4 ms·
Why has stoicism gained popularity in modern times?
- sixo 3y agoA chatbot either wrote this or could have written it. Move along.
- mholm 3y agoI still need to inoculate myself to this type of content. I was reading it and wonder why it was sliding right off my brain.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- softfalcon 3y agoIn my philosophy 101 class, we were taught about Kant, Hume, Descartes, Hegel, and Nietzsche. Then after we had pored over all of those works, the professor brought out Socrates and Plato. I have discussed this with other friends and this seems to be a common pattern for philosophy courses at University. I wonder if because it is taught last, even though it is an older philosophical method, it is looked at as "best" purely due to an order of teaching? There surely appears to be a "stoicism is best" and "stoicism is ancient and wise" popularity spreading across YouTube right now.
- beebmam 3y agoAt my university, formal logic was taught first, then Greek/Roman philosophy, then enlightenment, then modern. And then all the rest.
- softfalcon 3y agoInteresting! Formal logic is a completely separate series of courses at my University. Now that you mention it, that is a very odd choice by my University. Formal logic seems very relevant to analysing the rest of the philosophical works.
- RationalDino 3y agoYou might mean different things by "formal logic". It makes a lot of sense to teach Aristotelian logic either before or with Aristotle. But modern mathematical logic really is a different field.
- sixo 3y agoIf you read the story of the Scientific Revolution, the major difficulty seemed to be overthrowing the deep-seated influence of ancient thinkers, and learning to think for themselves rather than comment endless on Aristotle, Archimedes, Cicero, etc. It's not clear academic philosophy ever really moved past this inclination—a kind of perpetual scholasticism hangs over it, at least as commonly taught. The philosophical curriculum is what it is because—well, tradition; because that's what the teachers learned. You can stretch it to have something to do with the present, or to incorporate everything humanity has come to know to be true since then, but it seems to default to something closer to historiography than anything like what these writers were doing when they wrote in the first place. (Just venting my grievance.)
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoThe first book on Stoicism I ever read started from the observation by the author, a tenured philosophy professor, that most of his field was unable to provide any insight at all into one of the most common (and profound) philosophical questions that people seek answers to: how to live a good life.
- sixo 3y agoWhich was that?
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoWish I could tell you. I no longer have the book.
- billfruit 3y agoDid they ever get to Montaigne? Montaigne has a realisation of the messiness of human life, and how unbridled pursuit of virtue can cause more harm than good.
- softfalcon 3y agoUnfortunately, this never came up at all in our studies. I had to cover the bases myself many years later with my own research and reading.
- RationalDino 3y agoThe way that I look at it is this. Much of philosophy is about logic and analysis. Stoicism is about lived experience. When you're engaged in complex intellectual debate, there seems to me more to areas with logic and analysis. And that is what academic philosophy focuses on. But if you're trying to cope with life, Stoicism has a lot to say. So Stoicism captures something important that a lot of people want out of philosophy. But it doesn't capture what's interesting to have complex discussions about. Let's take just one idea, https://mountainstoic.com/2015/06/03/on-the-stoic-acceptance-of-fate/ https://mountainstoic.com/2015/06/03/on-the-stoic-acceptance.... How many conversations can you have about how it is better for you to go willingly along with fate than to be dragged kicking and screaming? OK, we can have another conversation about how the word "cynic" meant "dog" and so the Stoics were making fun of the Cynics in their dog and cart analogy. But really, there isn't that much to discuss. But there is certainly something to experience! For a more extreme example, I believe that the most influential and widely read Greek moral philosopher was Aesop. But you'll almost never see his name in a book about philosophy. Why not? I think that it is because his fables, designed to speak directly to experience, offer nothing that looks like complex intellectual discussion!
- ramesh31 3y agoIt's the aborted branch of western thought that most closely converged upon the truths found in eastern philosophy. And for the same reason those ideolgies have risen in the last 50 years, stoicism has gained ground. The West has become so thouroughly materialistic, both physically and culturally, that the disconnect between the inability to achieve that material happiness due to income inequality and the reality of modern wage slavery has driven many to find solace in those ideas. The alternative is to resign yourself to mainline western thought, and more than likely end up in a state of ressentiment from the above https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ressentiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ressentiment.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoHere's the question addressed by a historian of philosophy. https://dailystoic.com/the-transformation-of-stoicism-over-the-centuries-an-interview-with-historian-ada-palmer/ https://dailystoic.com/the-transformation-of-stoicism-over-t... https://www.exurbe.com/stoicisms-appeal-to-the-rich-and-powerful/ https://www.exurbe.com/stoicisms-appeal-to-the-rich-and-powe...
