3 ms·
I think the GP's point was that's how it should be. If a company is going to -- for "legal reasons" -- not treat contractors the same way they treat employees,
by kelnos 3y ago
I think the GP's point was that's how it should be. If a company is going to -- for "legal reasons" -- not treat contractors the same way they treat employees, then they should be doing so not only in bad, exclusionary ways, but also in good ways, with the expected perks of being a contractor that FTEs don't get: freedom to set their own hours, work where they want, and subcontract out their work.
But no, companies like Google want to have their cake and eat it too: they want a class of workers where they can require of them more or less the exact same things that they require of their employees (and much more easily fire them), but can give them a lot less, and treat them like a second class.
That's entirely Google's choice. It does not have to be that way. But they've decided to create this two-class system for their own benefit, not for anyone else's.
Also consider that these people are probably often not contractors in the legal sense. They're likely W-2 employees of some sort of staffing agency, who are then placed at Google. Google pays the staffing agency, the staffing agency pays the "contractor" a salary (significantly less than what Google pays the staffing agency), and all is fine... legally, anyway.
- ssharp 3y ago>> Google pays the staffing agency, the staffing agency pays the "contractor" a salary (significantly less than what Google pays the staffing agency), and all is fine... legally, anyway. The staffing agency vig is so high it is practically the same as an FTE.
- Galacta7 3y agoI used to work for a temp agency (clerical, not in tech) and I remember once seeing what my agency was getting paid for me on an hourly basis. Iirc, it was something like 3-4x what I was getting paid hourly. It was kind of sickening tbh. Plus many agencies forbid temps from being hired away without paying an outrageously hire fee to do so. It felt like being an indentured servant in many ways. The only upside was that if you hated the place you worked, you could always ask to be reassigned someplace else. But that's the only major plus I can think of.
- ethbr1 3y agoAfaicr, 3x was pretty standard in consultant salary vs billable rate. The idea is that covers 70-80% utilization, unprofitable engagements, HR, benefits, etc. Plus profit to the company.
- intended 3y agoI’m assuming Profit margins are about 14-25%, so a 4x multiplier would be what it takes. 3 would mean your firm had sources of revenue other than services/consulting.
- dchftcs 3y agoThe most profitable consulting-type businesses have profit margins >=50%, before distributing profits to equity holders. But either way I'm not sure about your implicit assumption here that the profits should be comparable to the pay of the employees.
- intended 3y agoHey, you began your comparison with the most profitable consulting firms… 2 things - 1) Accenture has an EBIT of 20%. 2) The tippy top of the consulting pyramid plays on branding in a way that the average firm does not. The VAST majority of service driven firms will not become McKinsey etc. making this a poor comparison Finally - I doubt that the top firms have those margins, I would most definitely like to be corrected though. If you could clarify or share your source, I’d appreciate it.
- scottru 3y agoFWIW, this isn't the case at Google (or many other large technology companies). Google dictates the staffing agency markup (which is very limited) and audits for compliance. This, among many other processes, has significant negative impacts on the quality of the agency that will work with Google on this sort of work - but it does help with cost control. (Source: I ran one of these agencies, and Google was a past client.)
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoWith that level of control by Goofle, the entire thing comes across as a legal charade at best, or fraudulent at worst.
- meheleventyone 3y agoContractors should cost more than a FTE you’re buying expertise and the contractor is shouldering the risk and burdens of not being a FTE.
- sgarland 3y ago> They're likely W-2 employees of some sort of staffing agency, who are then placed at Google. This is precisely what Samsung does in Austin at its fab, via Randstad. I was a supervisor, and had about 50:50 FTE and Contractor. They were treated exactly the same, including getting pizza parties and the like. The main – and largest – difference was FTE benefits were awesome, and Contractors got the bare minimum required by law (Texas, so basically nothing). I often complained about this to management, to no avail. My main argument was that we were training people to quit and go work for Intel or GloFo as FTEs. Didn’t seem to matter. I hate this model so much. Just pay people if you want FTEs.