3 ms·
> Only in South Korea more people live in collective dwellings than in Spain. I... have doubts. (Looks like they're only looking at OECD countries, so Singapo
by rsynnott 3y ago
> Only in South Korea more people live in collective dwellings than in Spain.
I... have doubts.
(Looks like they're only looking at OECD countries, so Singapore and HK, the most obvious counter-examples, are excluded.)
- alephnerd 3y agoSingapore and HK are outliers in general as they're city states (and the latter won't be a separate government in 23 years anyhow). Also by OECD standards it definetly tracks.
- bertil 3y agoI’m tempted to think that the author saw those two examples (and Monaco) as cities more than countries, which, for an analysis of urban density makes sense. That would be like excluding the Vatican from an analysis of immigration.
- rsynnott 3y agoAh, yeah, I think it's fair enough to leave them out; they're very much special cases.
- hbarka 3y agoI agree with you. Also, comparing by countries is intuitively not a good measure due to the averaging out of highs and lows. It would be absurd to compare Spain versus Alaska or Texas but these are two US states larger than Spain. How about comparing by cities? How does Madrid fare versus New York City or Chicago or Hong Kong?
- rsynnott 3y agoYou then get into messy definitional stuff; what's a city, anyway? :)
- dghughes 3y agoPopulation is one thing but density of people per sq km is another. For these cities people must be crammed into apartments I can't imagine that density would mean people are in single homes. Mumbai India pop. 23,355,000 density 24,740 Hong Kong Hong Kong pop. 7,347,000 density 25,254 Dhaka Bangladesh pop. 15,443,000 density 33,852 Density is almost a pun "dense city"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]