5 ms·

GPT-4 powers Copilot Chat

82 points by atgctg 3y ago

lysp 3y ago
Great to see that they have implemented a JetBrains plugin too.
deleted 3y ago
[deleted]
BaculumMeumEst 3y ago
thank god, it was unusably bad before
- dinvlad 3y ago
  I see what you did there :-)
iamflimflam1 3y ago
The tie up between Microsoft and OpenAI is bearing fruit.
brandonaaron 3y ago
I recently cancelled copilot (only used the chat) in favor of aider[0] and chatgpt vscode extension[1]. I really didn’t find myself using it much and paying for usage via openai api seems a bit more reasonable for my use case. Side note… I also tried continue.dev vscode extension[2] but could not get it to work reliably. [0]: https://aider.chat/ https://aider.chat/ [1]: https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=feiskyer.chatgpt-copilot https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=feiskyer... [2]: https://continue.dev/ https://continue.dev/
- vunderba 3y ago
  I really want to continue to support Continue as they're one of the few coding assistants that have extensions for both VS Code and Jetbrains IDEs.
  - brandonaaron 3y ago
    It looks like it should be a really nice extension. I did do a little digging to see if I could help debug the issues I was running into but ultimately didn’t have the time to allocate to it. I’ll try again in the near future.
- pests 3y ago
  Big fan of aider too. I spend way too much just playing around in repos. I think Paul is somewhere on HN too.
  - sainez 3y ago
    I believe he is @anotherpaulg
- ranguna 3y ago
  Aider looks pretty good, have you tried it on medium to big sized repos?
  - brandonaaron 3y ago
    I have toyed with it on a larger code base but nothing significant. I ran out of tokens fairly quickly on trying out some larger refactoring/tasks. I don’t find myself reaching for it much but I’m usually pretty impressed when I do.
alach11 3y ago
> Many ideas and bugs begin in a GitHub issue. By combining the details of the issue with the knowledge of the codebase and the reasoning capabilities of GPT-4, our research team at GitHub Next has developed an AI-powered bridge to help every developer scale the barrier of putting an idea into code It's interesting to see how careful they are to put developers first in the way they describe use of the products. To me this is a step closer to replacing developers with PMs.
- lucasyvas 3y ago
  Even if you thought this, then just become a PM who is a wicked-ass coder as well instead. Removing the feedback loop between Product and Engineering would be a huge productivity gain - I personally always wanted to see myself as more than a hired gun that just did what they were told anyway. This would probably be great for our careers long term if we learned the other side and accepted it. A lot of people just want to code, but if it were me I'd rather have someone do both if the economics and work load still made sense. What you might see long term is one role, with people having a T or M shape that is either more user-research driven or technical driven. It becoming a one-person show helps you too, if you are willing to be more entrepreneurial and capitalize on your own skills instead of lending them to someone else.
foobarbazooka 3y ago
Does anybody know whether copilot chat will be available through the vim plugin?
jjeaff 3y ago
Does this mean that the current copilot offering is not GPT4? I read the announcement and really can't tell what is supposed to be different about this than the current VS Code copilot extension. Is it just expanded availability to other services like GitHub?
JCharante 3y ago
> Bringing Copilot Chat to JetBrains Yay. I got into the copilot x labs beta but using VS code is a nonstarter. I love my JetBrains IDEs and refuse to use anything else.
- d4rkp4ttern 3y ago
  Same here. Any idea where we can get the JetBrains preview? EDIT - never mind found it
  - JCharante 3y ago
    Thanks! I didn't even know there was a waitlist https://github.com/github-copilot/chat_jetbrains_waitlist_signup https://github.com/github-copilot/chat_jetbrains_waitlist_si...
joshstrange 3y ago
Am I correct that only the enterprise version ($40/mo) will have the ability to use your GH repos as context for the chat? If so that kind of sucks. I’d almost consider paying for it for my personal repos which contains my side business but it’s a stretch.

82 points by atgctg 3y ago

lysp 3y ago

Great to see that they have implemented a JetBrains plugin too.

deleted 3y ago

[deleted]

BaculumMeumEst 3y ago

thank god, it was unusably bad before

dinvlad 3y ago
I see what you did there :-)

iamflimflam1 3y ago

The tie up between Microsoft and OpenAI is bearing fruit.

brandonaaron 3y ago

I recently cancelled copilot (only used the chat) in favor of aider[0] and chatgpt vscode extension[1]. I really didn’t find myself using it much and paying for usage via openai api seems a bit more reasonable for my use case. Side note… I also tried continue.dev vscode extension[2] but could not get it to work reliably. [0]: https://aider.chat/ https://aider.chat/ [1]: https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=feiskyer.chatgpt-copilot https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=feiskyer... [2]: https://continue.dev/ https://continue.dev/

vunderba 3y ago
I really want to continue to support Continue as they're one of the few coding assistants that have extensions for both VS Code and Jetbrains IDEs.
- brandonaaron 3y ago
  It looks like it should be a really nice extension. I did do a little digging to see if I could help debug the issues I was running into but ultimately didn’t have the time to allocate to it. I’ll try again in the near future.
pests 3y ago
Big fan of aider too. I spend way too much just playing around in repos. I think Paul is somewhere on HN too.
- sainez 3y ago
  I believe he is @anotherpaulg
ranguna 3y ago
Aider looks pretty good, have you tried it on medium to big sized repos?
- brandonaaron 3y ago
  I have toyed with it on a larger code base but nothing significant. I ran out of tokens fairly quickly on trying out some larger refactoring/tasks. I don’t find myself reaching for it much but I’m usually pretty impressed when I do.

alach11 3y ago

> Many ideas and bugs begin in a GitHub issue. By combining the details of the issue with the knowledge of the codebase and the reasoning capabilities of GPT-4, our research team at GitHub Next has developed an AI-powered bridge to help every developer scale the barrier of putting an idea into code It's interesting to see how careful they are to put developers first in the way they describe use of the products. To me this is a step closer to replacing developers with PMs.

lucasyvas 3y ago
Even if you thought this, then just become a PM who is a wicked-ass coder as well instead. Removing the feedback loop between Product and Engineering would be a huge productivity gain - I personally always wanted to see myself as more than a hired gun that just did what they were told anyway. This would probably be great for our careers long term if we learned the other side and accepted it. A lot of people just want to code, but if it were me I'd rather have someone do both if the economics and work load still made sense. What you might see long term is one role, with people having a T or M shape that is either more user-research driven or technical driven. It becoming a one-person show helps you too, if you are willing to be more entrepreneurial and capitalize on your own skills instead of lending them to someone else.

foobarbazooka 3y ago

Does anybody know whether copilot chat will be available through the vim plugin?

jjeaff 3y ago

Does this mean that the current copilot offering is not GPT4? I read the announcement and really can't tell what is supposed to be different about this than the current VS Code copilot extension. Is it just expanded availability to other services like GitHub?

JCharante 3y ago

> Bringing Copilot Chat to JetBrains Yay. I got into the copilot x labs beta but using VS code is a nonstarter. I love my JetBrains IDEs and refuse to use anything else.

d4rkp4ttern 3y ago
Same here. Any idea where we can get the JetBrains preview? EDIT - never mind found it
- JCharante 3y ago
  Thanks! I didn't even know there was a waitlist https://github.com/github-copilot/chat_jetbrains_waitlist_signup https://github.com/github-copilot/chat_jetbrains_waitlist_si...

joshstrange 3y ago

Am I correct that only the enterprise version ($40/mo) will have the ability to use your GH repos as context for the chat? If so that kind of sucks. I’d almost consider paying for it for my personal repos which contains my side business but it’s a stretch.