4 ms·
The UBI should be inadequate
- suoduandao2 3y agoBack when 15$/hour minimum wage was being widely argued for, I always thought 7.50 min wage and 7.50 UBI would be a much better proposal. Much more minimum wage jobs worth creating at that point, and no disincentive to do them.
- saithier 3y agoWhy should my tax dollars subsidize businesses who don't want to provide enough incentive for people to come work for them? I'm all for a UBI, but it should be enough to live on, and not (effectively) just the government paying wages on behalf of companies who don't want to pay for labor.
- Pet_Ant 3y ago> not (effectively) just the government paying wages on behalf of companies who don't want to pay for labor Well the arguments is that there are jobs that aren't worth doing at the current minimum wage. Imagine someone working in a garage who might be willing to hire someone for a $2/hr to fetch tools for them, but at $15/hr they would just rather get up and walk across the shop themselves. $2/hr is enough to cover transportation to work, so the UBI is used to bridge that gap. There are existing programs like this now for the developmentally handicapped. One of the main divisions of UBI is whether we require people to work no matter how demeaning (informed by the protestant work ethic) or whether it should guarantee people a certain level of dignity (informed by social welfare mindset). Not taking sides, but this is a schism that everyone in these conversations should be aware of.
- phmqk76 3y agoSure. Along with price controls, so companies pass the savings onto consumers, instead of just making obscene profits, right?
- suoduandao2 3y agoI'd see that as a separate issue and not be in favour of holding one good reform hostage by demanding another.
- MrStonedOne 3y agoGiving poor people a thousand a month caused them to get more jobs. Giving them 6k up front caused them to get even more jobs.[0] Author's argument is invalid. Percentage of Participants Working Full-time, Enrollment and 6-month Follow-up:[1] Group A (1000usd/m): 18% -> 25% Group B (6500usd one time + 500usd/m): 21% -> 35% Group C (50usd/m): 22% -> 22% [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37836296 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37836296 [1]: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gqtOfZG2sSanWgUdzn-lx-pwSXZKabj-/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gqtOfZG2sSanWgUdzn-lx-pwSXZ... page 22 (pdf page 23) figure 9
- ethanbond 3y agoIt’ll be inadequate no matter what because an area that institutes a UBI of $x will simply see their rent rise by $x.
- kurthr 3y agoIt's worse than that as long as they can loan you money to cover this weeks debts at high rates and soon enough garnish all of your UBI. It would end up a wealth transfer to payday "financial institutions", if you allow debt. If you don't allow debt, is it really income?
- Pet_Ant 3y ago> I am in favor of a Universal Basic Income (UBI) to replace the status quo of benefits, including Medicaid, food stamps, housing subsidies, etc. But I want the UBI to be a relatively small amount, something like $750 a month for a family of three. Okay, but it's not basic income if it can't cover the basics. That's just a subsidy. I mean that's not even rent. Let alone healthcare. A basic income allows a basic life allows for people to take more risks and start new businesses. If you are really against people being able to not work, than instead of UBI you want to support Employer of Last Resort. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employer_of_last_resort https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Employer_of_last_resort
- fsckboy 3y agoIf you were going to invest your own money in somebody for them to start a business, would you choose somebody who had been living off government handouts, or somebody who had gotten a job, worked a job, and thus learned something about how a company operates? which resume looks better to you? What if they actually worked a job in the field they wanted to start the company in? If you want to see more such resumes, what incentives should the government offer for resume building?
- spicyusername 3y agoI'm not necessarily against UBI, who doesn't want to eliminate poverty, but I have trouble understanding how it doesn't immediately result in price inflation of the goods and services most consumed by those at the lower end of the income spectrum. For example, if everyone is given an additional $1,000 / month, would most of that not immediately get captured by landlords through inflated rental prices for low-income rental units? Wouldn't it be the same story for used cars? etc? UBI doesn't magically increase the supply of goods / services, only the demand for them, right?
- EarthAmbassador 3y agoInflation isn’t simply driven up by supply but also greed. It is highly important to remember economics is snake oil for the lost part. As short a time as a few years ago, the Nobel Prize was awarded for work proving wage increases did it limit jobs, as was claimed for generations. One would think this had been proven long ago, but that’s not the case. It’s propaganda. Indeed, a great deal of the economic orthodoxy is little more than propaganda. All economic notions should be considered such until proven beyond a doubt. And it probably would be a good thing to track how wrong is the nonsense of people like Kudrow and Summers, yet they are trotted out as gospel constantly. Jamie Dimon too.
- jonathankoren 3y agoHe’s right that means testing is wasteful and can create disincentives, but the premise that it should be “inadequate” is not only antithetical to the very idea of UBI, but is grounded in an unfounded belief that people will just lay about instead of engaging in productive and enriching activities. That’s simply isn’t true. We know that’s not true because we’ve run multiple real world experiments. Mix in the the laughably misguided idea that charities will somehow fill in the gap, and you get the classic motivated reasoning with some straight line graphs that have dominated economics until very very recently. But hey. I welcome the Overton window shift.
- moomin 3y agoThis is, bluntly, dumb. The only way you can justify having UBI be below poverty is if you don’t accept any of the philosophy or studies of how UBI actually works and stick with the long-since disproven approach of “let people starve”. Geo-politically, you can’t outcompete China to the bottom, stop trying. And stop incentivising firms to drive their employees into poverty.
- 6510 3y agoIt would probably be a good transitional tool. We can start with 50 per month, it is enough to do the organization of it and end that part of the debate (both real and imagined) When in place it is really easy to increase it to 100, 250 etc
- wwarner 3y agoThe author is saying that reducing benefits is good because it will force people into marriage and into the very lowest tier of the job market. Kind of a terrible idea.
- tomatocracy 3y agoThis article is not really about UBI at all but about "cliff-edge" withdrawal of benefits. And it's pretty uncontroversial in the point it makes there.
- phmqk76 3y agoThe author’s thesis is to give every family (not person) $750 a month, and that eliminates all benefits including Medicaid. This isn’t a serious proposal, it’s Paul Ryan-style dismantling the social safety net rebranded as UBI. Just more Welfare For Me, Nothing For Thee so-called “fiscal conservativism”, the likes of which brought us budget-busting tax cuts for the wealthy, and austerity for the rest of us.
- underseacables 3y agoA UBI will always be detrimental to the overall economic system. Any additional money in the system, such as the massive amount of quantitative easing done during the pandemic, will cause inflation in the market. A UBI will also be erased by the market responding to an increase in the available money in the system. Why shouldn't a car dealer increase its price by however much the UBI is? Why would any business leave money on the table? Any mandated extra income to people will be negated by an increase in things like rent, commodities, cars, everything. A UBI is nothing more than a wealth transfer that has no long term viability, just as a political football. Who doesn't want free money? Vote for me and I'll make sure you get free money.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoAgain with the "The best life is one of grinding labor". We should recognize the Protestant Work Ethic when it is used as a blunt instrument, and call it out. In the 1950's, Science Fiction was all about how robots were going to lift the yoke of labor from our shoulders and let us live our better lives. Now that it's happening (automation taking over almost everything) we see panicky wrongheaded articles like this one, that cannot imagine a world where not everybody has to sweat for their daily bread.
- latestthing 3y agoVery good points. Thanks.
- EarthAmbassador 3y agoThe Horatio Alger school do economics. All BS, all the time, but orthodoxy nonetheless and the basis of conservative and libertarian economic thinking.