3 ms·
Despite all the people saying this is not a bubble, it is. Small businesses like this would not have got money a while back. This is not a technology business,
by justincormack 15y ago
Despite all the people saying this is not a bubble, it is. Small businesses like this would not have got money a while back. This is not a technology business, it has no first mover advantage, it does not require large amounts of capital to make stuff, maybe it will take off as a product category, but without a bubble it would not get $3 million, or indeed want that amount, being the sort of business you would grow organically. The bubble is people throwing cash around, not a bubble in startups, which have always been created.
- enjo 15y agoI disagree with almost all of that. It's not a technology business? Is airbnb? You need a way to connect folks who are willing to board dogs with those who need boarding. How do you do that without technology? The bulletin board at your supermarket isn't going to make it happen. It may not be particularly novel technology, but that sure as hell doesn't matter. first mover advantage: I personally have no idea if any other options exist for this. I have no idea if they are a first mover in crowd-source kenneling options. It certainly doesn't matter. We've beat this topic to death in the startup community, first mover advantage is rarely an advantage in the first place. without a bubble it would not get $3 million: Says who? Since I see no real signs of a bubble (in the traditional sense), I certainly don't agree. It's a relatively small amount of money for a business that is taking on a big market opportunity. A bubble is not the presence of investment in the first place. It's not even the presence of a lot of investment. Bubbles form when investments (on a large scale) are shoved into increasingly irrational businesses or investment vehicles in order to cash-in on the perceived momentum of a space. When you're investing just because "startups are the place to be right now" then you're looking at a bubble. Here we're talking about a company with a solid (proven) idea, in a big space, taking on a modest amount of money. I don't see the problem.
- justincormack 15y agoAirbnb is not a technology business. The internet is simply one of the major marketing and communications channels we have now, that does not mean that all businessess that use it are tech companies. Dog kenneling businesses did not get millions of pounds in equity investment based on very small revenues and the idea in the past. They self funded and grew. This is a less capital intensive way of providing the same service, so it has even less need for external capital. But it is taking it because the bubble means that its valuation is vastly inflated, because there is so much money chasing startups.
- Retric 15y agoI am willing to be many Dog kenneling businesses started with a business plan and a loan from a bank. When you get down to it 3.4 million is not that far above what it would cost to open a mid sized dog kennel and operate it for a while until you can build up a decent customer base in many parts of the country.
- pbreit 15y agoI disagree with pretty much all of it, too, but mostly with "it has no first mover advantage". In fact, the first to get traction in this type of category (two-sided marketplace, reputational) gains a massive, probably monopolistic, advantage.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ig1 15y agoMarketplace businesses tend to be natural monopolies, so there is in fact a strong first mover advantage. Once you become the dominant marketplace in a category it becomes very hard for someone else to displace you (look at craigslist, ebay, etc.) I'm guessing a significant chunk of that 3m will go towards marketing.
- melarobi 15y agoUser ratings, if done correctly, will make the site "sticky", so if they build their user base fast enough, they could have a first mover advantage. Even so, social networks supposedly have a first mover advantage and even those die off as improved user experiences are presented. It sounds like several of these dog sites have launched in the past few months, and the winner will be the one that makes the best user experience while building volume of users with polished profiles and ratings that seem real and credible.
- jordanb 15y ago$3.4 million is pretty chicken-shit to invest in a business. I know a brewpub that opened with more than $2 million and being a restaurant, it doesn't' have near the upside potential.
- Retric 15y agoThe first mover advantage in this case is simply the network of people that sign up + lot's of reviews. The barrier to entry is how many other people want to get into that market.
- avree 15y agoI work in at an "Airbnb for X" company. We happen to do car sharing, not dog sharing, which means there's a little more technology involved, but $3M for any company isn't much. There's a huge amount of operations involved in making any peer-to-peer industry work right. You have to have good anti-fraud, good abusive user detection (how do you weed out the guy who runs a dog-fighting ring and is signing up with fake information in order to steal someone's dog?), good support for when things go wrong, etc. Word for these kinds of things don't spread organically—to get people on both sides of the transaction (and properly balance supply and demand), you have to do pretty focused local and digital marketing. Add on software developers to build the site and keep iterating on features, designers to make it look pretty, maybe a PR firm to help get the word out... Things get expensive fast.