3 ms·
Some people, given $1000 a month, would move to locations where rent is less than $1000. There are still lots of those, but they are in locations without jobs
by bryanlarsen 3y ago
Some people, given $1000 a month, would move to locations where rent is less than $1000. There are still lots of those, but they are in locations without jobs. Lots of people are originally from those low rent locations and would like the opportunity to move back. So if UBI makes people more mobile and able to move to find low rent apartments, it limits the ability of landlords to raise rent.
- underseacables 3y agoSome people, given $1000 a month, would move to locations where rent is less than $1000. With all due respect, you don't know that. What's for certain is that it would increase money supply in the economic system. Everything else is pure supposition.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoWhat's for certain is that it would increase money supply With all due respect, you don't know that. The more well thought out UBI systems are fiscally balanced. They increase taxes enough to pay for UBI. The average taxpayer would receive a tax increase for the same amount as the UBI they receive. People with less than average income would see a smaller tax increase and Bill Gates would see his taxes go up by much more than the UBI he would receive.
- underseacables 3y agoYou just use the words fiscally balanced when describing the American economy. Specifically handing money out. The country cannot even pass single spending bills, you have no idea if it would be fiscally balanced or not. UBI is like communism, it hasn't worked anywhere it's been tried, and would still require taking money from one group and giving it to another. In the past, when the government hasn't been able to do that, they just print more.
- bryanlarsen 3y ago> they just print more. No they don't. They borrow more. Similar effect, but more accurate and a very different connotation.
- underseacables 3y agoBut from whom do they borrow more, now you're talking about increasing the national debt. There's no way UBI can actually function or work without harming the system. It's a pipe, dream man, if you want money work for it
- listenallyall 3y agoBut you just a described a scenario where demand increases in these locations. It enhances, not limits, the ability to raise rent prices.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoPeople moving from an expensive city to a poor city do not increase overall demand -- letting go of an apartment in a rich city to rent one in an inexpensive city does not effect overall demand. But what does have an impact on prices is the elasticity of demand. If you're willing and able to move to get a cheaper apartment you increase elasticity of demand, lowering prices. OTOH, if you're stuck in your apartment because it's the only one close to your job...
- listenallyall 3y agoRents are regional, "overall" (by which I assume you mean either national or global) demand is irrelevant. If the government provides a program that incents people to move to low-COL areas (low, because there are no employment opportunities), rents in those areas will increase.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoAnd, more significantly, rents in the high-COL areas will decrease. net win.
- listenallyall 3y agoThat's simply incorrect. Imagine 5000 people decide to leave Manhattan (1.6 million) to move to beautiful Saratoga Springs (28,000). It will have no noticeable effect on Manhattan rents, but will vastly increase Saratoga rents. It's amplified because people who were forced to share a housing unit in Manhattan due to economics can live alone thanks to lower COL in Saratoga combined with the government subsidy. So total housing demand increases. This phenomenon is clearly demonstrated every summer when people flood Saratoga during racing season, and every hotel room and Airbnb doubles, maybe triples, in price. Your entire hypothesis relies on you being blind (by choice, it appears) to some easily-observable realities of the world.