- adamnemecek 3y agoI wonder if stoicism was promoted by the ruling class in back in the day in order to prevent uprisings. These people should read Gramsci.
- somenameforme 3y agoIt wasn't promoted. Philosophy in Ancient Greece was quite a lot different in that people were expected to develop their own sort of philosophy of life. Stoicism was just one among many ideological systems that kind of competed but really just more or less all co-existed - with just a bit of murder here and there, along with people's own personal interpretations on everything. It's only in this context that otherwise inexplicable things like the Pythagorean math cult [1], of Pythagorus, can make more sense. This also applied to the 'ruling class' who would often have wildly divergent beliefs and values. IMO it this extreme diversity and freedom of thought that helped the Ancient Greeks make such incredibly rapid intellectual progress in basically every domain. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pythagoreanism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pythagoreanism
- peder 3y agoIt has?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bantunes 3y agoStoicism has been warped, like most things that get popular (see Agile, etc.). More than one finance person I know in London uses it to not let the plight of the poor shame them for voting for cutting social benefits, among other excuses for shitty behaviour.
- hef19898 3y agoThat is propably part of the explanation why stoicism became someehat popular in certain circles.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoTBH, Stoicism was also the preferred philosophy of the Roman senatorial / imperial class. So.
- RationalDino 3y agoIt's like a comment I originally made about mindfulness meditation. It helps you be more effective at doing what you want to do. This might not be a good thing if what you want to do is be an asshole. The corollary, of course, is that the potential criticism doesn't stop it from being a useful thing for you to learn. Even if you don't like how other people use it.
- mberning 3y agoThere is a terrific lecture by Michael Sugrue on Marcus Aurelius where he discusses some of the history of Stoicism. I think that lecture can give you a good understanding of the appeal.
- beauHD 3y ago> Can we really use Stoicism to make our lives better, or is it just a ruse to sell more books? A few takeaways from reading about the Stoic philosophy: - Focus on what you can control. - Amor Fati. The love of fate. Transmute everything into a lesson to be learned and something to grow from. - If it's bearable, endure it with wisdom and grace. - Does it agree with natural law? Is something in line with nature? If it's an abomination, leave it immediately. - Memento mori. Remember you will die. Live every day as if it's your last. Don't postpone.
- bitexploder 3y agoThe original stoics counted "nature" as something close to a proper God. I think not a lot is lost transmuting "nature" to be something more appropriate for modern interpretation of the philosophy though. Nature in a modern interpretation can be thought of the natural order of the universe and the way it is. Although there was also an implied fatalism (e.g. the future is predetermined) to their concept of "nature" which would not sit well with many modern stoics. Just adding some context for what "natural law" is and how modern philosophers have taken to viewing it. I think many people lack a cohesive life philosophy and stoicism is a keen observation of the human condition that rings true today. Not a lot has truly changed and the ancient Greeks and other philosophers had as much of a valid viewpoint of the human condition as we do today. In many areas science has now filled in blanks that were given more mystical properties in ancient times. I could go on, but Stoics were not dour and fatalistic about the future, their philosophy strongly encouraged them to live in the moment.
- sethammons 3y agoMy understanding about logos (nature / god), it is the governing reason of the universe. Because of logos being driven by reason, that which happens in nature or is natural is grounded in reason and serves a purpose. In this way, it is not much different than "God works in mysterious ways." It is a crutch upon which you can place acceptance.
- bitexploder 3y ago
- dhdudbd 3y agowould be really interested in HN users thoughts on the cross section between modern day stoics and fascists
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoAs far as the actual thought goes, I don't really see much point of intersection. There may be some fascists that claim to follow stoicism, but ideologically/philosophically/theoretically, I don't see the connection at all.
- Swizec 3y agoMy lay-person understanding of stoicism is that it’s a philosophy that promotes an internal locus of control. Focus on the stuff you can control, let go of the stuff you can’t. Internal locus of control has shown up as a good strategy in several psychology studies (yes yes replication crisis). Studies show that people with an internal locus of control report higher life satisfaction and better life outcomes. We live in a time of doomscrolling social media full of emotional tugs and pulls about stuff that is so far outside our control it doesn’t even affect us in the least. The only reason we care is because an algorithm shoved it in our face. Then we can’t help but to care. And you know the whole “Yep the world is definitely ending in our lifetimes” vibe that’s been going around the past 10 to 20 years. This is a big problem most of us can’t do anything about. All this conspires to make stoicism look pretty appealing. Now, is it true that we can’t “change the world”? Probably not. But it’s a lot easier to change the world with a series of actionable steps that are completable and within your control, than if you try to take on everything all at once.
