7 ms·
Terry Pratchett and the Maggi Soup Adverts (2011)
- helmutschmidt 3y agoNot complaining, just wanted to say that i see this mentioned every once in a while and it is still hilariously sad to see we had idiotic ad experiences before youtube.
- lostfocus 3y agoI remember that dumb ad. I think that was the moment when I finally decided to read his books in his original English instead. (It helped that at this time my English got good enough that I could read whole novels complete with puns and obscure references.)
- ur-whale 3y ago> when I finally decided to read his books in his original English instead. Good for you. Sooo much is lost in the translations of Pratchett to other (even linguistically close) languages. I mean, the translator try their best to carry the word plays or funny anglo-centric cultural references over, bu very rarely succeed in matching the wit and timing of the original English.
- 10729287 3y agoFrench is one of the most famous translation and is known to be excellent. I can confirm although I never read it in English (I'm not good enough, especially regarding cultural references).
- ur-whale 3y agoYeah, I've read all of Pratchett in English, and read one or two in German and French. The French version, much effort went into it, and it is very good indeed, but nowhere near the original. Some attempts at translating Pratchett's humor fall rather flat or completely miss the point of the original puns.
- mcv 3y agoIf you want a really good translation of something: the Dutch translation of The Lord of the Rings. Tolkien himself praised it[0]. Max Schuchart rewrote a lot of things completely to get the exact same vibe across to Dutch people that English-speakers would get from reading the English versions. It depends less on puns, though. Those are always hard to translate. The Dutch translation (the one book I've read the translation of) Terry Pratchett is okay, but not brilliant. [0] Edit: I thought Tolkien praised it. I'm sure I read that somewhere ages ago. Wikipedia tells a different story: that Tolkien hated it. Personally I think it's genius that names with a clear English vibe (like many hobbit names) get translated to names with a similarly Dutch vibe. Schuchart did not mess with the Elvish or other other languages as far as I know.
- bombcar 3y agoThere was a translation that caused Tolkien to write a guide to translating the Lord of the Rings - it’s worth reading to get a feel for what he wanted. Of course Tolkien was a linguist so he could understand translation difficulties even in languages he didn’t speak. He went so far as to add fictional translation difficulties to his own story.
- noirscape 3y agoTolkien was initially critical of the Dutch translation of LOTR, complaining that many of the nonclemature were too localized to his original liking[0]. That said, from what I understand, Tolkien would later change his mind after the original Swedish translator took even more liberties, which provoked him enough to write an official translation style guide, and in retrospective light apparently the Dutch translation would mostly end up conforming to those guidelines. The entire thing is pretty curious given the fact that if you want to get down to it, the framing devices of Lord of the Rings is that it is an alledged translation of a book called "The Red Book of Westmarch". Tolkien himself took liberties with this supposed translation, which is why many of the place names have some form of "common" English name, to make them more palatable to English readers. It's pretty interesting to see him then take offense at other translations. [0]: As someone who fell in love with Tolkien's work from the Dutch translation - eh, it's fine? Most stuff is fairly faithfully and accurately translated. The main issue is that the translator was an even bigger fan of purple prose than Tolkien and occasionally used German roots for certain words. Most of the literal translations used are translated to what amounts to kinda formal, stiff Dutch but others flow fairly well. The biggest difference is probably the title which is something closer to "In the grasp of the Ring", which... might be more accurate to describe the events of the book. It's hardly about the Lord of the Rings himself after all.
- kergonath 3y agoI have read both English and French versions of most Diskworld books. It is the best translation I have read, ever. Patrick Couton is outstanding. He carries all the charm and wit across languages, but is never a slave of Pratchett’s words and does not hesitate to adapt what needs to be. His French puns are glorious. Guet des orfèvres for Pseudopolis Yard is absolute genius, and so are many others. They always land well and are never jarring, and I find some of them better than the original. The Ch’ti that the wee free men speak is great. He managed to reproduce the difference in tone of the book series as well. Including the footnotes, which is most impressive. TL; DR: if there is one good translation, it has to be this one. If you read it in French, you are not losing much over the English original.
