6 ms·
Ripple CEO says SEC has lost sight of mission to protect investors
- Spooky23 3y agoFortunately, we have crypto companies that definitely aren’t providing financial services and securities who are dedicated to their mission.
- monero-xmr 3y agoCan you point to any other security where there was no contract signed and the issuer promised no profits or dividends or upside or equity whatsoever? The Coinbase vs. SEC lawsuit makes these arguments. I am describing something that sounds like a commodity.
- bboygravity 3y agoGotta love the business model of FTX, Coinbase, Binance (and all US retail brokers): receive money from clients for the purchase of securities, deliver nothing in return unless you feel like it. When your fraud moves against you, you can just restrict buying or selling or all trading until you're solvent again. All good. No biggy. 1 guy at FTX went to jail, I hope (for the future of the US) that there are many to follow.
- monero-xmr 3y agoI would argue they are purchasing commodities given the reality of what these assets are. The securities argument has been very suspect and with congress punting to the courts, we are starting to see it sorted out the long, expensive way.
- nightpool 3y agocommodities don't come with an "off switch" that the "original owner" can flip if they don't like the things you're purchasing with them.
- monero-xmr 3y agoThat’s why we should have rules defining what a digital asset commodity is. Where is the off switch for Bitcoin or Ethereum?
- ForkMeOnTinder 3y agoEthereum has "difficulty bombs" about once a year which effectively force the network to follow along with protocol changes made by the Ethereum Foundation. They could conceivably use that same mechanism to exponentially slow the network below the point of usability by waiting for the hardcoded block and then... doing nothing. Afaik bitcoin doesn't have anything like that.
- latchkey 3y agoSo that's the rub, right? You want more regulation for these companies so that individuals don't run off with all of your hard earned money. The issue is that the SEC isn't doing that. They are simply saying that crypto is bad and we aren't going to do anything about it other than try to ban it. Don't forget that Gensler met personally with that "1 guy at FTX", multiple times.
- Spooky23 3y agoThe SEC isn’t some medieval inquisitor. They are limited to acting within the legal walls provided by congress. The same congress whose dysfunction and craven corruption is such that they cannot agree to borrow money to fund the budget they approved in law.
- ethanbond 3y agoAre you telling me that these instruments, designed specifically to skirt grey areas in existing legal interpretation, are skirting grey areas in legal interpretations? Fortunately laws are interpreted and reinterpreted constantly to address this obvious, perennial technique of hucksters and conmen.
- monero-xmr 3y agoWell the SEC lost vs. Ripple in regards to XRP being a de facto security. So I guess you are mad at the legal system saying you are wrong?
- ethanbond 3y agoI’m not “mad” about anything? I’m saying, “no no no, this was designed to be ambiguous ergo can’t touch it” is a clear misunderstanding of how laws work, how they get their teeth, and why we have them.
- monero-xmr 3y agoWe are debating legal definitions and the court said you are wrong. We can debate philosophy but you are not speaking about reality because the court already said you are incorrect.
- ethanbond 3y agoIt’s not quite that simple, even in XRP’s case specifically. The court said that secondary algorithmic sales of XRP did not constitute trading investment contracts, however they also ruled that Ripple sold an unregistered security in their initial offer of XRP. What was that security? XRP! Look, we found a grey area again.
- RandomLensman 3y agoIn this specific case the court handed a (partial) victory to Ripple, not sure this simply translates into other situations.
- throw0101b 3y ago> Can you point to any other security where there was no contract signed and the issuer promised no profits or dividends or upside or equity whatsoever? Isn't that every security? You hope that the companies in which take an equity stake does will, but who is promising (guaranteeing?) such a thing. That's why investors ask for returns: they are risking their money and want to be rewarded. The riskier the investment, generally the more reward is asked for. And as a technicality: in the US, per the Commodity Exchange Act, cryptocurrencies (e.g., Bitcoin) are commodities (like oil, wheat, frozen concentrated orange juice, etc): * https://www.cftc.gov/sites/default/files/2019-12/oceo_bitcoinbasics0218.pdf https://www.cftc.gov/sites/default/files/2019-12/oceo_bitcoi... * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodity_Exchange_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodity_Exchange_Act Do you expect profits, dividends, etc on eggs, potatoes, onions, cheese, wheat, corn, soybeans, lean hogs, gold, silver, aluminium, iron? * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_Mercantile_Exchange https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_Mercantile_Exchange * https://www.cmegroup.com/markets.html https://www.cmegroup.com/markets.html You buy on one price and sell on another, and there are futures and derivative markets as well. Soybeans have no dividends.
