3 ms·
Hydrogen is "safe enough" if we want to use it, compared to gasoline and other routine hazards. The Hindenburg provided a recognizable meme but even with that,
by bombcar 3y ago
Hydrogen is "safe enough" if we want to use it, compared to gasoline and other routine hazards.
The Hindenburg provided a recognizable meme but even with that, there were things that could have been done differently (with technology of the time) to make even those disasters more survivable.
With modern materials, it could be quite safe, indeed.
- messe 3y ago> The Hindenburg provided a recognizable meme but even with that, there were things that could have been done differently (with technology of the time) to make even those disasters more survivable. It’s also worth noting that 64% of the crew and passengers survived. I’m not sure how that compares to the average plane crash, but it was certainly not as severe a disaster as it’s usually thought of.
- dewey 3y agoMaybe also worth noting that it was close to the ground, which it would not be in normal operation.
- rootusrootus 3y ago> I’m not sure how that compares to the average plane crash Average plane crash survival rate is about 95%. I'm guessing it's a somewhat bimodal distribution, however.
- wolverine876 3y ago> It’s also worth noting that 64% of the crew and passengers survived. I’m not sure how that compares to the average plane crash, but it was certainly not as severe a disaster as it’s usually thought of. 64% survival would be great for VC investments (depending on the returns); it would be awful for a round of layoffs; for human lives on transportation infrastructure ... maybe we are losing sight of a big picture here! :)
- Aunche 3y ago> Hydrogen is "safe enough" if we want to use it, compared to gasoline While I'm inclined to agree with your overall point, intuitively, it seems much more dangerous than gasoline. Gasoline is very difficult to ignite unless if it's vaporized. On the other hand, hydrogen is already a gas so it's significantly easier to ignite and more explosive when it does.
- bombcar 3y agoIt's easier to light, but it's pretty non-explosive if not mixed with air: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/_RKdWYqgu3Y https://www.youtube.com/shorts/_RKdWYqgu3Y (mixing with air is a problem). The big advantage (and what could be designed for) is that hydrogen goes up and so (by default) the flammable stuff escapes.
- throwaway4aday 3y agoIt only ignites in the presence of oxygen and a source of ignition so as long as you keep those things away from the hydrogen it should be quite safe. It's a solvable engineering problem. Use only materials that cannot burn for the gas envelope and structures immediately adjacent to it. Locate the engines as far out as possible on pylons. Divide the gas envelope as much as possible to limit the fuel supply for any fire that does start. The major complication is not adding too much weight but there's no reason airships couldn't be as safe as airplanes.
- wolverine876 3y ago> It's a solvable engineering problem. While that might be true, it's been said before. I'd be interested in an engineering study about the costs and risks.
- fsckboy 3y agohopefully the goal of modern technology would be "don't catch fire" more than "survive the fireballs!"
- bombcar 3y ago1. Don't burn. 2. If you must burn, do it politely.