- genocidicbunny 3y agoI'm probably biased, but I also think the Russian translation was very well done for most of the books. I read many of Pratchett's works in Russian before English, and I found that the translations were rather faithful in keeping with Pratchett's humour.
- totetsu 3y agoHow do the weemens way of talking come across in translation
- Scarblac 3y agoThe translators pick a fitting dialect of the target language, I think.
- loutr 3y agoIn French it's largely based on picard, a dialect from northern France.
- totetsu 3y agohttps://youtu.be/W17uYuQA9Mc?si=3Ndlen5P2ZqeyZdn&t=52 https://youtu.be/W17uYuQA9Mc?si=3Ndlen5P2ZqeyZdn&t=52 Oh Its perfect.
- Damogran6 3y ago[dead]
- btilly 3y agoThe one series whose translations are very good is the series Asterix and Obelisk. The original is in French. I believe that most of the translations are good. Certainly the English one is.
- zem 3y agothe translator (anthea bell) has also done a brilliant translation of leonie swann's "three bags full", a hilarious novel in which a flock of sheep try to figure out who murdered their shepherd. (at least, i assume it's a brilliant translation because the novel is both charming and funny in english.)
- vincent-manis 3y agoAbsolutely. I've read a few of the Asterix books in French, and a couple in Latin (my native language is English); they were originally written in French, of course. Just one example: in English, Obelix's dog is Dogmatix; the French version is Idée-Fixe. Brilliant!
- jhbadger 3y agoThat last one is weird in that while it conveys the same information of being stubborn, Dogmatix makes more sense in terms of humor because the point of Asterix is that the characters were supposed to have names that look vaguely like real Gaulish names like Vercingetorix; Dogmatix fits the mold better than Idée-Fixe. I know it isn't the case, but if I had to guess without knowing which was the original, I would have guessed Dogmatix.
- vincent-manis 3y agoThe French name is pronounced something like `eeday-fix', so even though the dog doesn't look Gaulish, he sounds Gaulish. Another of my faves in English Asterix is a Goth; all their names end in -ic. This one is named Electric. In a fit of enthusiasm about being a war leader, he says. `I shall be a general, General Electric!'
- deleted 3y ago
- Cosi1125 3y agoMuch is lost (and I learned this painfully reading the translation along with the annotations in APF), but also a lot is added by the translator. The translators had a lot of freedom – with Pterry's blessing – and some of them put it to good use. I love the Polish translation by Piotr Cholewa.
- henriquecm8 3y ago> (It helped that at this time my English got good enough that I could read whole novels complete with puns and obscure references.) It's been almost a decade since I started watching movies/tv shows, and playing games with original audio (usually english or japanese) and english subtitles instead of my native language, to help improve my english. But I to this day, every time I rewatch the movie Airplane, there are new jokes I hadn't understood before. It's one's of the reason I like to rewatch it every couple of years, the other being that it's my favorite comedy movie.
- sorokod 3y agoSometimes it is the core language and sometimes it is the jargon on top. After watching Apocalypse Now many times I recently found out that in Kilgore's "Outstanding Red Team, outstanding..." , red team is an actual thing in Air Cavalry .
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Terr_ 3y agoEven as a native English speaker, I'll occasionally re-read a Pratchett book and realize there was a minor reference or pun that I probably missed the last time.
- fabian2k 3y agoAnother pretty consumer-hostile thing German publishers sometimes do is to split books into multiple parts in the German version. This does have a legitimate reason in some cases as the German version will be longer and you can hit some limits on book size with already large books. But I've also seen it in cases where it was clearly artificial. And it results in essentially 2-3x the price for the same book, because of course each German book part costs around the same as the original full book.
- masklinn 3y agoFrench publishers do (or did at one point anyway) the same thing. For instance the first section of realm of the elderlings (3 trilogies, so 9 volumes) was published as 19 volumes. And for some reason a few years later they republished it in only 7, which is just as insane (they literally cut in the middle of the 5th volume).
- LocalH 3y agoReally shows how much these industries respect the actual art involved.
