4 ms·
Why did US $2 bill fail to become commonplace, unlike in Canada and elsewhere?
- n1b0m 3y agoDue to a mistaken belief that they might be valuable as collector's items which results in them being hoarded and so not widely circulated.
- ksaj 3y agoThat's like 50c coins. Both USA and Canada have them, but they tend to be collected instead of spent. Afaik they have only ever kept their worth at 50c.
- jareklupinski 3y agoi wonder what the economic impact was of all those 50 State Quarters books kept in people's closets
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y agoIt was pretty fun as a younger kid to go find these as they were minted and add them to the book. My grandmother still has ours in some closet somewhere.
- crazygringo 3y agoThe real question is more why it became popular anywhere else. Currency denominations seem to be efficient* when they follow roughly half-an-order-of-manitude increases -- e.g. $0.05 to $0.25 to $1 to $5 to $20 to $100. Adding mere doublings in there just complicates things for no good reason. There's already no particularly good functional reason for dimes or $10 bills, except we seem to want a denomination for every power of 10 -- it's more of an aesthetic thing. But there's absolutely no practical reason for a $2. There's no functional reason and no aesthetic reason either. * Finding a practical balance between carrying a minimal number of bills for any given total value (where powers of 2 would win), versus minimizing infrastructure like sizes of cash registers (where powers of 10 would save space in layout). (Edit: maybe the case is different for heavy coins though? E.g. $10 in $2 coins will weigh significantly less than in $1 coins in your pocket. On the other hand, the US already mainly uses bills for $1, which is why $2 makes no sense in the US.)
- epolanski 3y agoI don't know, we have 2€ coins and they aren't such of an issue, they are handy.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoWould it be any less useful if the coin were 2,5 Euros?
- epolanski 3y agoIt would definitely complicate mental math for most people.
- FirmwareBurner 3y agoHow so? Prices are rarely fixed even integers so people are used to floats anyway.
- epolanski 3y agoYou need to understand how people do math mentally, especially cashiers. When someone pays, say 6.80 euros and gives you a 10 what virtually every cashier does is: - tell you it's 6.80 - add 20 cents to get to 7 and put them on the table while saying "seven" - add 1 euro to get to 8 and put them on the table saying "eight" - add 2 euros to get to 10, put them on the table "and ten, thank you good bye" Now add 2.50 euros to the mix. It gets complex and slower which is what you want to avoid when counting money. Same reason why we have 1, 2, 5, 10, 20, 50c coins but no 25c one. Some shops have the machines do the calculation and even give you the change automatically, but that's not most of the businesses, it's more common in supermarkets than say a diner, a gas station or your auntie's garage.
- mlyle 3y agoImagine if Coke had gotten their way and had gotten a 7.5 cent coin issued in the US...
- pizzafeelsright 3y agoIt's a half measure. We need full notes and permit quarter notes. Even half notes exist but are rarely used.
- keep_reading 3y agoCanada doesn't have a $2 bill it has a coin. This isn't a good comparison. We shouldn't have $1 or $2 bills because they fall out of circulation too fast, but everybody interested in this topic knows it already. It's bizarre how antiquated our cash is and how there is no appetite for removing the penny from circulation either. I really thought we were going to pursue this like 20 years ago but nope... our government is too dysfunctional for even these types of changes
- tredre3 3y agoCanada withdrew its $2 bill in 1996 (when it introduced the coin) but it was still pretty common until 2000. Canada also withdrew its penny in 2012. There's been talks of withdrawing the 5c coin recently but I doubt it will happen soon.
- cherrycherry98 3y agoThat and the need to introduce large denomination bills. The $100 bill has been the largest in circulation since 1969 while it's buying power has significantly reduced due to inflation. $100 in 1969 is over $800 inflation adjusted dollars. Our government seems insistent on phasing out cash in favor of digital mechanisms they can track more easily.
- avidiax 3y agoRelated: What This Country Needs is an 18¢ Piece[1] [1] https://cs.uwaterloo.ca/~shallit/Papers/change2.pdf https://cs.uwaterloo.ca/~shallit/Papers/change2.pdf
- ianburrell 3y agoOne reason is that registers don't have a spot for $2. It sounds like they have slots for $1, $5, $10, $20. The result is that people never get $2 as change. Which means that they never circulate. Any $2 that are spent are sent to the bank.