- latchkey 3y ago> Soybeans have no dividends. ETH generates yield for holders who stake it. It is also deflationary.
- mmastrac 3y agoI'm so tired of these crypto dudes thinking they are something important and dismantling the protections for small investors.
- sadhorse 3y agoYou know what I'm tired of? Not being able to investments because I'm not a "accredited investor", therefore I must be dumb or something.
- cj 3y ago> therefore I must be dumb or something. Part of the goal of regulation is to force companies to publish information regarding the securities you’re investing in so that you can make smart decisions. When something is unregulated with no requirement to publish the risks of investing, it actively prevents you from having all the information a seasoned investor would want before making an informed investment decision. (In other words, smart people can easily be conned if they don’t have access to information — which is also the primary reason people were against SPACs… they allowed companies to IPO without publishing regulatory documents intended to help investors make informed decisions)
- jadbox 3y agoThis is like a casino saying gambling laws today don't protect players and should be removed.
- charcircuit 3y agoYes? It is only natural that the people being oppressed by the government would speak about it.
- surgical_fire 3y agoDoes the government also oppresses you when they take away the option of companies selling you lead-poisoned food and shit luke this? Regulation is, in the vast majority of cases, good.
- charcircuit 3y agoYes it does oppress you when it prevents free trade.
- WiSaGaN 3y agoI remember Coinbase initially refused to list Ripple (XRP) on its platform due to its largely owned (printed) by the company, thus not "decentralised". It seems that have changed now.
- latchkey 3y agoNo, Coinbase removed ripple because of the sec going after ripple. Once the SEC lost the case, they added it back. In order of events: https://www.coinbase.com/blog/coinbase-will-suspend-trading-in-xrp-on-january-19 https://www.coinbase.com/blog/coinbase-will-suspend-trading-... https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/sec-dropping-claims-against-ripple-executives-court-filing-2023-10-19/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/sec-dropping-claims-again... https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2023/07/13/crypto-exchange-gemini-may-relist-xrp-token-after-court-ruling/ https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2023/07/13/crypto-exchange-...
- steveBK123 3y agoIt's unfortunately that crypto most appealed to some of the least financially savvy "don't trust the system" types who would be most protected by the modern regulatory regime they eschewed. Instead they ended up in a downward spiral of snake oil 1800s era wild Wild West financial system that we learned was bad 100 years ago. Tech people might find the underlying concepts interesting, but a lot of the "small investors" in the crypto space were sports gamblers bored during covid, kids blowing their stimulus checks, and conspiracy theory adjacent types.
- LudwigNagasena 3y agoWere stimulus checks distributed directly to kids?
- filoleg 3y agoI think “kids” here means not literal children (under the age of 18), but more like fresh out of HS college students and recent grads. And they got stimulus checks distributed directly to them, yeah.
- LudwigNagasena 3y agoOld enough to vote, old enough to waste money on shitcoins, in my opinion.
- filoleg 3y agoI agree with you. Just wanted to clarify who the grandparent comment was talking about.
- junofan 3y agoBored sports gamblers needed more information about the business operations and financial health of Ripple to make sound investment decisions? I think we need to be clear on what we’re trying to accomplish.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- john_alan 3y agoDoes cryptocurrency have any useful use cases?
- gumby 3y agoNo. I have smart friends who continue to pursue distributed blockchain (to use neutral language) and we talk a lot about why it’s “great.” In the end the only justification boils down to “it’s decentralized” (annd I’m only looking for upsides; forget talking about the downsides). I’ve been a huge fan of end-to-end decentralization for decades but I also recognize its limits. There are lots of chip vendors and board manufacturers and anybody can make their own computer if they want, but in the end there are only a few ppl who make laptops. And they are dethroned from time to time, which is good. Another problem is non-repudiation. The great thing about studying computer science (or math) is that if you want you can ignore I/O which is messy. But the reality is that if you send a wire to the wrong person, or execute a trade of the wrong number of bonds, the bank can often quickly call the counterparty and unwind it. Because humans make mistakes. In short, the math is interesting, but it all ends there. BTW there’s nothing wrong with Merkel trees; the system we’re building has every sensor sight it’s data before uploading; every upload is signed as it arrives, making data forgery impossibly difficult. But that conventional blockchain use case doesn’t need all the rest of the encrustation of “crypto”, but we have to avoid using the polluted term “blockchain” — it excites the wrong people and turns away the right ones. (For the same reason we say “we don’t use any AI at all, just plain old machine learning”).
