4 ms·
Having an 8GB version makes it more accessible. Apple could just stop selling it and the complaint about there being a $200 upgrade would no longer be valid.
by charcircuit 3y ago
Having an 8GB version makes it more accessible. Apple could just stop selling it and the complaint about there being a $200 upgrade would no longer be valid.
- usea 3y agoThat's not the only other alternative.
- hulitu 3y agoI think thay the complain here is more that it comes with 8GB of RAM and less that the upgrade costs 200$. Apple fans are people for whom the money are usually not a problem.
- xp84 3y agoThey should stop selling 8GB configs, but they shouldn't hike the price by $200 to do it. They'd make the same margin dollars (though not percentage) if they hiked the base prices by $40 and bumped them all to 16GB. But obviously this is Apple we're talking about, and they've been playing these cynical margin games with their customers for 30+ years.
- chongli 3y agoIt’s called premium pricing. Apple charges more because people expect them to, given that Apple markets their products as premium products. What you’re proposing is for Apple to raise the price of the baseline model by $40 so that everyone gets 16GB. But most regular people don’t need 16GB. They don’t have a million tabs and applications open all at once. They use their computers for very basic things and Apple makes them very happy by providing a luxurious product for that. You can see the same pricing strategy play out in countless other premium products, and not just in consumer goods. Check out the prices on Fluke multimeters or Tektronix oscilloscopes sometime (and compare with UniT and Rigol, respectively).
- xp84 3y ago> most regular people don’t need 16GB. They don’t have a million tabs and applications open all at once First, I don't know a lot of regular people who DON'T have 20-30 tabs open minimum. And the #1 consumer of RAM for "regular people" is browser tabs. Just a "normal" page with tons of ads is eating a tremendous amout of RAM, and most people would like to keep dozens open. Not to mention running a half dozen Electron apps at once like Slack, Teams, etc. It's been a decade plus of ever-growing OS and software bloat and Apple's base model 8GB hasn't changed in all this time. So, if 8GB was just enough then, it can't possibly be enough for those same consumers now.
- defrost 3y agoI have the usual variety of machines and I like to keep the old ones running for "regular people" in the family. Yesterday an older machine with 4GB of actual memory and 12GB of paged memory on a fast drive running Windows 10 (I know, not an Apple story) died mid use and auto rebooted. The cause? Google Chrome, 14 tabs, 8 inactive, an app running extracting subtitles from a queue of MKV files, a terminal window and ... <drumroll> .. windows update triggered to sanity check for new updates in the background. The (windows) update checks are getting pretty damn heavy these days, you can hear the drives thrashing in the background as every critical file is version and CRC checked and who knows what else these days. The failure and rebooting was likely linked to my hard limit on paged memory - just this dedicated 12 GB partition and no more .. but the workload was light by any past standard and it's the first instance of the updater kicking in and exhausting resources.
- xp84 3y ago4GB with Windows seems to be bad to a degree I didn't previously realize. A friend had been assigned a Surface Go 3 from work, and it had a current or recent gen i5 or something, and 4GB of non-upgradeable RAM. My friend assumed she had malware, turns out the OS just consumed 2.5GB or so of RAM, and more than a couple of tabs or programs wouldn't just slow it down, it essentially locked up. It really only functioned after a reboot and before you tried to do anything. As much as I'd like to shame Apple for its 8GB junk, the Surface Go 3's 4GB RAM floor is an absolute travesty.
- SllX 3y agoApple's memory and SSD prices are too damn high for what they're giving. Basically ~$200 per 8GB of RAM and ~$200 per half terabyte of SSD. This is well out of line what you pay for both in any other product or standalone, and there's nothing especially good about the RAM and NAND chips they use to justify anything close to those prices. If they were buying SSDs retail off of Amazon and marking them up 30 or 40 percent, that would be a bargain compared to what they charge for SSDs right now, and they're not paying anything close to retail prices themselves.
- brucethemoose2 3y ago8GB of LPDDR5X does not cost Apple $200. Its... Maybe $20?[1][2] Its so cheap that it probably costs Apple more to manufacture the extra Macbook/CPU SKU, test it, support it and so on than to just sell 16GB as the baseline. Its literally, purely just to upsell the 16GB version. There is effectively no savings for the consumer even if 8GB is "enough." 1: https://www.dramexchange.com/ https://www.dramexchange.com/ 2: https://www.mouser.com/c/semiconductors/memory-ics/dram/?type=SDRAM%20-%20LPDDR5 https://www.mouser.com/c/semiconductors/memory-ics/dram/?typ...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> purely just to upsell the 16GB version It’s market segmentation. Memory isn’t the only difference between those models.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoRight, I forgot about the SSD... But that much NAND is pennies.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoCustomers don't like market segmentation.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoEspecially completely artificial, detrimental market segmentation.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> purely just to upsell the 16GB version It’s market segmentation. Memory isn’t generally going to be the only configured difference.
- Osiris 3y agoI am no expert. I would guess that the kind that can get added to the same package as the CPU might be specialized enough to have a premium over commodity DRAM. So maybe $30? It’s clear to be that the 8GB isn’t intended to sell in volume. It’s just there so they can advertise a lower “Starting at “ price. It’s literally just for marketing.