5 ms·
I did. My point is that the movie isn't the Holy Bible. The explicit message was wrong, and in a rather dumb way. "Life finds a way" is just law of large numbe
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
I did. My point is that the movie isn't the Holy Bible. The explicit message was wrong, and in a rather dumb way.
"Life finds a way" is just law of large numbers for masses. Big deal. Humans find can find a way too. We've been fighting "life finding a way" ever since humanity learned language. It's not something you run away from, it's something you overcome.
- cratermoon 3y ago> Humans find can find a way too Hubris. Philosophically, it is opposed to reason. The story of Icarus is the classic tale of hubris. As a sort of omnipotence with unlimited power, it is irrational precisely because it appropriates a belief in the possibility of transcending physical limits.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoThe story of Icarus is the story of inadequacies of wax as an adhesive. I'd understand your take, if you wrote this 200 years ago. But holy shit, we've been doing powered, heavier-than-air flight for over a century. People put their footsteps on the Moon, and then they safely came back to tell about it. If anything, I see such takes as a great example why the talks about "hubris" and "playing god" are not just wrong - they're dangerous, perverse, mind-consuming memes. Literally every advancement we've made in recorded history came from ignoring this take on hubris. (To be clear: there exist hubris that is dangerous. It's not this though.)
- cratermoon 3y ago> The story of Icarus is the story of inadequacies of wax as an adhesive. You can't be serious, can you? That's really your takeaway? Was it not covered in the schools you attended?
- randallsquared 3y agoIt's death-of-the-author applied to stories which no longer make sense as they were originally intended, due to reality being other than what the author believed. This is as true for Jurassic Park as for Icarus, except that the explicitly intended message of JP was obsolete when it was written, and it still was written that way for reasons (money, Luddism, or whatever) other than that anyone should have believed it. It's ironic that a similar message about AI, in 2023, is much more well-grounded, but largely ignored due to decades of crying wolf about nuclear energy, genetic engineering, etc.
- FredPret 3y agoA lot of people like the “don’t fly too high” thing because it’s a convenient excuse for them to not reach their potential, which takes effort
- ben_w 3y ago> The story of Icarus is the classic tale of hubris. Ancient Greeks thought the sun was a chariot guided by the hand of Apollo. Meanwhile in real life, we've been to the moon and back in the Apollo program and that name was chosen deliberately. Hubris is specifically extreme or excessive pride, or dangerous overconfidence — if you're genuinely better, for whatever reason, it's not hubris. Doesn't matter why, it could you use maths to prove your vehicle won't melt, or that you starting Dinosaur Island with just herbivores until you know more about the gene splicing tech and only then introduced one carnivore that can be all alone with nothing but a tire on a rope for company like some zoological gardens look like they do with tigers. With AI? I think quite a lot of the development is absolutely hubris. But if you want an effective example there, it's hubris to use Ancient Greek mythology as your example. Instead, use a modern reference from the real world — there are many modern military examples (the US has Bay of Pigs and Vietnam, WW2 had Pearl Harbour and Germany attempting Blitzkrieg on the USSR, and now Russia is repeating all of the USA's mistakes from Vietnam with their invasion of Ukraine) or you could have many companies with grand visions followed by collapsing valuations (X being only the most recent in major headlines, and nowhere near the most severe).
- calamari4065 3y agoBecause you disagree with the message doesn't change what the message is. The point is that "life finds a way" is not something that can be overcome. You cannot overcome all obstacles, and the universe not only doesn't care about your hard work and positive attitude, but is utterly unaware of and unaffected by your very existence. Life, nature, the universe all do what they do and no matter how hard you try, you can only influence things. You have no real control at larger scales. To think otherwise is pretty much the definition of hubris. And men with too much hubris clone a bunch of fucking dinosaurs and set them loose on the world.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Because you disagree with the message doesn't change what the message is. There's a difference between author-intended message, and message or messages received by the audience. La mort de l'auteur, and all. > The point is that "life finds a way" is not something that can be overcome. Hopefully not, because that take is bullshit. Of course you can overcome life finding a way. Were you ever vaccinated or took antibiotics? That's humans one-upping nature. The point, if anything, is that you can't overcome nature once and for all[0]. You have to put in effort to stay ahead. It's kind of implied in what life is in the first place. Evolution through natural selection is an optimization system. A greedy, short-sighted, incredibly dumb optimization system, but it has scale on its side. Which is why we are, for example, dealing with "superbugs" now. Life found a way around some of our antibiotics[1]. But this doesn't mean antibiotics were a mistake. It means we need to do better, one-up life again. Say, with phages. It's not hubris to realize we are smarter than dumb natural selection. It's not hubris to recognize we can win, and keep on winning. > To think otherwise is pretty much the definition of hubris. And men with too much hubris clone a bunch of fucking dinosaurs and set them loose on the world. Don't confuse hubris with hope or ambition. Or engineering. Meanwhile, I'll take my antibiotics and phages and RNA vaccines and cars and computers and airplanes[2], and if someone actually gets around to cloning dinosaurs, I trust they'll have people on the team who know what interlocks are, or redundant power supply. Unlike in movies like Jurassic Park, there exist non-idiots in the real world, and we also have case studies and regulations governing handling dangerous animals and technologies. -- [0] - Ignoring for a moment that humans are nature too, and everything we do is part of "life finds a way", too. [1] - In big part because human societies are dumb too. Clear parallels to Jurassic Park here. [2] - Oh my god what an exercise of hubris powered flight is! Didn't we learn anything from the story of Icarus?!
- mcv 3y ago> Humans find can find a way too. Yeah, humans find a way to mess up. Lots of things are in theory perfectly safe, and yet end up playing the lead role in a disaster. Deepwater Horizon and Fukushima were both caused by a corporation cutting costs on safety measures. That is the thing humans always find a way to do.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Yeah, humans find a way to mess up. Lots of things are in theory perfectly safe, and yet end up playing the lead role in a disaster. Sure. This is part of how we learn. We could do better in many aspects, but in general, stumbling on the boundaries is how you expand them. (Not to mention, "nature" / "god" is 100% growth by mistakes and disasters. Evolution means continuously throwing random mutations at a wall in hopes some will stick. We can't possibly do worse than nature.) Also, "disaster" is quite a misleading term here... > Deepwater Horizon and Fukushima were both caused by a corporation cutting costs on safety measures. ... neither of those were disasters in terms of loss of life[0]. All of those were disasters in terms of unnecessary destruction, but they don't prove oil rigs or nuclear energy are fundamentally bad ideas. They only prove corporate greed (in the former case) and paranoia (in the latter case) are problems. > That is the thing humans always find a way to do. Among many other things, including clean victories with no loss of life or ecological damage. -- [0] - Hydroelectric plants are disasters in terms of loss of life, if you want to look at specific failures. Solar PVs are a disaster, if you know how to add numbers. Coal power plants are a disaster, if you know how to integrate.
- ben_w 3y ago> Solar PVs are a disaster, if you know how to add numbers. First time I've heard this claim, can you go into more depth?
- mcv 3y agoBefore Fukushima happened, I'd heard lots of people claim that nuclear power could be completely safe. Chernobyl was a fluke; it was because of the old model, the communist system and the unsafe experiment they did, but a modern reactor in a modern country could be perfectly safe, and Fukushima proved that a lie. People will cut corners, they will cut costs, and anything that can go wrong, will at some point go wrong. And yes, Fukushima and Deepwater Horizon were absolutely disasters. Trying to paint them as not disasters is ridiculous. There's no winning argument for you there. And we can absolutely do worse than nature.