- calamari4065 3y agoEvery register I've seen has five unlabeled slots for bills and five trays for coins. That usually means you have a slot for 1s, 5s, 10s, 20s, then everything else. Coins are the same: 1, 5, 10, 25, then whatever else shows up.
- hiatus 3y agoWhen I worked the register, we would put 50s in the extra slot, and hundreds went below. Commingling different denominations in a single slot sounds like a mistake waiting to occur.
- inglor_cz 3y agoTo be frank, I don't understand why the USD 1 bill exists either. In Europe, we tend to have coins up to the value of approximately USD 2, included. The eurozone obviously has 1 and 2 euro coin. Czechia has 20 CZK and 50 CZK coin. Poland is slightly bucking the trend, because 5 PLN is a coin (of value more than 1 USD), but 10 PLN is already a bill. Bulgarian has 1 BGN and 2 BGN coins... Coins can take a lot more daily use than paper money, and are handy to use in parking automats etc. I wonder of one of the reasons for this difference is that US WCs tend to be free? Toilets are paid in much of Europe, and you generally use a suitable coin for access, though lately some of the facilities started accepting contactless cards as well. Paying for a toilet with a bill would be very impractical. That is a frequent use case in Europe, which necessitates existence of suitable coins. But in the US, this use case seems to be rare, if extant at all.
- MarkusWandel 3y agoOne thing about these free washrooms is that they're hard to find, they're often dirty, and a lot of them have restrictive opening hours. Frankly paying a small sum for use, and finding reliable, clean facilities might be a good tradeoff. As for coins being useful for parking, around here (Canada) we've already moved beyond the pay-and-display machines (which don't even accept cash) to - horrors - a sign with a QR code. Nothing worse than wanting to do a quick 15 minute stop to show visitors something, scanning the QR code and being greeted with an account signup page that demands a ton of information. But cash? Hardly used at all any more. The only US$2 bill I've ever encountered - and of course I kept it as a souvenir - was in the change for a $5 in Tanzania, of all places. The Plattsburgh ferry used to give either 50 cent or $1 coins in change for $10 - this dates me! The pre-loonie Canadian $1 coins obviously never gained any collector value. I got a sheet of a whole bunch of different years at a garage sale for face value!
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoYou'll get paid bathrooms but they will be just as dirty lol.
- hakfoo 3y ago
- pupppet 3y agoPersonally I don’t love the $1/2 coins. Bills are better for those of us who only carry a wallet.
- hnbear 3y agoMoving from the UK to the US I found the loss of the pound coins to be quite annoying. I was used to paper currency and coins both having more significant value. A handful/pocketful of change in the UK, where there are 50p,£1, and £2 is generally worth about£5. Similarly cash in my wallet is typically worth £20+. Moving to the US I found that coins are basically worthless. To carry $5 you need a lot of them. And a small bill selection can be anywhere from $5 to $500. Being all the same size and color makes it even harder to assess quickly. Of course, now I don't carry much of either and just Apple Pay for everything.
- jackcosgrove 3y ago> Of course, now I don't carry much of either and just Apple Pay for everything. I think this sums up the discussion.
- laurencerowe 3y agoI’ve had the same experience. It was especially frustrating when my previous landlord replaced the washer and dryer and made them payable. A full load took 18 coins (1x wash and 2x dry at $1.50 each) because there are only quarters. Really annoying given it was a $3000/month apartment!
- drpgq 3y agoI remember hearing as a kid that $2 bills in weren't popular in Western Canada as that was the common price prostitutes charged and the stigma stuck around.
- the-dude 3y agoSteve Wozniak likes his $2 bills.
- happytiger 3y agoThey were really hard to get. We used to special order them from my local bank for fun; they make fantastic origami rings and I loved giving them to kids. But they were actually challenging to find. So, in my mind, that’s why they weren’t popular: they weren’t really distributed like other currencies. Akhams razor.
- phanimahesh 3y agoOccams razor. Though it doesn't apply here. It just begs the question of why they weren't distributed well, which can be answered with "because nobody uses them". It's a circular logic that can not be broken from within. We need other, better reasons to consider the question answered.
- happytiger 3y agoSorry for the typo.