4 ms·
> A health care company collects money under the premise that "these premiums you're paying will cover you if something bad happens" That's not the premise of
by JohnFen 3y ago
> A health care company collects money under the premise that "these premiums you're paying will cover you if something bad happens"
That's not the premise of insurance, though. The premise of insurance is that a large group of people pools their money (through paying premiums), out of which the people in need of assistance get paid. It's not that you'll be "repaid" your premiums in services. It's pooled risk, not a kind of savings or investment.
In order for it to work financially, most people have to never have claims in excess of what they paid in. The whole point is to be able to cover exceptional and rare disasters.
I think one of the ways that health insurance (at least in the US) has gone horribly wrong is that it became a means to pay for routine medical things rather than just exceptional ones.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> I think one of the ways that health insurance (at least in the US) has gone horribly wrong is that it became a means to pay for routine medical things rather than just exceptional ones. This is solved by high deductible health plans. > In order for it to work financially, most people have to never have claims in excess of what they paid in. The whole point is to be able to cover exceptional and rare disasters. This is where the problem is. Humans will have health problems and will have claims, especially after age 50. Which means (assuming a stable population), the present value of premiums has to equal the present value of all the healthcare you will need (until you get to Medicare, age 65). Which is a large number, especially considering the obesity/hypertension/diabetes/heart disease rates. Which means premiums are effectively just another tax (except they are no longer mandated). A big wrinkle here is declining proportion of younger populations to pay for older populations, so the premiums young people pay for healthcare older people receive now, but when the young people are older, there will be fewer younger people to pay for them, so it is also a marginal “age” tax, where the younger people pay for more than what they will receive. Exactly the same as Medicare taxes.
- ethbr1 3y agoThis isn't solved by high deductible health plans, because they just kick the can down the road by letting customers self-segregate into different risk profiles. - Young with no health issues? HDHP. - Suddenly get sick or are older with medical needs? Wait until next year's open enrollment and switch to a higher tier plan. Guess which risk pool has to pay out more in claims (against a neutral population average). And therefore has to increase premiums. The issue is that we should categorically ban non-catastrophic health insurance. Everyone gets an order-of-magnitude yearly disposable income * 2 deductible plan. Everything else is out of pocket. Surprise! Suddenly discount options appear. Suddenly hospitals are competing on price. Etc.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoACA does not permit segregation of risk pooling based on plan choice. The subsidy from young to old will remain no matter what due to the statutory age rating factors, and the subsidy from healthy to sick remains due to the restriction barring use of health history to price premium. > The issue is that we should categorically ban non-catastrophic health insurance. This is basically banned as all ACA compliant health plans have to have out of pocket maximums, which are limited by law (currently ~$10k/$18k for single/family). However, there was a political compromise to allow non ACA plans due to some extremist “religious” factions, which I doubt had anything to do with religion. The root problem will remain however, because the supply of doctors and non patented medicines relative to demand is very low, and hence prices will not come down.
- ethbr1 3y agoI expect we might be tripping over my misuse of terms of art re: risk (sorry!) and your proper use? If we look at two plans: (Plan HB) an HDCP bronze plan and (Plan P) a traditional platinum plan. Each can set premiums on the basis of their expected payouts, no? So if, for the last 5 years, plan HB had an average participant age of 35, few health complications, and low payouts and Plan P had an average participant age of 55, more health complications, and high payouts... Plan HB could set lower premiums and Plan P could set higher premiums (against all-of-population neutral rates), no? Or am I misunderstanding limits on actuarial use under ACA? (Disclaimer: I haven't done much work on the actuarial side)
- lesuorac 3y ago> In order for it to work financially, most people have to never have claims in excess of what they paid in. I don't this needs to be true. If you say pay 10,000 and they invest that and it returns at 10,500 at the end of the year then if your claim is 10,300 they've technically made $200 still. Given that they're raking in billions in premiums I think they have access to better rate of returns than each of those individuals could've done on their own. > I think one of the ways that health insurance (at least in the US) has gone horribly wrong is that it became a means to pay for routine medical things rather than just exceptional ones. I really am surprised that most insurance networks don't become more vertically integrated. Like manufacture their own drugs, hire their own doctors, etc since a lot of their expenses are extremely predictable.
- lotsofpulp 3y ago>Given that they're raking in billions in premiums I think they have access to better rate of returns than each of those individuals could've done on their own. Not really, as far as I know claims reserves have to be kept highly liquid (Treasuries or High Grade Corporate Bonds maybe?, especially for a health insurer which pay out almost all the premiums it collects every year. They are not going to be invested in VC/PE/REIT/etc.
- mrguyorama 3y ago>I think one of the ways that health insurance (at least in the US) has gone horribly wrong is that it became a means to pay for routine medical things rather than just exceptional ones. Then why isn't this a problem in any country with socialized medicine or other required health "insurance" things? They have increasing costs but not nearly to the extent the US experiences. The cost of childbirth in the US is insane. It is literally cheaper to fly to another country, pay out of pocket the purposely inflated "tourist medicine" price, hang out in a nice hotel for a few days, and then fly back!
- zdragnar 3y agoThere's a number of reasons. - malpractice insurance - cost of living difference - government rationing of care in public systems - lower capital expenses for nice looking buildings and top-of-the-line equipment - unpaid bills turn into higher prices Medicare/Medicaid have their own distorting effects. One doctor told me that, for certain billing codes, he was effectively making less than minimum wage because the government rate was so low. To make up for it, other billing codes had to be overpriced, or he had to stop accepting any non-private payments. Countries with socialized medicine have their own problems. It can be great for average people with average problems, but outside those lines you run into things that would be trivial in a US healthcare setting. Obviously, it varies by country, and there are plenty of things I hate about how healthcare works in the US.
- JohnFen 3y ago> It is literally cheaper to fly to another country, pay out of pocket the purposely inflated "tourist medicine" price, hang out in a nice hotel for a few days, and then fly back! I can top that... In my part of the US west coast, if you need to have two dental crowns done, it's cheaper to fly to Taiwan and have it done there than to have it done locally. As a bonus, the quality of care and materials will be much better and the dentist may even actually apologize for having to charge you at all.
- manuelabeledo 3y ago> In my part of the US west coast, if you need to have two dental crowns done, it's cheaper to fly to Taiwan and have it done there than to have it done locally. This is exactly what I do. I would take the kids back to my home country, pay out of pocket for any treatment, and have a nice holiday in the process. Last time we went back, I was chatting with the dentist and casually told her about the treatment costs in the US - she was flabbergasted. Markup prices in the US seem to be 500%+ of those in many European countries.