3 ms·

Absolutely, but I must know what will follow if the prototype turns ok

deleted 3y ago
[deleted]
simne 3y ago
Usually, schemes are copyrighted, or even patented. If you will just make 1-2 copies for your internal use, most probably nothing happen, because in legal practice exists negligible case, where not worth considering sue you. But if you will show copies on public, upload 3d model on your site, and/or try to sell them (make ads, other marketing, and yes, opensource copy of patented things also prohibited), on some moment they could make decision, this is not negligible and will sue you. To avoid such things, you could try to find their patents and make your own mechanics with other geometry. Also, patents are not forever, usual max term approx, up to 70 years, and than it become effectively public domain. So you could copy mechanics of some old piano, or expired patent.
simne 3y ago
BTW, I could design electronic suspension of key for you. It may not cheap, but you'll avoid any patent issues.
- chalcolithic 3y ago
  I'm far away from a point where I can make an informed decision about that yet. Thanks for your offer!
  - simne 3y ago
    You will be informed only if you try. All business is really circle: begin -> try to make -> try to sell -> measure income -> decide if possible to continue (or if worth) -> if decide, return to begin. Nobody could tell you if it worth, without try. To be strict, exist people, who know everything, like taxi drivers, but for some fundamental reasons, they don't use their knowledge to earn money and got some better life.
    - chalcolithic 3y ago
      Since nothing about the keys themselves is new(the new stuff is how I would use the control surfaces), I should start making a prototype by ripping out the keys from some existing keyboard:)
      - simne 3y ago
        Ok, it's unclear to me, what is your proposal? I should wait? Or something else? :) For example, I could design case for 3D printing. Or develop app (possible mobile, possible desktop).

deleted 3y ago

[deleted]

Usually, schemes are copyrighted, or even patented. If you will just make 1-2 copies for your internal use, most probably nothing happen, because in legal practice exists negligible case, where not worth considering sue you. But if you will show copies on public, upload 3d model on your site, and/or try to sell them (make ads, other marketing, and yes, opensource copy of patented things also prohibited), on some moment they could make decision, this is not negligible and will sue you. To avoid such things, you could try to find their patents and make your own mechanics with other geometry. Also, patents are not forever, usual max term approx, up to 70 years, and than it become effectively public domain. So you could copy mechanics of some old piano, or expired patent.

simne 3y ago

BTW, I could design electronic suspension of key for you. It may not cheap, but you'll avoid any patent issues.

chalcolithic 3y ago
I'm far away from a point where I can make an informed decision about that yet. Thanks for your offer!
- simne 3y ago
  You will be informed only if you try. All business is really circle: begin -> try to make -> try to sell -> measure income -> decide if possible to continue (or if worth) -> if decide, return to begin. Nobody could tell you if it worth, without try. To be strict, exist people, who know everything, like taxi drivers, but for some fundamental reasons, they don't use their knowledge to earn money and got some better life.
  - chalcolithic 3y ago
    Since nothing about the keys themselves is new(the new stuff is how I would use the control surfaces), I should start making a prototype by ripping out the keys from some existing keyboard:)
    - simne 3y ago
      Ok, it's unclear to me, what is your proposal? I should wait? Or something else? :) For example, I could design case for 3D printing. Or develop app (possible mobile, possible desktop).