4 ms·
This article is specifically about not being able to include some of your work in your portfolio, and this is not a problem that's unique to video game artists.
by crazygringo 3y ago
This article is specifically about not being able to include some of your work in your portfolio, and this is not a problem that's unique to video game artists. It's true of all sorts of people in the entertainment industry -- writers, actors, and so forth.
But in reality it's not really a problem. Sure, you absolutely cannot take past contracted work that never saw the light of day and put it in a public portfolio without permission. Rightly, no team wants any part of the creative process leaked, except when the people at the top choose to.
But this still leaves:
1) A public portfolio of stuff that was actually released by the companies (final video game clips, movie clips, etc.)
2) A public portfolio of personal material -- projects of your own, designed to showcase your talents at their absolute best
3) A private portfolio of unreleased stuff that you can selectively and judiciously show in private interviews, when it's not competing (e.g. show your Dove soap ads to Snickers, don't show them to Dial soap)
And that generally works quite well. Especially your personal portfolio of material (#2) -- everything you work on professionally is often compromised by top-down direction. But when you create stuff that's 100% yours, it allows you to show your unique gifts in the best possible light.
- product-render 3y agoIt is a problem that (3) is something that could get you sued, depending on the specifics, although I'll grant that almost never happens. I have work for major big brands that I suspect would land me more clients but I can't even mention the relationship. I signed the NDA, so it wasn't a surprise, but it is frustrating that the power imbalance allows that.
- phendrenad2 3y agoHN skews toward believing that if you can be sued, you will be. It's the infinite monkeys theory applied to contract law.
- hn_acker 3y ago> HN skews toward believing that if you can be sued, you will be. Maybe it's more like, it doesn't matter how correct you are unless you can afford a good lawyer. The infinite monkey theorem is not applicable. Lawyers who make the bulk of their money from being on the suing side (or not necessarily suing, just being hired to be able to sue) rather than the defending side are not monkeys randomly pressing keys on their keyboards. Then again, not everyone's threat model for "getting sued" is the same.
- phendrenad2 3y agoThese are two separate effects but they are both very real.
- JohnFen 3y agoThere's a similar problem in the software dev world. It's very desirable to provide examples of your past work, but if that work was done for an employer, then you usually can't show it to anyone. Lots of devs have hobby projects in part to generate work that they own and therefore can show to others.