5 ms·
My problem with GIMP is that there's too many ways to access controls and some controls only appear in certain menus. You've got the iconographic tool picker wh
by calamari4065 3y ago
My problem with GIMP is that there's too many ways to access controls and some controls only appear in certain menus. You've got the iconographic tool picker which has submenus on right-click for some tools. Then there's the classic menu ribbon at the top which has most things you expect. Then there's the right-click context menu inside the canvas that has a subset of all other menu items. And then you have inscrutable hotkeys. Some actions are reasonable, others are not. There's too many hotkey layers with modifier keys and some actions which should be on the same layer are not.
Then there's the escape key. Sometimes it does what you want, other times it just gives you an error ding with no other information.
The core problem with GIMP is that the interface is bad. No two ways about it, it's just bad. It needs a total redesign, but that would be unacceptable as it would alienate evryobe who has already learned it.
As an editing program, GIMP does everything you need and then some. It's fully featured and functional, just not usable.
That said, GIMP is still my only choice for photo editing. All the other options are worse in different and mostly worse ways.
- TylerE 3y agoI’d say it’s biggest core issue, even more that the UI, is that it’s basically harecoded to work with generic RGB. No native CMYK or good support for color management.
- prokoudine 3y ago> basically harecoded to work with generic RGB The days of that are numbered.
- prmoustache 3y agoYou are contradicting yourself. If it is your only choice, it means it is usable. Is it without fault, no. Usable yes.
- fsckboy 3y agothe way I used to crop photos they moved/broke, so now I have mypaint installed so I can use it for cropping. Then I switch back to gimp. It's used, but not usable, a bit like a used car.
- prokoudine 3y ago> the way I used to crop photos they moved/broke Out of curiosity, what's that? Are you by any chance referring to the option that allows not removing cropped pixels? Well, it's an option. You can disable it.
- prmoustache 3y agoThat analogy doesn't really work.