3 ms·
This is backward. They should eliminate the law school requirement and let people be lawyers with just the bar exam.
by rayiner 3y ago
This is backward. They should eliminate the law school requirement and let people be lawyers with just the bar exam.
- alistairSH 3y agoThis program requires a short apprenticeship and the submission of a body of work to the bar in lieu of the exam. This sounds reasonable to me (though the 675 hours sounds low - I would have expected 1 year of experience or more). Virginia is one of two(?) states that allow an apprenticeship ("reading the law") to replace law school. But the bar exam is still required. And the pass rate here is much lower than law school graduates.
- Arainach 3y agoTalking to friends who have taken the bar exam, it excels at testing, among other things, attention to detail - a scenario that "is clearly X" at first read is actually nuanced and the answer is completely different. I don't personally believe that any single other skill is more important to being an effective lawyer, and do not believe that a short apprenticeship or submission of "body of work" is any sort of substitute. Will there be some people who can be effective lawyers without passing the bar? Probably - in the sense that there are some people who can be effective software engineers coming out of a coding bootcamp. That doesn't mean that 95% aren't incompetent people looking to make a quick buck.
- anon373839 3y ago> I don't personally believe that any single other skill is more important to being an effective lawyer I’ll posit one more: a holistic intuition of how the law “works”. The law is unfathomably large. As a lawyer, you have to make numerous decisions that involve novel circumstances or that you simply don’t have the opportunity to research beforehand. So you need to base a surprising number of decisions on instinct, experience, or derivation from first principles.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoIs the pass rate being low, bad? Couldn't it just imply more people attempt it?
- alistairSH 3y agoThe pass rate for law readers (apprentices) is lower than those who completed law school (20% pass rate vs 80%). The law reader program requires an undergraduate degree and 3 years of apprenticeship under a supervising attorney, so it doesn't save time vs law school. It only saves money. A small number of people undertake and complete the law reader program in VA. Likely because it's not viewed as a good value - if you complete law school, but fail the bar, at least you still have a post-graduate degree (that's generally viewed favorably in general). But, IANAL or expert in this program, just interesting the different options to get into a law practice.
- kelipso 3y agoMore than a good chance the law readers are doing it alongside a full or part time job, while law school students are fully invested in terms of time and lots of money.
- alistairSH 3y agoThat's possible. From the program rules... "Each calendar year shall consist of at least 40 weeks, with a minimum of 25 hours of study each week..."
- kevinmchugh 3y ago> if you complete law school, but fail the bar, at least you still have a post-graduate degree (that's generally viewed favorably in general). For folks who don't know, lawyers really like JDs, to the point that if you want to be a recruiter for lawyers, you probably need a JD. If you want to be a career counselor at a law school, you probably need a JD. They can be this choosy because there's enough people with a JD who don't want to be a lawyer or can't hack it as one.
- lucb1e 3y ago> 675 hours sounds low - I would have expected 1 year of experience Doing the unit conversion for everyone else: that's 17 versus 48 workweeks, assuming 40 hours/week in both cases.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 5555624 3y agoFour states allow you to take the bar exam without attending law school: California, Vermont, Virginia, Washington. The various requirements differ. California requires two years of college, Virginia requires a bachelor's degree. Vermont takes four years, California takes five years.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoAgreed. Lincoln was one of the famous lawyers that never attended law school: https://www.politico.com/story/2016/11/lincoln-admitted-to-practice-law-dec-3-1839-232022 https://www.politico.com/story/2016/11/lincoln-admitted-to-p...
- mustache_kimono 3y agoEvery lawyer attending law school is a relatively new phenomenon although law schools have been around in the US since 1817. Previously, many might apprentice, then take a bar exam. Justice Robert Jackson, one of our greatest SCOTUS justices and a personal favorite, was the last SCOTUS justice not to attend the standard 3 years of law school. However IMHO there are plenty of attorneys, perhaps too many, and de-professionalizing the practice of law, at this moment in time, will not be a good thing for judges, other attorneys, and the administration of justice. But read carefully what Oregon is doing: > After law school, candidates will spend 675 hours working under the supervision of an experienced attorney and create a portfolio of legal work that bar officials will grade as an alternative to the traditional bar exam. I think this policy gets the problem backwards. Kids are actually spending too much time and money in law school. The preparation and sitting for a grueling 2-3 day exam more closely approximates one aspect of the profession, than yet another year of law school. I'd be more pleased if we re-adopted the apprenticeship model, as an alternative to some law school, and reduced the traditional law school curriculum to 2 years.
