4 ms·
I'm having some trouble with the idea that all of that heat is going to go back into space. I can see my neighbor's roof. If I can see it, that means that it's
by hinkley 3y ago
I'm having some trouble with the idea that all of that heat is going to go back into space.
I can see my neighbor's roof. If I can see it, that means that it's radiating in all directions, not just into space.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- ummonk 3y agoIt doesn't need to go back into space. If you don't want the scattered sunlight to heat your house, you can always add the same ceramic to your house...
- hinkley 3y agoI'm pretty sure that doesn't work. The surface works because it's emitting a band of radiation that the atmosphere is mostly transparent to. If it sees radiation in that same band it's going to absorb it, not emit. Point enough of these at each other and you'll approach zero.
- zmgsabst 3y agoSure — but how visible is the roof from above versus the sides? It’ll expel that fraction to space regardless of its neighbors.
- hinkley 3y agoLess than 70% on non-commercial structures. And on commercial structures the roof can be a negligible percentage of the total building envelope. This is cool stuff, but it’s just stuff. It’s not a silver bullet. We here are all old enough, many of us by half, to no longer get sucked in by magic thinking.
- ummonk 3y agoThe material works by having very low emissivity / absorptivity at sunlight wavelength so that sunlight is scattered back out, and by having high emissivity at typical earth temperature blackbody peak wavelength, so it radiates out heat effectively. Sunlight that is scattered off the roof can scatter back off other roofs before heading into space. Likewise radiation that is emitted by the roof can be absorbed and then re-emitted by other roofs before heading off into space. Neither of these preclude the roof from doing its job. At the end of the day, the roof will effectively reflect back sunlight from the high temperature sun, while radiating infrared radiation into the low temperature sky, and have a neutral energy balance with the surrounding earth / houses / trees / objects which are at a similar temperature to it.
- deathanatos 3y ago> Sunlight that is scattered off the roof can scatter back off other roofs before heading into space. … but that's not what they're asking about? Imagine you're standing in a second story window, looking out. Out the window, you're seeing your neighbor's roof, coated with this stuff. A lot of sun is hitting that roof — How much heat is coming in through that window, off that roof? There have been stories in the past of reflective surfaces cooking nearby apartments, so I get the concern. I think in this case it boils down to it not being reflective, mostly, so it's fine.
- hinkley 3y agoYou’re missing the point here. Almost willfully so. Two pieces of this material in an overlapping field of reflection are putting out exactly the wavelength the other will absorb. I can’t defend my building from being baked by yours by coating it with the same stuff. I am simply going to return the favor in the process. Not to mention the big problem of creating a new case of the haves versus the have-nots.
- powersnail 3y ago> If I can see it, that means that it's radiating in all directions, not just into space That depends on what you mean by "see". If you paint a square on a white paper with a magical paint that absorb 100% of the light, you can still see that there's a black square, because it's sitting on a contrasting background. Even if the material is perfectly radiating everything to space, i.e., the roof sends no light to your eyes, it's still just a patch of blackness among normal things, and you can see the shape of it, just like a puddle on the road at night, as you walk with your back to the moon.
- deathanatos 3y agoI'd imagine it's (total amount of sunlight hitting the visible portion of that roof) * (… the solid angle the window occupies, relative to the roof?) The first portion of that equation is hot: roofs have a lot of sq. ft.'age, and a fair bit of sunlight strikes them. But the second part is well the other direction: the window probably doesn't occupy a whole lot of the field of view of the roof: i.e., mostly, any ray emitted randomly from any point on the roof is likely going to be skyward, so assuming it emits the heat/light out equally in all directions, your window only gets a small fraction. The portion coming in your window doesn't go back out to space but I don't think that's a big deal?
- calamari4065 3y agoIt's about the angle of reflection. When light reflects off a surface, it leaves at an angle equal to the angle it comes in at. Most of the light hitting the roof will be reflected back up into space. Some small percentage of it will scatter and disperse into all other directions. If you were in a plane at exactly the right angle between the roof and the sun, you'd see a glare much stronger than you'd see at street level.
- p1mrx 3y agoThat problem can be solved by adding a mirrored ring around the cooling surface, so it can only "see" the sky: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zW9_ztTiw8&t=404s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zW9_ztTiw8&t=404s
- lolc 3y agoThe bulk of the roof can be assumed to be oriented to the sky, or it wouldn't get much sun and be of no concern. So it will radiate towards the sky mostly. The infrared radiation will indeed go out in all directions. The way I understood it there will be less of it, because the roof is cooler. So if this material replaces a traditional surface, you will get more visible light scattered your way, and less infrared light.
- 4gotunameagain 3y agoGoogle "diffuse reflection" and "specular reflection" if you're interested to understand why. Things do not radiate uniformly, neither behave like mirrors (specular). The truth for most objects is somewhere in between. You can see it with a plastic object as well, when it is positioned so that the angle to the normal vector (a vector perpendicular to the surface) of the light source and to your eye are the same (as in, you would be able to see the light source if it were a mirror), you see much more light than when you are simply looking at it "from the side".