6 ms·
What if psychedelics' hallucinations are just a side effect?
- andsoitis 3y agohttps://archive.ph/2023.11.11-051613/https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2023/11/non-hallucinogenic-psychedelic-clinical-therapy/675942/ https://archive.ph/2023.11.11-051613/https://www.theatlantic...
- simbolit 3y agoThe central bit: "psychedelics are silently doing something even more remarkable than warping reality: They are rapidly inducing a state of neuroplasticity, in which the brain can more easily reorganize its structure and function. (...) For the first time, researchers have purposively developed psychedelic drugs that appear to bring about neuroplastic effects without producing a trip. These drugs stimulate the same serotonin receptor as traditional psychedelics (...) nontrip psychedelics will have at least one major advantage over their trip-inducing analogs: They can more easily be placebo-tested. Classic psychedelic research has been bedeviled by the simple fact that it is virtually impossible not to know that you are taking a classic psychedelic"
- davidw 3y ago> the brain can more easily reorganize its structure and function What's that actually mean? That sounds like something with lasting effects...?
- simbolit 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroplasticity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroplasticity
- hiddencost 3y agoThat's the idea. It's why you encounter many people who talk about therapeutic applications of psychedelics.
- haswell 3y agoIn short, it often is. People who experience ongoing depression, especially when associated with long term/complex trauma, are essentially fighting against the structure of their brain. The deeply ingrained defense mechanisms brought about by complex trauma were installed gradually and repeatedly (or suddenly and violently for other forms of trauma). Establishing new patterns of thought is possible but slow and sometimes excruciating. The possibility that psychedelics can put the brain in a state from which it can reform its conception of these events in a shorter period of time than traditional therapy is pretty incredible, and one of the reasons I’ve personally gotten very interested in this space. There was a point after years of traditional therapy when I started to realize and understand I’m safe and can’t be hurt by events of the past. But even though I deeply “get it”, and this is a kind of victory on its own, my ever-active brain just keeps churning away, running the subroutines beat into me (sometimes literally) from an early age, and this manifests as anxiety and depression. It’s a frustrating place to operate from. Aware of why my nervous system does what it does, but often powerless to prevent it. Psychedelics seem to offer a much better chance of integrating these events.
- tpmoney 3y agoThe analogy I heard recently was a brain with chronic depression/trauma is something like a car with a bad engine. It is repairable and fixable, but it's a lot of work to tear everything down, and lots of times trying to fix or replace one thing snowballs into many things (e.g. you shear a rusty bolt, or as long as you have the timing belt out, you really ought to do the water pump). Other times you really need to address the broken rod before you can do anything else, but to get there you need to tear the whole engine down. The problem is, you can't just tear your brain apart into individual pieces and leave it scattered across your garage as you work on each piece one at a time. Every new counseling session, every new day you're starting over and tearing down things and then when you're done, when you have to get back to the day to day of life, you have to put it all back together and hope it gets you through to the next one. Psychedelics seem to give you a very brief window where you whole brain is just sort of "exploded" like a giant parts diagram. And you can poke at and work on one part at a time without all the tear down and without having to do all the other pieces because they just all got out of the way. It's not as good as if we could just tear everything down and do a complete rebuild over the course of a week. But given what we have, when things are really entangled and overlapping, it's a better / faster approach.
- yieldcrv 3y ago>> They can more easily be placebo-tested yes, please! psychonauts communities can be insufferable without this component. “oh you had a side affect? you should have known you have a history of such and such in your family, the drugs are perfect stop talking!” would love basic studies with control groups and hypothesis
- hluska 3y agoYou’re participating in the wrong communities. Bad people do bad things regardless of what tribe they belong to.
- rokkitmensch 3y agoAnd every cult has idiots.
- yieldcrv 3y agoFor a movement that loves the empathy improvements from their drugs, the phrasing here is lacking that and is still Exhibit A of invalidating and minimizing, not even an example of a community that does it better. Edit: Additional capitalization added for the maturity goal post, let’s see if it pays off.
- hluska 3y agoI haven’t taken a psychedelic since I was thirty. Do you think a recommendation for communities I haven’t been a part of for nearly twenty years will be of any use? And finally, if you want to try to insult someone on the internet at least have the courtesy of using capital letters. I can’t expect maturity or even following the spirit of this site. But can I at least expect the most basic part of the written language?
- yieldcrv 3y agoWhy do you feel qualified to invalidate and minimize if you aren’t a part of any community in question?
