4 ms·
Hmm... How much is human psychology - Scarce & Expensive is Desirable; Cheap & Plentiful is Low Class - discouraging migration from IPv4 to IPv6?
by bell-cot 3y ago
Hmm... How much is human psychology - Scarce & Expensive is Desirable; Cheap & Plentiful is Low Class - discouraging migration from IPv4 to IPv6?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dluga93 3y agoI think you have it the wrong way around. Scarce & Desirable is Expensive; Low Class & Plentiful is Cheap It doesn't always go both ways.
- djbusby 3y agoNa, cause if it's scarce and you charge a lot it becomes desirable - is a psych trick.
- hot_gril 3y agoYou wanna bring psychology into it, it seems like v6 abuses the crisis of low address supply to sneak in a bunch of unrelated changes. If the solution were truly just aimed at adding more addresses, it would've looked very different, for instance the existing ipv4 addresses would've been carried over to ipv6. Another thing about humans, addresses like 2001:4860:4860::8888 look awful. You gonna tell me that's an upgrade over 8.8.8.8? And 192.168.1.2 becomes fe80::1c03:b6d1:9222:3a02. Why can't I keep 192.168.1.2?
- LinAGKar 3y agoWhy carry over mistakes from IPv4 when they have an opportunity to fix them? When else are they gonna make those changes? And how would you propose making larger addresses without making them longer?
- hot_gril 3y agoThere isn't a strong enough consensus that these were mistakes, aside from making the address size too small. Maybe removing fragmenting was uncontroversial, but aside from that, ipv6 seems more complicated than ipv4 in many ways. Special kinds of addresses (link-local, v4-mapped, ULA, etc), special ways to write them, and so on. > And how would you propose making larger addresses without making them longer? Pre-existing ones don't need to be longer. If my IP before was 1.2.3.4, it stays that way. If a new ISP can't afford /32s for its customers, maybe it hands out /48s like 1.2.3.4.5.6, and if there are ever 282 trillion users, the next one is 1.2.3.4.5.6.7. At home on my LAN, ofc 192.168.1.2 is free and I keep it. IPv6 addrs are only long because they're spread out.
- orangeboats 3y ago>Special kinds of addresses You give one example (ULA) and I can raise you four: 192.168.0.0/16, 10.0.0.0/8, 172.12.0.0/12. You give one example (LLA) and I can raise you another: 169.254.0.0/16. So come on now with the "complexity" talks. It's obvious that you are not even educated in IPv6 technologies, or else you will be talking about NDP and others, not mere addresses. >Pre-existing ones don't need to be longer We cannot do that even if we wanted to do so. Think about this: computer A supports only the "shorter IPv4" and computer B supports both the "shorter" and "longer IPv4". Now computer B has the IP "1.2.3.4.5". How can computer A, which supports only the shorter IP address, connect to computer B? By the magic of having hindsight? No. Therefore: Congratulations! You have just repeated the current IPv4-IPv6 pain point without being aware of it. Which is fine, but note that in your comments you have tended to act like your solution is better than IPv6's.
- hot_gril 3y ago> You have just repeated the current IPv4-IPv6 pain point without being aware of it The current pain point with ipv6 is not simply that hosts/routers need to support the new packet header. Vast majority of them do by now, right? But going v6 means redesigning your network. If all the addresses, routing, etc were kept the same as before and switching just meant handling a different packet header, it'd be a much easier transition. Then once everyone's on v4.1, people could start using longer addresses. > It's obvious that you are not even educated in IPv6 technologies, or else you will be talking about NDP and others, not mere addresses. They're mere addresses in ipv4, but not so in ipv6. ULAs are routed specially, basically as a replacement for NAT. See, I can use jargon too, but it doesn't matter here. From a common sense standpoint, there's no way that making the address field bigger requires changing all existing addresses.