- arlort 3y ago> distributed blockchain (to use neutral language) Personally I tend to use "distributed ledger" when I want to talk about the exceedingly few actually interesting use cases / technical innovations in the general area
- janandonly 3y agoMicropayments and remittance are a both huge and still growing use cases. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1544612322006560 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S15446... https://www.gbgplc.com/en/blog/bitpesa-evolution-of-payments-in-africa/ https://www.gbgplc.com/en/blog/bitpesa-evolution-of-payments...
- whatwhaaaaat 3y agoI don’t get it. These guys got caught red handed manipulating the market for a token they created yet you will see commenters go out of their way to defend them. We know from their exposed emails they were paying (in xrp) social media influencers. I have a hard time believing anyone supporting xrp in 2023 is not being paid by brad and gang.
- kderbyma 3y agoI like ripple and I was not paid. The only issue I had with them was their Closed Source ledger tech
- yieldcrv 3y agoas usual, hackernews’ most vocal audience is too cynical to look at the merits of the case or statement itself, simply because the topic is crypto the merit of the statement is that the SEC has no tool to protect investors here. just like you, they’d wish “crypto” to go away. also just like you, they are not the authority to accomplish that. unlike you, they thought they were and the courts are clarifying what was unclarified, but predictable if you ever looked: the SEC has a limited way of designating everything as securities or curbing any specific transaction from occurring. their charter includes a mission to protect investors, in this case they don’t have the ability to do that. going after a token’s issuer doesn't help investors. investors also learn it doesnt affect the secondary markets whatsoever. but if it did, that would only hurt investors too as the assets becomes illiquid and lower valued, either way thats not actually the case as crypto infrastructure improved to not require exchange companies for most digital assets, autonomous applications facilitate trading now, until going to a primary crypto asset that can be exchanged for government currency on a company run exchange. “crypto” as an amorphous industry and technology is capable of providing transparency to investors/consumers far beyond what the SEC mandates, and it is up to those purchasers to discern and be discerning. The SEC has no bearing on that either way. another part of their charter includes a mission to facilitate capital formation. they could choose to engage that way and do not. instead, the crypto industry becomes more resilient upon every SEC enforcement action, each action publicly disclosing how to operate outside the already limited SEC purview. on designation as securities, its reached its natural peak: either all collectibles like trading cards and limited run sneakers are securities or neither those or crypto tokens are. its also natural to want to play devil’s advocate but the arguments have all been made over the last decade, the courts have sided with the crypto proponents and said they were correct, and crypto cynics were incorrect. or at the very least the SEC should be able to make a cohesive argument about why it hasnt gone after Magic the Gathering trading cards and Nike shoes, and has been unable to explain that in their laser focus on crypto tokens, or how a crypto token could be issued just as compliantly as trading card issuers and sneakerhead drops. The SEC stumbles over itself and has been unable to explain, simply losing the few cases that reach the courts and losing all sympathy in their senate hearings on this topic. Why the court cases now? Well crypto capital formation was successful within 5 years of crypto existing, 5 years after that the SEC targeted some of the ones that were wealthy enough not to settle, and now those are getting opinions of judges that mostly match the crypto company’s lawyers rationale. The only people that looked at the environment with a fresh lens. Fortunately, there are also other regulator bodies that are a better fit and are active in the crypto space. Such as the FTC, which regulates products. And the CFTC which regulates commodity derivatives and when the spot commodity influences those derivatives. Those regulators have not lost sight of their missions and engage in the crypto space in a way that the SEC can take a note from. Those approaches don’t involve crypto going away, and so the SEC just keeps embarrassing itself. The SEC could change its tune, but right now that just bruises its ego, although there are some commissioners that have flipped based on their own enthusiasm about the technology. Congress and the White House are watching the agency’s trainwreck and are also not amused.
- latchkey 3y ago... from scams like Ripple!