3 ms·
This is even worse than the "pseudo science based on anecdotes". This is pseudo science based on the shoddiest "statistics" (if it's worth calling it that) poss
by swombat 18y ago
This is even worse than the "pseudo science based on anecdotes". This is pseudo science based on the shoddiest "statistics" (if it's worth calling it that) possible - pseudo science based on pseudo scientific data.
"Here's a very small sample of data. Let's draw totally arbitrary conclusions from the data and then extrapolate wildly about extremely complex systems and patterns of behaviour. Tada! I can haz argument!"
How much lower can we go?
- lbrandy 18y agoHis statistics are double bad because he confused correlation and causality. He just assumes that people are motivated by their bosses and good bosses equals good motivation. I find that assumption extremely suspect. My suspicion is most of the time it works the other way around, people are motivated by a large variety of issues and their current passion for their job colors their opinions of everyone working there.
- auston 18y agoand yet, I can't seem to recall a single fact or statistic with supporting information from Paul Graham's essay. I'm not siding with the author, I agree in part with Graham's theory, but you're attacking someone for taking a contrary point of view supported with (what may be a best effort in self-conducted) research.
- swombat 18y agoTwo wrongs don't make a right... And I still maintain that this is even worse. Paul Graham's article was certainly one of his weakest (though not quite as bad as http://paulgraham.com/prcmc.html http://paulgraham.com/prcmc.html imho), but at least he doesn't claim to be scientific while thumbing his nose at any sort of scientific rigour. Claiming to be scientific while being the opposite is worse than just being non-scientific.