5 ms·
8GB RAM on M3 MacBook Pro 'Analogous to 16GB' on PCs, Claims Apple
- nness 3y agoWith it's shared memory, 8GB on an MBP isn't even analogous to 8GB on a PC... irrespective of how efficiently it is utilised.
- pjmlp 3y agoQuite right, there are lots of good things to like on Apple hardware and NeXTSTEP heritage, at least for me, however the whole "you're holding it wrong" narrative that pops up from time to time on various matters, it certainly isn't one.
- snvzz 3y agoRidiculous, and shameful.
- daviddever23box 3y agoHow so? What's your day-to-day experience?
- dharmab 3y agoMy day to day experience is that I regularly need over 30GB of RAM for simulation and media workflows, and I don't use my Macs for them because PC RAM is so much cheaper.
- pjmlp 3y agoUnfortunely for them, Apple has been positioning themselves outside of a workstation domain that now better served with Linux/Windows workflows. The only creators left on the ecosystem are the ones targeting iDevices.
- dangus 3y agoWhich Windows or Linux systems have discrete-class GPUs that can address up to 128 GB of RAM on a laptop, or 192GB for a desktop? I assume for a VRAM-heavy workflow, a Mac might be a good choice, and considering that the M3 Max benchmarks close to the laptop 4080 you’ve basically got the second best laptop SKU on the market with dramatically better power and battery life figures. If you care even a little bit about overall portability Apple is offering a product that you can’t buy from anyone else at any price. Considering that something like 80% of PC sales are laptops that’s no joke. I haven’t had an employer issue me a desktop PC since 2012.
- pjmlp 3y agoPlenty as that is what desktop PCs with discrete graphics cards are for, the market once upon a time Mac Pro was for. Now it can only take audio cards. As for laptops, here is one with 128 GB DDR5 and NVIDIA RTX 5000 Ada (16GB GDDR6 VRAM). https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/p/laptops/thinkpad/thinkpadp/thinkpad-p16-gen-2-(16-inch-intel)/len101t0069#tech_specs https://www.lenovo.com/us/en/p/laptops/thinkpad/thinkpadp/th...
- foldr 3y ago> GPUs that can address up to 128 GB of RAM
- pjmlp 3y agoExcept they don't, they use unified shared memory. If you want a 128GB GPU, that is only possible with dedicated cards, those used in professional graphics workstations, none of them running macOS. https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/data-center/h100/ https://www.nvidia.com/en-us/data-center/h100/
- foldr 3y ago>Except they don't, they use unified shared memory. Yes, which is what allows the GPU to address all 128GB of the available RAM! This makes it possible to do lots of things that the laptop you linked to can't do. >If you want a 128GB GPU, that is only possible with [cards used in professional graphics workstations] That is exactly the point. But I think you know that.
- dangus 3y agoThe “components per dollar” crowd hasn’t been an Apple user since the Apple II. There are other considerations for buying a system besides the cost of a particular component. For example, let’s say your maximum budget is $4000, and you need 64GB of RAM to run those simulations. Which laptop will do so for the longest while on battery? Which laptop will make the least heat and noise? Which one is easiest to carry around? Which one can be used with a smaller power brick? Which one feels best to touch and use? If my maximum budget for a car is $50,000, should I buy the Kia that has the most features per dollar, should buy a Toyota for the reliability, or should I buy a Mercedes for the quiet and luxurious cabin? All of these brands have vehicles for $50,000 or less, so the answer all depends on my priorities. We all know that RAM is what pads Apple’s profit margins but they're selling a solution, not a bucket of components.
- bergen 3y agoThis is not 100% true, in 2008 you could have a MB/P and upgrade the RAM manually to have better price/performance then most other laptop manufacturers. Today this looks different looking at the "components per dollar" ratio due to the impossibility to swap yourself. > For example, let’s say your maximum budget is $4000, and you need 64GB of RAM to run those simulations I can get a lenovo for nearly half the price, and it feels good, and runs long enough. The other things are nice to have, but weight and heat come with the territory, if I buy a simulation monster I don't buy a small leightweight lifestyle laptop.
- dharmab 3y agoWhen I bought a Mac around 2015, they were quite competitive in certain ranges if you included a comparable display.
- pjmlp 3y agoUntil the last edition of Mac Pro, at least the components workstation crowd was still catered for. Now just like OS X Server, not really markets that are relevant for Apple's business. It is turning into consumer electronics.