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoUsers of DMT, or participants in the ayahuasca ceremony, often advocate for the drug because they claim that it really opens a portal to another dimension and godlike beings there. The trip is very much the point, not mere vague benefits like neuroplasticity or developing more empathy. Indeed, I can imagine some DMT advocates claiming that an approach of applying psychedelics without inducing an actual trip, is the man's attempt to intentionally deprive people of contact with those extradimensional entities.
- capableweb 3y agoYeah, hallucinations without the other effects of the psychedelic sounds sort of useless, unless used as a weapon, torture or something on people who don't realize it. Trips without heavy hallucinations are still useful, but hallucinations without the trip? Not sure what the point of that would be.
- smt88 3y agoThe point is treatment of psychiatric illnesses like depression without the potential for upsetting hallucinations. Even SSRIs are now thought to work by inducing neuroplasticity, and they don't cause hallucinations either.
- vore 3y agoJust a small correction but you mean DMT: DHT is the hormone that causes hair loss.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoFixed, thanks.
- cgb223 3y agoHey now, I take propecia to make sure those portals to the demon world stay _closed_
- jvanderbot 3y ago
- Blackthorn 3y agoIt would be amazing to be able to learn like a kid again for a set bit of time. Imagine taking a neuroplasticity drug and then practice guitar, or Spanish, or whatever, for an hour or two.
- Kye 3y agoMaybe I just have freakish neuroplasticity, but I find that getting better at learning more than made up for ease of learning. I traded rote for note, and am better off for it. Now, combine that with a neuroplasticity pill...
- garciasn 3y agoThey mention Ketamine and its perceived effect on mental health as a side effect of its primary action, but a recent study says it’s no better than placebo: https://www.science.org/content/article/ketamine-no-better-placebo-alleviating-depression-unusual-trial-finds https://www.science.org/content/article/ketamine-no-better-p... So, it’ll be interesting to see if these effects from other drugs, will do better as we continue to study and learn more.
- chpatrick 3y agoThat's kind of a weird study though, it's saying that ketamine while you're on general anesthesia doesn't alleviate depression better than placebo. But to me that doesn't mean much because you don't have a chance to consciously address reasons that you're depressed if you're knocked out, or to experience not feeling like garbage.
- Spivak 3y agoSo it's a good study because it's trying to assess why the medication does what it does. You could give me my antidepressants while I was under and when I woke up they would still work the same because it's a physiological change. If it doesn't work when the patient is out it means that the experience of being high is the treatment. Aside: Don't fall into the trap of assuming that depression always has a "cause" that's mental, emotional, or external. I stand as a testament to the "chemical imbalance" cause. I was still depressed and suicidal despite every aspect of my life being good and in otherwise good mental health.
- freedomben 3y ago> If it doesn't work when the patient is out it means that the experience of being high is the treatment. I don't think we should rule out the possibility of synergistic effects
- cpncrunch 3y agoAlso, many people in tgat placebo group also had life changing reduction in depression.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- NotSuspicious 3y agoI (and many people I have talked to) have come to a similar conclusion. What's really interesting is that going on a weeklong or so meditation retreat where you are meditating for 10 hours a day feels phenomenologically equivalent to microdosing LSD or (if you can remember) generally how you felt when you were happy as a child. This makes me think that the "trippiness" is a side effect of neurogenesis. Speaking with other people in the retreat-junkie/psychonaut/happy-childhood community agree only has helped me be more sure that this is the case.
- b33j0r 3y agoNeurogenesis gets thrown around a lot in this community. I have had success with ketamine treatments. The basic science research is there, but the clinical evidence so far remains pretty vague. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6082376/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6082376/ On the “I feel it so it works,” thing… yeah but it makes me uncomfortable to believe in it like a faith. Something like neurogenesis feels anecdotally correct, but can anyone accurately describe their own brain function based on sensation from inside their brain? Without data, it could equally be the feeling of brain cells (that made you feel unpleasant) dying forever. Would that be a worse treatment? I don’t know, but more research is needed. Sign me up ;p
- lostmsu 3y agoResearch in mice actually showed psilocybin reduces the rate of new neurons appearing.
- bandrami 3y agoI was very unhappy as a child, which may have to do with why I find hallucinogenics very anxiety-inducing.
- dfxm12 3y agoI think "happy as a child" here really refers to awe and excitement around experiencing things for the first time. It is certainly not referring to reliving one's literal feelings from their personal youth.