- jayjader 3y agoThere was (still is?) a French law that mandates the maximum sales price for soft-cover/paperback books: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lang_Law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lang_Law (if you can read it, the French version of that wikipedia article is much more detailed). The intent behind the law being to attempt to keep "culture" accessible to all incomes, notably by preventing resellers from price-gouging books at the expense of the publisher(s). This has resulted in many larger tomes being split up when translated to French - for example, the first 5 (English/Original) volumes of A Song of Ice and Fire are sold as 15 (translated to French) books in total : https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Tr%C3%B4ne_de_fer#Publications https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Le_Tr%C3%B4ne_de_fer#Publicati... I am also very disappointed at how often French publishers seem to decide that they can chop up these stories willy-nilly without it degrading the quality of the art (re-)productions that they are selling us.
- Popeyes 3y agoI remember Fay Weldon taking some money for product placing Bulgari products in her novels. So it's a thing that some authors are happy to do.
- rob74 3y agoIt's one thing if the author decides to do it (although it might not go down well with their readers anyway) and a completely different thing if a publisher does it without the author's knowledge. But, to say something positive, it was at least identifiable as an ad and not "seamlessly" integrated into the text. Some not-so-reputable print magazines still do something similar to this day: embed ads that have more or less the same layout as the actual articles, praising some product. However these must be clearly labeled with the word "ANZEIGE".
- wrp 3y agoDoes the law in other countries require advertorials to be labeled? I seem to remember cases in the USA, but I haven't been looking.
- RamblingCTO 3y agoActually definitely in Germany. But with product placement a "supported by product placements" is enough afaik.
- SideburnsOfDoom 3y agoSpecifically her novel "The Bulgari Connection"
- suoduandao3 3y agoI read a series as a teen that I'm fairly sure had some product placement - characters mentioned multiple times how much they liked Smuckers preserves. Interestingly, the series had multiple viewpoint characters with each book narrated by one, and one of them had much more product placement than all the others - I only remember Cinnabon being mentioned outside her viewpoint books, or her being the one to mention a brand. I wonder whether it was a result of the author method writing, as that character was also the most ruthless of the group.
- cubefox 3y agoI saw this type of ad only once, in an old Bruce Sterling novel. I found it funny (it referenced the story in a clever way) and thought it was some new innovative approach to advertising which hadn't caught on. I didn't knew this was actually an old thing for Heyne.
- jhbadger 3y agoYeah, in the ones I've read the characters themselves are eating the soup and commenting on how good it is! It's funny, but I can well see how an author might not be amused by advertisers putting words in their characters' mouths.
- cubefox 3y agoIt also makes more sense for some novels than others. For a cyberpunk novel this example of unchecked capitalism would fit right in.
- hprotagonist 3y agoSee also, what happens if you try this game with harlan ellison: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MB_hekYXWiw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MB_hekYXWiw
- Slow_Dog 3y agoThis explains the naff "Captain Crunch" section of Neal Stephenson's "Cryptonomicon". Not that you can get it where I live; it would have made sense to do a "Weetabix" section with the same theme.
- lkramer 3y agoI figured that was a homage to https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/capn-crunch-whistle https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/capn-crunch-whistle
- celticninja 3y agoIt absolutely was
- toth 3y agoIt's funny, I know exactly what passage you mean and even though it's been many years since I read Cryptonomicon it's one of two specific passages I vividly remember reading and enjoying. This is even though I've never had Captain Crunch in my life. (The other passage was the one about one of the characters using a computer while in prison and setting up a profusion of xterms scrolling through random files because he suspected he was being spied on using van Eck phreaking.)
- rvbissell 3y agoSo, not the imperial pint of semen?
- wedn3sday 3y agoSuch a great book. Two of the big stand-outs to me have always been the bit about his ex-girlfriend doing a whole research project about his beard, and the phrase "anally copulating shopping carts" pops into my head every time Im at the super market.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoOld-fashioned targeted advertising! Little did they know how prophetic they were...
- anonymous_sorry 3y agoI know you joke, but this advert is surely completely untargeted? It's definitely untargeted in the modern meaning (they don't pick which adverts to insert into the book when you buy it based on a profile of you). And even under any other meaning, I can't imagine German readers of Pratchet are much more bewitched by the charms of powdered soup than anyone else.