- dTal 3y agoMy day-to-day experience is that a 12 gigabyte dataset will not fit into 8 gigabytes of RAM no matter whose logo is on the case. A byte is a byte.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ttfkam 3y agoWith 8GB, you will swap to SSD more. Intelligent algorithms and fast SSDs will indeed keep things running quickly and smoothly for the most part. However, the number of write cycles on the SSD will increase substantially compared to its larger-RAM peers. Combined with the likelihood that someone buying an 8GB machine will also have a smaller SSD due to budget, there is a much higher probability of failure in the shorter term. And once only one of the two SSD chips fails, you lose all your data, the BIOS, the ability to boot, and all other utility from this disposable, non-upgradable, non-repairable hardware. If the BIOS were on a separate chip and they used NVMe storage, this wouldn't be a big problem. But they aren't, so it is. You care about Right to Repair or you don't.
- foldr 3y agoThe first MacBooks with non-replaceable SSDs came out in 2016. We don't seem to have seen a significant problem with SSD failures.
- voakbasda 3y agoI have a coworker that has lost two MacBooks due to drive failure in the past two years. I would never touch one of them unless I wanted to lose my data.
- foldr 3y agoI mean sure, SSDs can fail, but they were clearly very unlucky.
- ttfkam 3y agoThe unlucky should be able to swap broken components too.
- swagempire 3y agoOk? But I have 4 Macs (MacBook Pro 2011,MacBook Air 2012, Mac Mini 2012 and a MacBook Pro2017), all with SSDs and heavy usage-- absolutely no failures so far. Almost all of my previous Macs with HDDs have failed. So maybe your co-worker is unlucky or you are saying this for another reason.
- Havoc 3y agoI too get 8 hours of sleep done in 4 hours every night.
- devit 3y ago16-bit bytes?
- johnboiles 3y agoThis was my experience. Before the M1 Pro/Max I needed to do some Apple Silicon porting for a project, so I bought the low end M1 MacBook Air with 8GB of RAM. It was amazing how well it kept up, and was generally much more snappy than my older Intel Mac with 16GB RAM. I hadn't had <16GB of RAM in years. I didn't expect it to, but it became my daily driver for several months until the Max came out.
- RecycledEle 3y agoSo if Windows is bloated, we can overcharge for RAM! So if she weighs the same as a duck, she's made of wood and therefor a witch! From Monte Python's "She's a Witch" at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zrzMhU_4m-g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zrzMhU_4m-g
- yieldcrv 3y agoIt’s always very simple: if you need contiguous memory for a single process then there are no tricks you can do and you need more RAM. If you don’t need contiguous memory there are many tricks you can do and can get away with less RAM. 99% of us are in the latter. 1% of us are in the latter 99% of the time.
- zshrc 3y agoModern paging/swapping can take a good bulk of higher memory pressure... but it comes at the cost of SSD wear. Mind you, even extreme SSD wear would result in ~7 year "failure" rate... but the SSD not being replaceable is kinda a slap in the face. For most people, 8GB is still fine. You're not getting robbed, applications have become too bloated. But the price for 8GB is a bit dumb.
- phendrenad2 3y agoIt's true, Macs just seem to be smarter with RAM allocation/paging. I'd rather have an 8GB Mac than a 16GB PC.
- deafpolygon 3y agoIsn't part of the problem that the 8GB RAM is shared by both the system and the GPU? Most PCs with 16G ram have discrete VRAM onboard their GPU, separate from the system RAM.
- WhereIsTheTruth 3y agoBad PR response.. I don't expect a macbook to be analogous to a PC, I expect macbooks to be superior to PCs.. While I believe 8gb is plenty, 16gb should be the minimum for a workstation We should also keep shaming bad developers for wasting memory.. Example: Jetbrains just released Fleet, watch the memory usage of their background toolbox ;)
- serf 3y agoITT a lot of people are making a presumption that system memory is strictly for the use of swapping, I guess presumably for the sake of coping with Apple's decision.. but there are plenty of use-cases for large amounts of contiguous and constant-use memory space, especially when considering industrial or professional use. 8GB isn't much for most developers, even if it's special Appletanium. I need a machine that won't be severely hindered whenever I spin up a persistent server or VM that's rougher on memory footprints -- the sheer speed of memory isn't going to help so much in those kind of cases.
- andrewstuart 3y agoYeah and I’ve got a bridge to sell you. These machines will become ewaste rapidly.
- karmakaze 3y agoIt entirely depends on what you're doing. If you're web browsing using Safari, than maybe. If you're compiling/linking a large application or doing anything with larger amounts of database data or running multiple application (micro)services, then no. Currently my 16 GB MacBook Pro can barely run Slack well alongside my Chrome windows/tabs and IDE. The iPhone 15 Pro and iPhone 15 Pro Max both have 8GB of RAM, so are you doing anything on your computer that's more demanding than what you do on your phone?
- barryrandall 3y ago8GB is enough if you only run native apps on local data. If your workflow requires 36 copies of Chrome to be running at all times or any number of virtual machines, it might as well be 8MB.