3 ms·
Your title is not an accurate reflection of what the paper says. Quoting specifically, it says: > Most foreign students, researchers, or professors > stud
by ColinWright 15y ago
Your title is not an accurate reflection of what the paper says. Quoting specifically, it says:
> Most foreign students, researchers, or professors
> studying or working in the United States are here
> for legitimate and proper reasons. Only a very small
> percentage is actively working at the behest of
> another government or organization.
Nowhere can I find it saying that "many" are spies. I've searched specifically for the word "many," but perhaps I've missed the section you are quoting.
From http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html :
You can make up a new title if you want, but
if you put gratuitous editorial spin on it,
the editors may rewrite it.
Please could you quote the section from which your title derives?
Thanks.
- loverobots 15y agoI had to distill what it meant in a few words. I used the word many because I couldn't say "most," "a few" or "some." Bloomberg has their own take with examples but I chose to link to FBI instead http://mobile.bloomberg.com/news/2012-04-08/american-universities-infected-by-foreign-spies-detected-by-fbi http://mobile.bloomberg.com/news/2012-04-08/american-univers... "American Universities Infected by Foreign Spies Detected by FBI"
- dalke 15y ago"A small percentage of foreign students are spies" would not be too long. Though the actual article concerns "students, researchers, or professors." There's something like 700,000 foreign university students in the US, and 1 million foreign born workers in science and engineering. Which means that "Many foreign researchers are spies" would have been more correct, by your logic. For that matter "Many foreigners are spies" is even shorter. Fewer than 400 Americans have been to space. Would you honestly write "Many Americans have been to space"? I'm with ColinWright - your headline is not an accurate reflection of what the paper says.
- loverobots 15y agoEDITED to a more neutral title. The title will never be perfect but FBI is certainly concerned, as are US colleges.
- chives 15y agoTechnically, even at .01%, we are still talking about 100s or thousands of bone fide spies, so many (being a vague adjective for multiple) is applicable. Also, more controversial titles get more hits, -editing 101. I understand your opinion and were it raised for nearly every other article that makes it to the front page, I might agree with it. However, as it stands and being the netizen I am going to upvote simply to keep things the same.