3 ms·
Yes, trying to lift large boxes with narrow sticks seems iffy. It's a rather bulky machine for what it does. Here's a commercially successful robot for the sam
by Animats 3y ago
Yes, trying to lift large boxes with narrow sticks seems iffy.
It's a rather bulky machine for what it does.
Here's a commercially successful robot for the same job.[1][2] Universal Robots has some nice machinery. They've succeeded where Rod Brooks' Rethink Robotics failed. No cute display with facial expressions, but better mechanical engineering and short payback times. Also, UR's machines are safe around humans. The chopstick robot looks too dangerous to run outside a cage.
While AI for controlling robots in unstructured situations still isn't that great, the mechanical and electrical parts work much better. Motors and motor controllers are great and not too expensive. Sensors are widely available and pretty good. Compensation for flexing under load has made much progress, and robots no longer need to be as rigid as a milling machine. A decade or two ago, if you tried to do anything with robots, you spent most of your effort on those issues. (Been there, done that.) We're now past that.
Vision is far enough along that semi-structured jobs work pretty well. Pick up known object from bin, place in machine, get out of the way while machine does its thing, remove object from machine, put in output bin - that covers a lot of factory work. Especially with vision systems smart enough to notice that something is gone wrong, stop, and call for help.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6QuPJnDUFi8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6QuPJnDUFi8
[2] https://www.universal-robots.com/ https://www.universal-robots.com/
- lwhi 3y agoLooks nice and it's impressive, but 1700 boxes in one day seems far less efficient though?
- Animats 3y agoThat's the price of working in the same envelope as humans. Can't build up too much kinetic energy.
- rob74 3y agoEven better (or worse): trying to lift heavy boxes with narrow sticks by holding the box from the sides - no idea what force has to be exerted by the robot to keep the box from slipping...
- traceroute66 3y ago> no idea what force has to be exerted by the robot to keep the box from slipping... I would assume that if it's anything like real chopsticks then the answer would be relatively little. If you use chopsticks correctly, you can can use surprisingly little force to pick up realistically heavy objects. I believe the physics explanation of this ability is based around the concept of levers.
- fsckboy 3y agothere are slick/slippery food pieces that can be extremely difficult to pick up with chopsticks. better/more stable chopstick skills (like this robot has) definitely help, but still a part of the problem is caused by the indirectly applied force on the two thin sticks. 3 or 4 chopsticks would be improvements. hmm, just realized, I've been on a kick to learn to do things left-handed so if I lose by abilities with my right hand I'll be ready. Or just becuase it's annoying to asymmetrical. So, I just realized if I learn to use chopsticks with my left hand, I will have 4 chopsticks at my disposal. I will be a force at the dinner table with the ha cheung.
- traceroute66 3y ago> there are slick/slippery food pieces that can be extremely difficult to pick up with chopsticks. better/more stable chopstick skills As you say, slick/slippery being difficult comes down to chopstick skills. The ultimate skills test is whether you can pick up something slick/slippery with Korean chopsticks. Why Korean? Korean chopsticks are both thin and generally manufactured in polished stainless steel. Which makes them a greater dexterity challenge than the Chinese or Japanese formats.
- Grazester 3y agoI have seen a few life long chopsticks Chinese users make a mess of themselves eating food with chopsticks. I now assume that at some point you're going to lose your food with them and more regularly than a fork