3 ms·
People hated your business because you brought ticket scalping to the restaurant world. Many years ago, I went on a couple dates with a 'professional' ticket s
by kelnos 3y ago
People hated your business because you brought ticket scalping to the restaurant world. Many years ago, I went on a couple dates with a 'professional' ticket scalper; as soon as I found out what she did (which she tried to hide with several all-too-transparent euphemisms), I noped right out of there. These people are the worst of capitalism.
I don't think most people mind when a restaurant sells the moral equivalent of tickets to dining slots ahead of time. I've visited restaurants that do that, and had no problem with it.
The issue is that you were taking something that was free (open reservation slots), and then forcing people to pay for them if they wanted to dine there... when they could have just made a reservation -- perhaps farther in advance -- for free.
I agree that most people in the restaurant business aren't in it for the money (if they are, they've picked the wrong industry). But scalping reservations to their restaurants is making things worse, not better.
- earleybird 3y agoFair to say "exploiting the commons for personal gain"?
- jonathankoren 3y ago> (which she tried to hide with several all-too-transparent euphemisms "market maker" ?
- wolverine876 3y ago> These people are the worst of capitalism. That's pretty strong. I won't name all the people doing much worse, but lots of people do jobs that are only about profit, such as much of the finance industry, tech industry, etc. If she was a developer for Google's ad system, would you do the same?
- subarctic 3y agoCurious to hear what these euphemisms were
- satvikpendem 3y agoBringing efficiency to a sub-utilized market, perhaps.
- uoaei 3y agoCall it what it is -- rent-seeking (or maybe in HN parlance, "MitM attack"). Every single economist from Smith to Marx hates these people.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoArbitraging prices in different markets is not rent seeking.
- uoaei 3y agoForcibly divesting consumer from producer, creating two separate markets where before there was only one, is rent-seeking. They artificially created the conditions that justify their existence, and if they were to stop existing or otherwise stop their practice, the situation would revert. None of this behavior is defensible following any economic ideology except a trivially cruel one.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThere is no force, the seller can require name at time of purchase and check identification.
- watwut 3y agoWhich requires more effort on their side. The seller have to spend d money to defend its business from rent seeker.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoThe amount of effort of typing in a name and checking an ID which everyone has on them is inconsequential relative to the benefit.
- uoaei 3y agoYou will have to convince the people who actually run these platforms that that is true if you want it to be a feature of reality. It seems only you are here speaking in hypothesis while everyone else is speaking about facts of the matter.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> The issue is that you were taking something that was free (open reservation slots), and then forcing people to pay for them if they wanted to dine there... when they could have just made a reservation -- perhaps farther in advance -- for free. So first come first serve is an okay way of allocating resources, but charging a higher price is not?
- seattle_spring 3y agoAre you just intentionally missing the point here?
- etchalon 3y agoCorrect.
- ls612 3y agoWhy?
- Kinrany 3y agoIt is economically inefficient. Scalpers create no value and destroy some by spending their time.
- ls612 3y agoScalpers transfer goods from those with lower willingness to pay to those with higher willingness to pay. This is by definition increasing economic efficiency. Rationing of scarce resources and all that.
- etchalon 3y agoTransferring goods from those "with lower willingness to pay to those with higher willingness to pay" does not increase economic efficiency, it changes the allocative efficiency. But at scale, in many situations, scalping merely becomes rent seeking. Rent seeking reduces allocative efficiency. How much the rent-seeking of scalpers offsets the allocative efficiency is up for debate. But all of this is sideways to when and whether scalping is moral or, at least, preferable in society. Not all actions which increase allocative efficiency are things we actually want in society. Otherwise, kidnapping and ransoming children back to their parents would be a boon industry.
- ajmurmann 3y agoThe scalper issue would go away if tickets were auctioned off instead in order to find the actual equilibrium price. I know that this is a solution that some of these only platforms considered. Nothing ever happened. However, now they are marketplaces and the ticket gets sold twice which means the platform gets commission twice. So no scalpers made money on the delta between sticker price and equilibrium and the platform for commission twice. All that is money that the artist and venue aren't seeing. Just do auctions! Edit: The reservations also weren't free. For several restaurants I've had to figure out at what time new reservation open up, set an alarm and then still sometimes not get a seat because it's already booked out. When I traveled to Spain we had one place we called late at night our time to get a reservation. None of that is free. I'd happily paid extra to avoid this trouble and beer certain that I can go to the restaurants for which I'm traveling to another continent.
- AniseAbyss 3y ago[dead]