4 ms·
This is the future. Every unemployed person will have an AI scanning all the job listings. They can send off 5k applications a day. Conversely, every open posit
by pjc50 3y ago
This is the future. Every unemployed person will have an AI scanning all the job listings. They can send off 5k applications a day. Conversely, every open position will receive 100k applications, almost all of which will have fictional resumés and perfectly tailored cover letters. These will be fed into the company AI, which unavoidably has to make hiring decisions.
The actual hire will be someone the hiring manager knows from college.
- lagrange77 3y ago:D exactly. AI will help one side to decrease the signal to noise ratio and the other side to increase it. The same for the 'content' industry.
- gumballindie 3y agoBut this use case shows that the rate of success is low when using ai. So if anything it would indicate that using ai for job applications is not a good idea. If i see ai spam in a job applicant’s email i am rejecting them instantly.
- jacquesm 3y agoThe rate of success is tremendously high when viewed as a return on time invested compared to the 'normal' method.
- benterix 3y agoI'm not sure about that, it probably depends on the position. In my case, If I send out 10 resumes, I get ignored by 3 potential employers, 3 will politely write back that "after careful review...", but 4 will invite me for the interview and at least one make an offer (usually more than one). So at least in my case, using "AI" (or: automatically generated resumes) is actually more of a risk than advantage.
- gumballindie 3y agoI mean how long does it take to press a button on job ads that you asses as matching your profile? Few seconds at most?
- yowzadave 3y agoHow many of those 20 interviews do you suppose were at great places where the person would enjoy working? They are evidently the places with the worst resume screening (or, alternatively, the most desperate hiring managers). Maybe there’s a reason they’ll interview anybody who tosses in a crappy AI-generated resume.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoyou're assuming that the Mk 1 Eyeball does a better job of sorting through candidates than "crappy AI" resume. And history has clearly proved that's just not the case. Most resumes follow a template and are scanned for keywords and action-phrases. ATS software isn't smarter than that, outside of maybe making some guesses about you based on time worked at each job or if you're lacking attention to detail by not ending each bulletpoint with a period.
- footy 3y agoWhen I got my current job, I applied to only that one. It probably took less than an hour to put everything together and email the hiring manager. The time before that, I think I applied to three places and got two offers. So the "normal" approach has been quite good for me for the last seven years. My success rate is orders of magnitude larger than 20/5000.
- the_only_law 3y agoWhen’s the last time you had to do it. I never had issues either… until I was laid off in late 2022.
- jacquesm 3y agoLucky you. I know someone that has been trying very hard to get employed again but is now for two years without a single positive response. Sure they're doing 'something wrong', no doubt or their resume might be off-putting but your experience isn't necessarily the experience that everybody else has.
- vmfunction 3y agoAI is just the new spam.
- tomjen3 3y agoYou don't see AI spam. All I have to add to the AI prompt is "use the style of Matt Levine", "patio11", "Hemmingway", "a 10 year old on crack" or "Donald Trump" and the letter looks nothing like what you think AI writing looks like.
- rglullis 3y agoIt just came to my mind that, for all the talk about cryptocurrency being "funny money", this could actually be an interesting use case for utility tokens. "Hey, do you want to apply to the position? Tell me how many Vitae (tm) tokens you want to pay for it." It doesn't need to be worth a lot, it just needs to be something.
- vsnf 3y agoHow does this do anything expect perpetuate the already well-off, who can purchase an excess supply of Vitae?
- rglullis 3y agoYou make it inflationary. You reset the supply every year. You make it in a way that it is super easy to add companies to the list of approved minters, and let them mint whenever they want so that they can give to their prospects. The token itself has no monetary value. I'm literally meaning it as a way to be an utility token, which is just another way to say "funny money". The idea is just to have a way to avoid spam applicants. There will be no point in hoarding it, unless you are just trying to stop everyone else from ever submitting job applications.
- red-iron-pine 3y ago> unless you are just trying to stop everyone else from ever submitting job applications Sure. Less of them means more success for me. Or for my people, i.e. we here at Stanford hoard it in order to ensure the success of Stanford grads. In principle I'm alright with the idea -- force people to limit themselves to 25 applications, stuff you really want, keep down the noise -- but what happens if people don't get a bite at 25? what are you forcing the hiring orgs to do?
- rglullis 3y ago> Less of them means more success for me. No, less of them means that recruiters will not receive any applications in that channel. If recruiters stop caring about that channel, there is nothing stopping them from using or even creating a different one.
- altdataseller 3y agoAnd the AI will be sending rejection/acceptance emails to the candidate which in return will send an AI/generated response back, which will result in an AI giving an interview to someone who created an AI to do said interview..:
- gilleain 3y agoSo job interviews will incorporate Voight-Kampff test-style questions? "The tortoise lies there, its belly baking in the hot sun, beating its legs, trying to turn itself over, but it cannot do so without your help. You are not helping. Why?"
- analognoise 3y agoI love how we thought Voight-Kampf would be used for sentient androids and instead it is just an everyday filter for job seekers. Thanks I hate it.
- coremoff 3y agoThere's quite a common Sci-Fi trope of sending an AI proxy to represent oneself or to triage inboxes etc.; guess the future is now
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]