3 ms·
> The reason why less-well-off folks are more likely to support a command economy Yep, but ironically it would destroy even more of their surplus, so, at least
by satvikpendem 3y ago
> The reason why less-well-off folks are more likely to support a command economy
Yep, but ironically it would destroy even more of their surplus, so, at least for now, they're still benefiting.
But also, why shouldn't surplus be destroyed? You don't see people complaining when business surplus is destroyed, and it is because it benefits one party (ours) over the other (theirs), it's simply hypocrisy to think so. For a truly efficient market, surplus on either side should not exist.
- uoaei 3y ago> Yep, but ironically it would destroy even more of their surplus, so, at least for now, they're still benefiting. No one who is excluded from affording a service due to dynamic pricing going higher than their budget is "benefiting". I'm having trouble interpreting the boundaries between individuals and groups here in your comment, the language seems to freely and fluidly move between referring to one or the other.
- satvikpendem 3y agoI'm talking about the failures of command or communist economies, mainly.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThere is long term benefit in that it signals to suppliers that more demand exists and leads to more supply. > No one who is excluded from affording a service due to dynamic pricing going higher than their budget is "benefiting". If everyone cannot afford a service, then that means there is limited supply. Any option other than increasing the simply simple favors one party over another for some reason. For example, if price is kept lower than the highest bidder, then it favors whoever was first (which is unfair too). Or you can do a lottery system, which is “fair”, but not necessarily desirable for a society of every limited service is distributed via lottery and hence removing all incentive for competition.
- uoaei 3y agoThat happens anyway in a market, you do not need to inject a third party in order to get that signal. What is your angle, why are you so adamant to defend this behavior?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI had a typo in my previous comment. The first “simply” should be supply”. > than increasing the simply simple favors one party over another for some reason This comment chain is about dynamic pricing, which does not necessarily involve third parties (assuming you mean scalpers). > That happens anyway in a market What happens anyway? Price discovery? Dynamic pricing allows for better price discovery, that is obvious. Whether it is done by sellers or resellers is irrelevant. Obviously, different businesses have different mechanics, so the cost of that price discovery may not be worth the inconvenience. For example, a restaurant might want to eliminate scalpers so they can require IDs, but still increase their price with every 20% of capacity they sell.
- uoaei 3y ago> Dynamic pricing allows for better price discovery, that is obvious You'll have to clarify your definition of "discovery". Your attempt to keep it vague is suspicious to say the least. What dynamic pricing actually does is define and enforce pricing according to unilaterally controlled procedural structures. It is basically a capture of the pricing mechanism. Price discovery already happens in the market as the result of people buying and selling things, this is what's already obvious and is understood from Finance 101 by literally everyone. Traditionally, how price discovery occurs in goods and services (excepting speculation) is 1) market research and 2) adjusting offered prices in cases of massive recognized disparity between supply and demand to maximize the revenue. As an example of 2, if a restaurant wants to start charging for reservations they first set a price, eg $20, and if they book solid they raise the price after a couple weeks or if they can't get any revenue from this they lower the price. That's the extent of "dynamics" that are necessary here. You don't need to create some additional service that adjusts these things on the fly, first there is no value for the manager who's already watching and synthesizing this activity as part of their understanding of the operations, and also, it costs more for everyone involved compared to the baseline in order to, what, create one job in the economy?
- twelfthnight 3y agoI think the issue is that business surplus concentrates power to a greater degree than consumer surplus. Concentrated power, be it a business, a government, etc is typically bad because it can be used to distort the market in its favor (i.e. corruption). So it makes sense to me why even folks who favor efficient markets don't want to shrink consumer surplus, at least not faster than business surplus. In the case of a single restaurant like here, I don't see a huge issue though.
- satvikpendem 3y agoThat assumes a monopoly or oligopoly, which is not implied here at all. If one doesn't like the practices of a restaurant, they can go elsewhere, freely.
- ip26 3y agowhy shouldn't surplus be destroyed? Capitalism is a tool, not a law of nature. Perhaps we quite simply do not want to eliminate all surplus, because we like the result of a system with surplus.
- satvikpendem 3y agoWhy would you want such a system? Capitalism is not a law of nature but markets, in aggregate, across many cultures, certainly are, for some definition of nature (perhaps human nature) which is not wholly consistent with the literal laws of nature such as those of the physical world.
- scoofy 3y agoImagine you see a painting you like... you really like it... but you don't even have to look at the price because you already know what it is. It's the most you would possibly pay for it. That's eliminating the consumer surplus. Everything would be priced at the highest possible price that you'd still pay. Need to fly home for a funeral? Suddenly plane tickets are $10,000 because they know you wouldn't miss it for the world. You need only look at the difference between catering/decor for a wedding and catering/decor for any other event to see how much wealth extraction... how much poorer we would all be, if we lose the consumer surplus.
- satvikpendem 3y ago> Everything would be priced at the highest possible price that you'd still pay. That is almost always the case anyway. Things are priced at the point that one would pay. To lament that on behalf of the consumer and not of the business is hypocritical, or more concretely, self-interested, as of course we all are. > how much poorer we would all be, if we lose the consumer surplus. To summarize my point, imagine how richer we would all be if we didn't have to pay anything at all. Unfortunately, that is a false world; production depends on consumers paying what they can and businesses charging what they must.
- 3y ago