- i_am_jl 3y agoI wouldn't be so sure about the second bit; in my experience there's a significant overlap between Pratchett-readers and consumers of instant soup.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoshoop According to Cohen the Barbarian
- bombcar 3y agoIt’s even more deceptive because if an author you like recommends a thing, you are much more likely to try it. So deceptively convincing the author or even worse just sneaking it in is breaking trust.
- anonymous_sorry 3y agoInteresting. But in which direction does the arrow of causality point? Were they* advertised to because they* like instant soup, or do they* like soup because they* were advertised to? * Oh okay then, "we".
- SamBam 3y agoSure it's targeted, it's targeted at buyers of cheap pulp fiction. You say you don't think the readers are "more bewitched by the charms of powdered soup," but do you notice them selling river cruises through France? A Great Books history course? Rolex watches? Advertisers understood the idea of a target market even back then.
- erremerre 3y agoDon't you dare to delete the ad with a black marker, because doing so it is clearly unethical, just like those internet ads.
- tmtvl 3y agoI know what you mean, as long as you paid for it nobody has the right to tell you that getting rid of ads in a book or webpage is wrong.
- vanderZwan 3y agoI'm surprised nobody seems to have caught on to the obvious sarcasm in your comment
- kriro 3y agoLoved this part: """They did it to Iain Banks, too, and apparently at a con he tore out the offending page and ate it."""
- Slimbo 3y agoAnd both men are sadly no longer with us. Coincidence, hmm?
- marssaxman 3y agoI would like to read more about that incident - which book was it!? - but I can find no other reference, alas.
- ordu 3y agoIn "Moving Pictures" Dibbler tried to do just that with... well.. moving pictures. Only it was not a 5-min soup but Harga Ribs. I think even phrasing was the same "why not try..." "...nuorishing..."
- hnbear 3y agoCovered a month ago too: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37762092 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37762092 Why black out some text? Is that actual story text blacked out?
- nxobject 3y agoIt doesn't look like it – this is an example from a Star Trek Novel: https://johannes.freudendahl.net/2019/01/werbung-in-romanen/ https://johannes.freudendahl.net/2019/01/werbung-in-romanen/ The only redeeming quality is that the ads seem to be typeset to cover a whole physical page, so you could just tear it off without losing any actual story text. But you don't need the black lines to do that...
- Maken 3y agoSo, are the black lines there just to pad the page? Seems quite wasteful.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- riffraff 3y agoThis is great. It's odd because this kind of stuff is pretty normal in TV (quiz shows, sports etc) but I had never imagined it might happen in books. I can see how Sir Terry might have been deeply annoyed back then, but this was very fun to learn now.
- AdmiralAsshat 3y agoWasn't this pretty common for comics during the 70's/80's? https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-tfJ2jdP-UbY/UETPI7yXmdI/AAAAAAAAFuU/zLuzxoLTi2c/s1600/hostezz.jpg https://4.bp.blogspot.com/-tfJ2jdP-UbY/UETPI7yXmdI/AAAAAAAAF... https://i.pinimg.com/originals/2c/32/80/2c32806b8a19c33614d4b6fed396c959.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/2c/32/80/2c32806b8a19c33614d4... https://i.pinimg.com/originals/e0/3f/7e/e03f7eec694bf14dfb0966c329e5413f.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/e0/3f/7e/e03f7eec694bf14dfb09... I guess the difference being that Marvel approved the advertisement.
- jacquesm 3y agoCompared to your average youtube interstitial this is benign. Thank god for adblockers.
- neonate 3y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20231113180707/https://gmkeros.wordpress.com/2011/09/02/terry-pratchett-and-the-maggi-soup-adverts/ https://web.archive.org/web/20231113180707/https://gmkeros.w... https://archive.ph/s6wbk https://archive.ph/s6wbk
- jhbadger 3y agoThey did this to William Gibson too! For some reason Count Zero (the middle book of the Sprawl/Neuromancer series) was translated as into German as Biochips and had the embedded soup advertisements. In way, that's fitting for the corporate-controlled cyberpunk future he depicted.