5 ms·
Thomas Massie failed to stop "kill switch" mandate that could disable vehicles
- biomcgary 3y agoI found the language around the vote(s) confusing. Were Republicans / Democrats for or against the "kill switch"?
- thedaly 3y agoDemocrats are for it, Republicans against.
- PKop 3y agoDemocrats were for the kill switch, Republicans were against it. Massie (R) created an amendment to stop the mandate for a kill switch. Two Democrats and 199 Republicans voted in favor of his amendment. 210 Democrats and 19 Republicans voted against his amendment. His amendment failed.
- whelp_24 3y agoWhy are the democrats for this? Do you know?
- michaelt 3y agoLanguage like "if deemed impaired, limit or completely prevent the vehicle from functioning" makes me think it's a drunk driving detector.
- explaininjs 3y agoDemocrats have been the party of government mandates for some time now, typically under the justification “everyone should give up some freedoms, because otherwise a few people might be harmed”. The real surprise is that AOC voted against it, along with a sole other democrat whose name escapes me. The only exception to this pattern I’m aware of is in the abortion debate, but only under the worldview that unborn children aren’t people (not the time or place to make any claims one way or another about that, just saying it how it is).
- drdaeman 3y agoSadly, they're generally in favor of nanny state approaches, where government is given control over every possible aspect of people's lives where someone or something can theoretically do something bad. Sometimes it's sensible, but sometimes it's very questionable. What truly sucks is that there is no third option.
- northisup 3y agoPossibly unpopular idea here, but I want cars to enforce a speed cap inside cities. They have all the relevant speed limit and GPS data. And hopefully this would stop those cars from going 45mph on my 20mph street. ebikes already have this, why not cars?
- whalesalad 3y agoFreedom is the reason.
- northisup 3y agoi'd like to be free from being hit by cars. its not freedom if its killing other people
- whalesalad 3y agothey are not mutually exclusive
- PKop 3y agoWhy not pass a law to cut off the hands of speed violators? Would that not solve the problem? Why invade the cars of every single person. Absurdly heavy-handed, and not necessary nor likely as effective at stopping people speeding on your street. Narrow, targeted enforcement against violators of existing laws would suffice. Keep incrementally increasing the penalty until it works.
- qbrass 3y ago>Would that not solve the problem? If it didn't work the first time, it's not going to work the second time.
- PKop 3y agoOf course it would work. Harsh punishment in Singapore works fine. When has that been tried? We don't even do this to stop retail theft let alone residential speeding. What on Earth are you referring to re:the first time?
- thedaly 3y ago> The kill switch mandate forms a critical element of the 2021 infrastructure law. Car manufacturers are bound by the legislation to incorporate advanced driving technology designed to proactively assess a driver’s performance and, if deemed impaired, limit or completely prevent the vehicle from functioning. I see no way that could go terribly wrong...
- colpabar 3y agoNow it's time to play the fun game of "which politician has a spouse/sibling that owns a company that makes the stuff that is now illegal not to buy?"
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoMore like, let's play a game which VIP person will get kidnapped for ransom thanks to this kill switch feature.
- AlexandrB 3y agoNot only that, but it's another mandatory system in cars that are already bloated with systems and features. More curb weight, more cost - both to purchase and to repair.
- enragedcacti 3y agoNot necessarily. We won't really know exactly what these systems will need to look like until the NHTSA releases their standard, but its possible that the standard will be satisfy-able while piggybacking off of already very common (and soon to be mandated) ADAS functionality like lane monitoring and automated emergency braking. IF the standard goes that direction then automakers would probably need a little more compute but that's about it. If it mandates eye-tracking, breath or touch analysis, or anything like that then that will be a totally different can of worms.
- Confiks 3y agoIndeed. Comma.ai [1] does this [2] in a very open way. Including eye-tracking (which doesn't work for everyone yet apparently [3]). Unfortunately existing manufacturers are unlikely to implement this in a local-first way. [1] https://comma.ai https://comma.ai [2] https://github.com/commaai/openpilot/blob/master/selfdrive/modeld/models/README.md#driver-monitoring-model https://github.com/commaai/openpilot/blob/master/selfdrive/m... [3] https://github.com/commaai/openpilot/issues/2436 https://github.com/commaai/openpilot/issues/2436
- superkuh 3y agoIt's going to be nasty when people figure out which cars implement this badly and start turning off their engines in the middle of freeways. Even nastier when it starts being used to prevent people from gathering in groups or driving away from protests/etc.
- PKop 3y agoThe value of spyware-free used cars will likely be going up.
- HPMOR 3y agoThomas Massie tries to kill everything. His reputation for voting “no” on EVERY SINGLE piece of legislation seriously diminishes his ability to __actually__ get certain legislation nixed. He was a great engineer and probably understands this issue much more than his peers, but his historical actions doomed his credibility here.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Ajay-p 3y agoActual title: "Thomas Massie Tried, But Failed, To Stop “Kill Switch” Mandate That Could Disable Vehicles" I think the title gives a little negative slant on Mr. Massie, when the negative charge should be on the failed effort.
- toss1 3y agoWhichever way this goes, just the fact that it is being considered makes me definitely more interested in rebuilding and maintaining some good 1990s sporty car for daily driver use. After many structural crash-performance-improvement measures were common but before every manufacturer wanted to sell cars-as-a-service...
- Ajay-p 3y agoI am eager to find this kill switch and disable it. I regret to think that it will be baked into the computer but with right to repair movements, and good hacking, we can disable the kill switch. It is an unreasonable intrusion into the legal use of a legitimate product. Where would this effort stop? A kill switch on your home furnace because you are using too much heat, which is burning fossil fuels and endangering the health of the people? Your phone is geofenced and disabled to protect national security?
- rokkitmensch 3y ago[dead]