5 ms·
The unbelievable part of Red Dawn was the notion that the US could be taken over by a surprise attack of paratroopers. The largest paratrooper operation was the
by WalterBright 3y ago
The unbelievable part of Red Dawn was the notion that the US could be taken over by a surprise attack of paratroopers. The largest paratrooper operation was the Allied invasion of Normandy, and the paratroopers' job was to soften things up for the main invasion force.
- dylan604 3y agoAgain, the original had them mainly coming over the border with Mexico. Nothing about the remake was any good. Nothing. Even the remade War Games sucked less than Red Dawn
- WalterBright 3y agoThere are so many good books that have never been made into movies, I'm baffled at the impetus to make bad movie remakes.
- justinclift 3y agoBooks are notoriously hard to make into movies though. Can be done, but often the cuts and changes are so drastic that the movie (or tv series) becomes just a shell of the book.
- dylan604 3y agoYet some of the better movies made were based on a book. You really need a screenwriter just as good (if not better) as the author of the book to make it really happen.
- WalterBright 3y agoShort stories are well suited to turning into movies.
- dylan604 3y agoMy favorite Stephen King adaptations were from his shorts vs novels. Shawshank and Stand By Me are deserted island movies for me. But I agree, short stories are just long enough to put a concept out there with just enough to establish characters, motives, plots, yet leave enough room to expand on for the movie version without conflicts from deviating from canon.
- neilv 3y agoThe strategy was to first secure the rural high school, and then the cows would be defenseless. But "Red Dawn" (1984) did have some redeeming qualities as a film, and apparently it was influential in at least one way... Circa '96, I was talking with grad student from the former USSR (attending a US Ivy university), and I got the impression that the film had been taken more seriously there than it was here. Like they thought it was some influential propaganda that people in the US fervently believed: the Communists will invade the heartland of America, and you should prepare to engage in guerilla warfare with your guns. On second thought, I suppose it's possible some people did get that message, especially some demographic of gun-enthusiasts. IIRC, the movie has the invaders getting the list of registered gun owners, which sounds like a sensitive policy question. But I'd wildly guess only 50/50 chance that any US student at the Ivy in '96 had seen the '84 movie, though they would've had about the right age overlap.