3 ms·
I guess that's one reason I can't fully trust Wikipedia. Because of its beauracracy, primary sources can't make much headway. If I had an entry and they got my
by johnnyanmac 3y ago
I guess that's one reason I can't fully trust Wikipedia. Because of its beauracracy, primary sources can't make much headway. If I had an entry and they got my birthday wrong, I can show them my birth certificate and they wouldn't accept it. But if I talked to Fox News and said I was born in X, suddenly it's "a good source for wikipedia".
I think it's a good rule of thumb to not have people edit articles too close to them, but for some objective facts you may as well let it in (and remember: "facts" means "can be proven OR disproven". I can make a fake birth certifricate but you can objecively prove through later talks that I lied. Or the hospital realizes they messed up and my own birthday is a lie to begin with. Much easier to reason with than "am I a good person?")
- naasking 3y ago> If I had an entry and they got my birthday wrong, I can show them my birth certificate and they wouldn't accept it It's a bizarre rule that doesn't consider a birth certificate to be a primary source.
- xorcist 3y agoIt gets really weird when 1. Someone adds obvious nonsense to wikipedia 2. A mainstream publication republishes this because wikipedia is generally trustworthy 3. Someone else at wikipedia notices nonsense and removes article 4. Article gets reinstated using a referense to publication at (2) It may sound weird but it has happened a few times. Wikipedia could probably do more to avoid circular references, but there's really no simple answer.
- johnnyanmac 3y agoIndeed, one of my favorite XKCD comics: https://xkcd.com/978/ https://xkcd.com/978/ but the answer in my head is simple. 1. make sure the primary source is publicly viewable and archiveable (be it a blog, acedemic profile, about us on a news site, or even a social media post). 2. ensure that there's some way to verify this as a primary source. This one pains me the most, but if we trust news sites to vet anonymous sources, may as well trust social media communities to vouch for a source really being that person. IME social media loves to call out lies, so them trusting a personality isn't as scary as it sounds. 3. be able to mark a source as "primary" to give a bit of distinction so we know there is some lack of vetting compared to a mainstream resource (which hopefully has such vetting built in). similar to [citation needed], it can be footnoted like [2, primary]. There is and always will be nonsense that penetrates through, but I don't think we should discount primary resources as much we do currently. That's not how real life reflects on such resources. Wikipedia has loosened up and started to use more social media as ciations, so this isn't a radical direction.
- anon_cow1111 3y agoFor an amusing but harmless example, see the Amelia Bedelia article. It's been long since reverted, but I'm sure there are many similar prank edits that survive to this day https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Amelia_Bedelia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Amelia_Bedelia https://www.dailydot.com/unclick/amelia-bedelia-wikipedia-hoax/ https://www.dailydot.com/unclick/amelia-bedelia-wikipedia-ho... (EDIT: please use noscript if you visit the daily dot link, it's a terrible 3rd party spam site)
- tim333 3y agoI don't think the avoidance of primary sources is due to bureaucracy. It's long been a policy in the guidelines. I can sort of see the reason if you look at something like say vaccine safety, primary sources would be papers and the like, secondary articles in the nyt and the like. The trouble with papers is there are loads and hard to understand for non specialist and you can find one saying they caused problems in this instance or not in that according to your biases. Whereas nyt articles etc are written for the public and try to be kinda balanced. Not quite sure what the birthday problem was about.
- qingcharles 3y agoI once added an album release date to a page and cited the artist's own home page for the date. I was sharply rebuked for it.