- jcranmer 3y agoFrom what I understand, the law school requirement is more useful than the bar exam. To use a CS analogy, the bar exam would involve questions like "write a Sieve of Eratosthenes using PDP-11 assembler," and you're expected to have the PDP-11 assembly manual fully memorized to be able to take it.
- catlover76 3y ago[dead]
- biomcgary 3y agoOne of my frustrations with professional licensing (beyond being intentionally protectionist) is that it requires X number of hours in a seat, not really demonstrated competence. This slows down market response to increasing demand (I can't find an electrician in my area). A very involved exam stretching over multiple days would be much faster and more likely to achieve the stated purpose of licensing competent people.
- plagiarist 3y agoI would love to study on my own, take an exam, and be qualified to do electrical work on my own house. The only thing stopping me from attempting is the hour requirement. I kinda see the point, practice is important. But I'm not about to transition careers and work as an apprentice at this stage in life.
- dpe82 3y agoIn many US states, you can already do electrical work on your own home without a professional certificate as long as it's done to code and inspected.
- jimmaswell 3y agoOr if nobody notices.
- earleybird 3y agoOr as a sibling of mine did recently. Electrician didn't have time to do the work so sibling did the work and electrician reviewed on completion (when he was back from vacation) for a nominal fee. Electrician noted the work was meticulous, in fact better than any of his assistants. Several things to note, siblings meticulous work also applies to day job as developer, it probably took longer than the electricians assistants would take and finally you could say the electrician 'approved and merged the PR'.
- kibwen 3y agoCertain jurisdictions do allow you to do electrical work without a license if you're the property owner.
- miobrien 3y agoNo. The bar exam is an outdated, gatekeeping, hazing mechanism that requires rote memorization and application of blackletter law and is altogether unrelated to the practice of law. However, it wouldn't hurt to shorten law school from three to two years. The third year is a waste.
- xwdv 3y agoNo, that’s exactly what they want to prevent: pissants who game the exam and then go on to practice law. If you’ve done law school, that should be good enough. No need to pin everything on one exam.
- killjoywashere 3y agoAny professional program instills way more than just knowledge to pass a test. The fact that you survived long enough to pass the test is often a big part of the test's function. The graded practice thing is actually even more intimidating. Not only do you have to do well, you have to do well live in front of people, and you have to have had the requisite experience in those hours of practice to get an adequate portfolio together. This portfolio development component can be brutally harder than all the tests combined.
- ibejoeb 3y agoIf you've practiced for a decade in one state, and then you moved to another state without reciprocity (many permutations) and want to work, suddenly you have to sit again. That's a very different headspace. This "supervised work" is a good option in this scenario.
- kstrauser 3y agoThat's the same for doctors. My wife and I moved to a state without reciprocity. One of the local requirements was to have passed the board qualification exams -- the ones you take as a med school senior as part of applying to residencies -- within the last 10 years. Doesn't matter if you've been practicing for 25 years, or even teaching in a med school: you're taking the test again. My wife's the genius of our family and passed it the first time through. I'm glad I work in an industry where I don't have to ever take and pass my college exams again.
- throwitaway222 3y agoThen test EVERYTHING one should know
- killjoywashere 3y agoHow do you propose testing real world ethics in a controlled environment?
- 3y ago
- efitz 3y agoThey should eliminate the license altogether and get out of the business of deciding who can practice law. Professional licensing is generally a scam that allows people in a trade to control competition among other things. Under color of government it’s given the veneer of “protecting the public” but in reality it’s protectionist and also used to punish people who don’t think or act like the licensing organization prefers.
- itslennysfault 3y agoThis exists in some states... sorta. I have a friend in WA that has been a paralegal for over a decade who is currently going through the process. In most states you are not allowed to take the bar unless you have a law degree, but in WA, CA, I'm sure others, you can take the bar after studying under a lawyer for X hours (not sure the number, but its a lot).