- sixo 3y agoSee, this is an article worth writing—one that engages with the content of stoic philosophy at all.
- Glyptodon 3y agoA dash of Stoicism and a dash of Epicureanism are good for anyone, right?
- glitchc 3y agoI love my Epicurean Stoic. A hedonist completely at peace with whatever pleasure the universe throws at them.
- jmyeet 3y agoIs it actually stoicism that's (allegedly) become popular? Or is it just something calling it conservative? I ask because when i see stoics in normal life, you'll often find them startiing with marcus Aurelius and ending up with Julius Evola. Who is Evola, you might ask? He's quite literally Nazi philosopher (graduating from Mussolini's Italy) that is popular on 4chan. There are edit wars on Wikipedia to remove the Nazi associations from his Wikipedia entry. Evola is popular with various "trads". The central idea being that there is a moral corruption of our society and we need to return to traditional values, including traditional gender roles. In evangelical circles, you'll see terms like "complementarianism" thrown around to disguise the misogyny. For many, this is the beginning of the alt-right pipeline. Not being happy with the modern world plus there are plenty of people to fan the flames to make you feel persecuted or oppressed. LARPing as being oppressed is an entry point to white supremacy. Stoicism is fine. Self-improvement is fine. But if you see anyone on this path look for these signs because you'll start seeing them.
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoWhen the organized populist socialist left is defeated and cannot effectively organize on behalf of working class people, and give secular and democratic answers to why the world often sucks and why crisis are happening... Into the void steps far right anti-democratic authoritarian conservatism (of which one variant is fascism but also authoritarian conservative religious fundamentalism, etc). All the the conspiracy theories about the WEF and COVID vaccines and whatnot have this tiny yarn of truth attached to real injustices and inequalities, but once you start tugging them, they pull up a whole scary ball of yarn. Obama promised "Change we can believe in" and ... they couldn't. Demoralization and right wing radicalization is a direct result. But yes, I think you're right about various flavours of Stoicism making the rounds. They have the aura of "trad" and a kind of rational masculinity, seemingly grounded in some old pre-democratic, pre-enlightenment thought. Myself... I prefer Spinoza's Ethics to Stoicism.
- pedroma 3y agoI'd argue studying any philosophy correlates with people looking to study traditional thought. Traditional thought correlates with conservatism, not Nazism, maybe Nietzsche does though.
- progne 3y agoThe surge in stoicism is reactionary, as the stoic Sticks and stones will break my bones but words will never harm me. ...is an anti-inflammatory response to the opposite sentiment embedded in the campaign to eradicate microaggressions. Stoicism is permission to not take damage from verbal barbs.
- surgical_fire 3y agoEverything is reactionary nowadays it seems, even a philosophy based off on accepting change.
- kortilla 3y agoBecause people are looking for a substitution for religion.
- Aaronstotle 3y agoI picked up a Stoic Philosophy book a few years ago and read some excerpts of Epictetus this week. In some way I think the popularity is that these writings are still relevant and offer good advice, one passage in particular that stood out with me. https://classics.mit.edu/Epictetus/epicench.html https://classics.mit.edu/Epictetus/epicench.html Part 29 Stoicism has also gained in popularity because of people like the Daily Stoic, who has created a large social media presence.
- selykg 3y agoI actually use the Daily Stoic (the book) as a sort of journal prompt generator. It has been really great to look at various things in my life from a different lens. That said, I also read the source material (via translations, obviously) because I think a big part of the appeal is being able to interpret what is relevant to the individual reading the material. Read it, understand it, find what resonates, learn to apply it to your life in a sustainable way. Is _everything_ in stoicism for me? Nope, as someone else mentioned in another comment, as someone who is not religious in any way shape or form, those particular bits don't apply, and therefore I substitute in something logical for my beliefs. So far, stoicism has been very helpful and at the very least extremely interesting.
