what virtually every cashier does is: - tell you it's 6.80 - add 20 cents to get to 7 and put them on the table while saying "seven" - add 1 euro to get to 8 and put them on the table saying "eight" - add 2 euros to get to 10, put them on the table "and ten, thank you good bye" Now add 2.50 euros to the mix. It gets complex and slower which is what you want to avoid when counting money. Same reason why we have 1, 2, 5, 10, 20, 50c coins but no 25c one. Some shops have the machines do the calculation and even give you the change automatically, but that's not most of the businesses, it's more common in supermarkets than say a diner, a gas station or your auntie's garage.
- mlyle 3y agoImagine if Coke had gotten their way and had gotten a 7.5 cent coin issued in the US...
- crazygringo 3y ago> Same reason why we have 1, 2, 5, 10, 20, 50c coins but no 25c one. I guess that's why it doesn't seem difficult for anyone in the US -- we have $0.25 coins but not $0.20 ones (nor $0.50 ones in common usage), and I've simply never heard of anyone saying that thought quarters made anything more complex or slower. It's just a non-issue. But it's also funny that in the US you don't really see anybody counting change the way you're demonstrating -- it seems backwards. Like, first you calculate the change, and then you count out the change. If it's $0.40 in change, then it's a quarter and a dime and a nickel without even thinking about it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mlyle 3y ago1 to 5 is .7 orders of magnitude; 1 to 2 is 0.3; both are roughly equidistant from half an order of magnitude. Clearly we need $1, $3, $9, $27 bills ;) An interesting thing to think about is-- assuming the distribution of transaction values follows a power law-- where's the point of diminishing returns on having more denominations? I know this isn't well-posed; we'd also have to quantify the downside in having more denominations.
- dasyatidprime 3y agoExactly equidistant, in fact. 5×2 = 10 ∴ log(5) + log(2) = log(10) ∴ 0.5log(10) − log(2) = log(5) − 0.5log(10).
- mlyle 3y agoGood point-- I should have thought that through a little more :)
- jltsiren 3y agoThe 1, 2, 5 scheme is simple and consistent. You use the same algorithm for giving back change, regardless of the sum. There are other similar schemes, but 1, 2, 5 seems to be the most popular. The US scheme, on the other hand, is unnecessarily complex. For some weird reason, there are $0.25 coins but $20 bills. For the sake of consistency and simplicity, one of them should be replaced by either a $0.20 coin or a $25 bill.
- hakfoo 3y agoThe reason is that the US dollar was originally based on the Spanish coins of the time. This meant that they had a lot of 8-real coins in circulation that could pass for $1, and 2-real coins that passed for 25c. People got used to that model, so as "real" American coinage scaled up, it continued to be in the 25c denomination. A 20c coin was tried to great failure in the 1870s. There was a $2.50 gold coin issued for most of the era when gold coins were issued for circulation. I note the 1-5 only scheme is fairly common too: Japan and South Korea went there (with both having a 2000 denomination note as a limited run commemorative); Russia went that way for their 1998 currency reform, but more recently added a 200 and 2000.
- jorvi 3y ago> Currency denominations seem to be efficient* when they follow roughly half-an-order-of-manitude increases -- e.g. $0.05 to $0.25 to $1 to $5 to $20 to $100. Thanks but no. I’m not gonna carry around four bills ($5 x2, $20 x2) if I just want to carry $50.
- crazygringo 3y agoWhy would you need to carry $50 exactly? You'd just carry three $20's. Cashiers and stores hate it when you break $50's anyways.
- cameldrv 3y agoBy that argument though the $20 should also not be popular and we should just use $10s and $50s, but the $20 is very common and the default bill given out at ATMs.