5 ms·
John Carmack noted during a Slashdot interview all the way back in 1999: "Making Snow Crash into a reality feels like a sort of moral imperative to a lot of pro
by ryandrake 3y ago
John Carmack noted during a Slashdot interview all the way back in 1999: "Making Snow Crash into a reality feels like a sort of moral imperative to a lot of programmers, but the efforts that have been made so far leave a lot to be desired."[1]
1: https://games.slashdot.org/story/99/10/15/1012230/john-carmack-answers https://games.slashdot.org/story/99/10/15/1012230/john-carma...
- J_Shelby_J 3y agoThe true value of a liberal arts degree is learning how to not to be totally cringe.
- ipython 3y agoI have been struggling for a long time to identify what you just so succinctly described in one sentence. Thank you.
- lencastre 3y agoReads like unpopular opinion but actually it’s like a hard pill to swallow
- FFP999 3y agoI think it was summed up well by an ad (yeah yeah I know) I saw for some university's continuing ed program: "The sciences teach you how to clone extinct dinosaurs. The liberal arts tell you why that might be a bad idea." [adjacent to graphic of T. rex pursing scientists]
- TeMPOraL 3y agoWhich field will tell you that it's actually a perfectly fine idea, as long as you take correct precautions, and that taking them is literally what makes engineering a profession? Jurassic Park wasn't a "don't clone dinosaurs" movie, it was a "don't be an idiot" movie with a dinosaur theme.
- jay_kyburz 3y agoYes it was. It was "Life finds a way"; or things are more complicated than you think; or you are not as smart as you think you are. It was "Don't play with fire because there is always some idiot out there waiting to sneak past your recruiting team and blow everything up."
- ryandrake 3y agoJohn Hammond was the villain in Jurassic Park, much moreso than Dennis Nedry. The theme was "Don't do risky, dangerous things while cutting every corner imaginable to save money (bonus: while constantly claiming you've spared no expense)." That's the "don't be an idiot" part.
- gknoy 3y agoI feel like trying to make Hammond's greed/foolishness into the main point of the novel is a disservice to the rest of the story. He's not some rare supervillain, he's only a bit more greedy than most people would be in his situation, because on the whole we tend to discount risks. The "don't do this" aspect of cloning / genetic resurrection hits so hard precisely because that greed is entwined enough with human nature that any person rich enough to be a Hammond, probably is going to also have the ego to think that their idea is more safe than it is, or the greed to think they can get away without the proper precautions -- thereby dooming the project in a similar way.
- jay_kyburz 3y agoI believe this is why Nuclear is so popular here on HN. The risks are downplayed and the consequences are underestimated.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> any person rich enough to be a Hammond, probably is going to also have the ego to think that their idea is more safe than it is, or the greed to think they can get away without the proper precautions -- thereby dooming the project in a similar way. 1. "Rich therefore ego" is a popular meme. It's also bullshit. 2. Real world doesn't work that way. Society exists, regulations exist, licensed professions get involved here. Jurassic Park is the tail-end worst possible scenario, and even there, few people get eaten, big fucking deal. The danger didn't come from cloning, the danger came from greed and negligence. In the movie, dinosaurs were involved. In real life equivalent, roller coasters were involved. Some people died because of greed of others, of course it's bad, but no one is going on about "hubris" and "life finds a way" because some dumb idiot managed to blind-walk themselves into operating dangerous hardware without usual safeguards noticing.
- CM30 3y agoAs someone who did study a liberal arts esque degree (philosophy in this case), it definitely didn't make me consider a real life Jurassic Park a bad idea, or question a lot of science and tech and their possible uses. Heck, you could probably justify most possible moral beliefs via consequentialism, deontology, etc if you wanted to.
- isk517 3y agoThe 'Introduction to Philosophy' and 'Philosophy of Science Fiction' elective course I had to take as part of my engineering program may not have done much to develop my career but I think have definitely helped me (or at least set the ground work) develop as a person.
- Kalium 3y agoOn the contrary, they generally teach people to be an entirely different kind of cringe.
- cratermoon 3y agoCan you elaborate? Do you have specific examples in mind?
- Kalium 3y agoIt's been my experience that spending a lot of time with cautionary tales spun mostly out of imagination teaches people that the consequences of things can be predicted in the same way one might predict the course of a story. This is demonstrably an inaccurate assessment of human ability to consistently predict the future. Stories tend to adhere to specific patterns that make them comprehensible. Reality is under no such obligations. The issue arises when people try to shape the future and one another in ways that depend on these faulty predictions. Before long, you wind up with people who essentially believe that Cambridge Analytica was easily predictable from the invention of TCP/IP and thus that they (or we) are responsible for averting it. That false assurance is cringe, and it seems to come about in no small part from confusing the conformity of narrative fiction for messy reality.
- cratermoon 3y agoOkay but what are some cringe examples you know?
- JamesBarney 3y agoI think he's purposefully leaving out examples because the way liberal arts majors are cringe are usually ways that can start flame wars.
- cratermoon 3y agoBut we're on HN, we can discuss our differences with reason and logic. Surely there are examples worthy of examination and critique.