- pstuart 3y agoDrug laws are stupid and insane. The government declares that psychedelics have no medical value but the article clearly shows that the pharma industry believes they do. They just want to take the fun out of it and keep the money. Yes, they have risk, but guess what? Alcohol has zero medical value and has shown to be harmful to the body and to society at large. Same thing with tobacco. The reason these laws remain on the books is too many of our fellow citizens let it happen. Yes, there are problems with creating a free for all with legalization (Portland, I'm looking at you!). But that's a problem with the failure to regulate drugs as well as a failure on medical/mental health services and housing. It doesn't have to be this way folks.
- DangitBobby 3y agoIt's not just laws. People like me that have had bad trips and never want to touch another psychedelic because of it (or just people that are afraid of it for other reasons) could benefit from drugs that have that same "reset" effect without the trip.
- pstuart 3y agoAbsolutely. I should have been clear in my rant -- the work outlined in the article is incredible and should be celebrated. My point is simply that we should have the choices ourselves, and the reason we don't is bullshit. p.s., condolences on the bad trip. I did a lot of psychedelics recreationally in my youth and have had a couple "misadventures" and so I do not do so today. It's powerful stuff and I do plan on trying again but in a therapeutic/spiritual way and will not do so lightly.
- PheonixPharts 3y agoMost experience psychonauts consider "bad" trips equally as valuable as "good" trips if your focus is self development. Confronting the things that terrify you the most, that are the roots of deep insecurity that take over during a psychedelic experience are the things we need to confront to move on. I've had my share of "bad" trips, but as I've matured I've realized those trips all contained very valuable information about anxieties I was not ready to consciously address. It's hard to imagine a "reset" effect especially in the cases where a bad trip happens. I think the bigger issue is that when people first try psychedelics they are left alone to deal with a "bad" trip without any guidance of how to process that experience. In which case it truly is a bad trip.
- cmrdporcupine 3y ago"Recent experiments show that 2-Br-LSD, like LSD, relieves depressive behavior in mice." Haven't been down this road in 25 years, but I don't think I've ever felt as deep of depressive symptoms as the week or so after taking LSD. I have suffered depression my entire life, but LSD certainly never helped, and probably worsened. Buyer beware. I get very wary of some of the coverage of this stuff, it all seems very reductionist and simplistic. I suspect that the positive effects people are having from these things ultimately comes down to two things: 1. the revelation that they can feel a different way, as a result of having the emotional and perceptive aspects of their brain all frazzled (in somewhat random ways) for a period of time. 2. the genuine upside that some psychedelic experiences can and do show how beautiful the world can be. Standing in a quiet field in the spring, or in some mountains, or in a forest in the fall is and watching a flock of birds fly by and hearing the insects sing etc is always an amazing experience, but these chemicals can make you far more sensitive to perceiving that, for a time. And in a way that can stick with you your entire life. Being reminded that the world can be beautiful, and experiencing that at a deep emotional level... may be the best antidote to depression for me. But they can also really mess you up. I've watched a friend lose total contact with reality, start ranting incoherently, and begin trashing my apartment and wrecking my stuff. I've seen people become total anti-social assholes. I've seen it bring out severe paranoia. And, quite often, pronounced arrogance or elitism. And I worry it's just more "this chemical will quickfix you", while in fact our brains are so social and community driven and that aspect gets ignored rather than dealt with... And on that note I'd argue that's probably one of the aspects of the positive effects seen in MDMA treatment, in that it definitely does encourage an empathetic and social focus from the individual, or at least it feels like it.... for a time. (But also at the same time, some of the most self-focused and shallow behaviours I've ever seen, so ...)
- bugglebeetle 3y agoOr a more recent example, the pilot who suffered from depression having a psychotic break after taking mushrooms, because he thought he was trapped in a dream or hell, and attempting to crash an entire plane full of people as a result.
- 3y ago
- _yb2s 3y agoIt seems like some of the benefits from psychedelics come from allowing people to process trauma, and negative feelings. They find much stronger benefits when patients are guided through integrating the experience with therapy. I would say this can happen without hallucinations, e.g. PTSD patients find they are no longer afraid to process trauma on MDMA and can revisit painful experiences. However, there also seem to be cases, particularly with psilocybin, where the hallucinations themselves are obviously providing the patient a new story or framework to think about something troubling, e.g. the cancer patient who comes to terms with death in a new way, and has a story about the process. So I don’t think the answer is so cut and dry- it depends on the drug and the patient.