4 ms·
SpaceX considering a new 'Commercial Cape Canaveral' in Texas
- dalke 15y agoMakes good sense to me. 2 degrees closer to the equator than the Kennedy Space Center, and as the article points out, it's closer to their headquarters, there's the option of being able to abort to Florida, and they don't have to contend with other launch schedules.
- excuse-me 15y agoWhere politics meets orbital mechanics. Texas hates government, so Texas hates Nasa, so Texas will be willing to throw grants/tax-breaks/permit waivers at anyone that looks like a non-government alternative to Nasa
- aaronbrethorst 15y ago> Texas hates Nasa Funny, I could've sworn that was an space shuttle on the Texas license plate... Also, this article suggests that Houston-area lawmakers lobbied hard to save the boondoggle Constellation program. http://www.chron.com/news/houston-texas/article/Texas-fights-for-NASA-despite-fading-clout-1591346.php http://www.chron.com/news/houston-texas/article/Texas-fights...
- excuse-me 15y agoI think you are getting confused between damn federal goverment money-wasting pork barrel projects in other states and vital local jobs brought to that state by it's brilliant and astute senator. Sometimes it's very difficult for mere amateurs to spot the difference.
- dalke 15y agoYet the article said: "The filing is intriguing for a number of reasons, not least of which is the strong opposition by the Texas congressional delegation to NASA's Commercial Crew program. SpaceX is one of four NASA partners in Commercial Crew, the object of which is to develop private sector access to the International Space Station. Texas seems to dominate the House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology, with five members, and Senator Kay Bailey Hutchinson has been one of Commercial Crew's strongest critics. " This makes it seem like Texas doesn't want a non-government alternative to NASA. Or perhaps they're just playing hard to get.
- Symmetry 15y agoI wonder if there's any danger of debris from a failed launch hitting Florida though? It seems a bit far for that to happen, but I'm not a rocket scientist.
- excuse-me 15y agoIt's fairly easy to ensure that there isn't a lot of debris from an object at high altitude consisting mostly of composites and rocket fuel.
- dalke 15y agoCase in point: the Space Shuttle Columbia disaster left debris over two states, but with little in the way of damage. South Florida has a lot of Everglades (see the ValuJet 592 crash) and is 1500 km away and only 250 km or so wide. That's a small target. The Ares SRB splashdown is only 240km downrange and separation is at 38km altitude, so by the time anything is over Florida it's going to be at 100+ km altitude and nearly in orbit. In short, the odds of debris being a problem in Florida isn't enough to worry about.
- excuse-me 15y agoThe shuttle is a much larger and heavier vehicle than they are proposing, and it was in atmosphere and essentially 'flying' when it broke up on return.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoInteresting, Spaceport America [1] is at 33 degrees N Lat, so 5 degrees north of Kennedy and 8 degrees north of this proposed spot. Now what delta-v difference you get per degree of latitude I do not know. I've often wondered why we didn't keep part of Panama for the purposes of space launch. Not forward thinking I guess. [1] http://www.spaceportamerica.com/about-us/faqs.html http://www.spaceportamerica.com/about-us/faqs.html
- Avshalom 15y agoI can't find the number right now but I'm pretty sure I've seen it somewhere that Baikonur at 45N has a 9% penalty (cargo mass_Baik = .91*mass_Canav for the same propelent). So 2 degrees south is probably fairly trivial.
- excuse-me 15y agoIt's also dependent on what orbit you want. Equatorial is easiest launch to achieve and you gain the biggest advantage from launching east and near the equator so it's what was tried first. It's also rather useful if you wish to go to the moon - which is one of the reasons KSC is where it is. Today fibre cables means geostationary is a declining satellite market and a lot of the new business needs to go into much higher inclination orbits to cover a larger part of the earth's surface (think Iridium, GPS etc). For this an equatorial launch still helps but latitude is less of a consideration than the angle you can launch from without hitting any major cities. This is the reason for Edwards AFB, if you want a polar (eg orbit for surveillance satellites) you really don't want to launch due N from KSC - there is a lot of expensive real estate on the eastern seaboard!
- MPSimmons 15y agoI'm guessing the reason for Texas is the proximity to their manufacturing facilities. I would like to see Spaceport America used for more as well, but to my knowledge, none of the tenants (or proposed tenants) are seriously discussing orbital launches anytime soon anyway.
- dalke 15y agoV = omega R, and R here is R_earth * cos(latitude), so the velocity ratio is cos(latitude1)/cos(latitude2). Looks like there's an 8% velocity difference between those two spots. LEO is about 7km/sec. The equator is at 0.465km/s. The proposed site is 90% the radial velocity of the equator, so 0.421km/sec. You get about 1% more velocity from launching on the Equator than from Texas. Doesn't seem like Panama is that big of a deal over Florida or Texas. At 46 degrees north, for Baikonur Cosmodrome, I get that it's a difference of 2%. The difference compared to the pole is 7%. This velocity difference has an exponential effect on the amount of power needed to get to orbit. I am unable to do that math. Avshalom's memory of 9% seems reasonable. Which means the 8 degrees has some advantage, but not as much as I had expected.