- RationalDino 3y agoThe Daily Stoic was created by Ryan Holiday. I believe that he really did a lot to encourage current popularity for Stoicism. But it is interesting to note that he seems to have gotten into Stoic philosophy to make up for the sins that he committed as a digital marketer. Of his books, his expose on social media and digital marketing, https://www.amazon.com/Trust-Me-Lying-Confessions-Manipulator/dp/1591846285 https://www.amazon.com/Trust-Me-Lying-Confessions-Manipulato..., is my favorite.
- gumballindie 3y agoProcedurarily generated spam, nothing to see here.
- jessicas_rabbit 3y agoThis article mentions all kinds of trends correlated to stoicism, but it completely failed to explain causation. Stoicism gained recent popularity because it directly opposes other trending cultural perspectives, such as self-victimization dialogues surrounding mental health and self-accountability for survival under capitalism. The topic is promoted by red-pill commentators because they are leveraging it to argue against societal complaints coming from other people whose needs are portrayed as “weak” or lacking accountability.
- gustavus 3y agoVery higelian comment.
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoIt's a very important philosophy to teach to people when they are beginning to suspect you've been picking their wallets for fifty years. "Who Moved My Cheese", part five million and thirty two.
- readthenotes1 3y agoReally, the prequel. Hated that cheesy book.
- valand 3y agoWhat's more curious is why is it becoming popular nowadays. The internet, of course, factors into it. But ideas don't stick only through dissemination. The adopters of the idea need to be able to relate to the idea to some degree.
- avgcorrection 3y agoStoicism is the only Western philosophy with classical roots that is popularily promoted as a philosophy-for-living. The rest are steeped in How Many Angels Can Fit on the Pin Of A Needle chin-stroking.[1] I tried to idly bring up philosophy for living questions a few years back. But I was asking academics (on Reddit) and I mostly got queer eyes about what I was asking such weird questions for. It has a praxis, not just a set of ideas. It also doesn’t have the “stain” of being associated with any religion. Which means that secular people can adopt it without some defensive stance on how they are only adhering to the “practical” or the “scientifically backed” parts without the “bullshit” (c.f. Buddhism). [1] Popularily. I’m sure someone could be applying things like Cynicism and other classical philosophies.
- incomingpain 3y agoI will be shocked if this subject is allowed and doesn't end up flagged, including my comment. I posit to answer the question may dwell on https://archive.nytimes.com/opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/02/02/how-to-be-a-stoic/ https://archive.nytimes.com/opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/20... Massimo is who turned me Stoic. I expect he predates Ryan Holliday, both of which are the contemporary stoic masters. The article being focused on Ryan. Why does stoicism work? Well psychology has extensively researched this for decades and without question has confirmed the value in mindfulness in so many ways. Fundamentally it's about emotional regulation. Sensory management is often part of it as well. Afterall, you don't do mindful meditation with noise and light around.
- FigurativeVoid 3y agoI tend to not like stoicism and similar ideologies that have a component of "suffering is noble." There are certain things in life that you must be able to abide, but suffering is suffering. Reducing suffering for ourselves and for others is a good thing. These systems can lead to the perverted notion that suffering is good, and that we should just allow it to happen. We should not. We should reduce suffering for ourselves and for others when we can.
- zozbot234 3y agoEverything in life is suffering. The one surefire way to "reduce suffering for ourselves and for others when we can" is letting go of our attachments, cravings and improper desires (while of course feeling free to cultivate good aspirations so as to replace those undesirable cravings - such as the virtuous aspiration of becoming a sage and helping enlighten the world at large), and Stoicism gives us lots of good suggestions as to how to achieve this.
- RationalDino 3y agoIf you think that Stoicism says that suffering is noble, then you don't understand Stoicism. It focuses on emotional tools that let you do what you think is important, without normal difficulties causing you undue suffering. And it is PERFECTLY consistent with Stoicism that what you think is important can be reducing suffering for yourself and others if you can. Therefore a wish to reduce suffering is a reason to study Stoicism, and not a reason to reject it. You still might not think that Stoicism is worth learning about. But you shouldn't be rejecting it for the wrong reasons.
- laserlight 3y ago> I tend to not like stoicism and similar ideologies that have a component of "suffering is noble." Do you have a reference for this? This is the first time I’ve heard of the idea.
- UltimateEdge 3y agoI think this might be a skewed misinterpretation of the idea that you should not let the threat of suffering subvert your moral principles. I would be happy to look for a precise reference from the discourses of Epictetus if you are interested.