3 ms·
Conservatives have always chaffed at treaties because they’re generally hostile to the idea of international law, and they’re skeptical of giving the government
by rayiner 3y ago
Conservatives have always chaffed at treaties because they’re generally hostile to the idea of international law, and they’re skeptical of giving the government in the present the power to bind the flexibility of the government in the future. The general rule is that what one Congress does today, a different Congress can undo tomorrow.
And of course there are smart people in the Republican Party. Conservatives make up maybe 10% of lawyers, but over the last 40 years have been rolling back a generation of liberal jurisprudence. For example, they have made the case for textualism so strongly that even liberal judges feel the need to fight on that turf. As a result, the arguments made by liberals a generation ago wouldn’t fly with liberal’s of today’s generation. (Credit also goes to Justice Ginsberg, who despite her left of center bent made an entire career advancing a textualist construction of the 14th amendment.) You saw this with Roe, where the left could offer no real argument that Roe has been decided correctly on the merits to begin with, and resorted instead to emphasizing how long ago it was decided. That happened because over 50 years, conservatives completely chipped away the intellectual underpinning that made Roe defensible in the first place.
- dctoedt 3y ago> For example, they have made the case for textualism so strongly that even liberal judges feel the need to fight on that turf. The "so strongly" part comes solely from what Justice White's Roe v. Wade dissent grumbled was simply "raw judicial power."
- rayiner 3y agoMore or less. But in 1973, exercising “raw judicial power” in dispensing “Justice” was seen differently than it is today. It was quite interesting to see commenters who went to law school post 2000, like Vox’s Ian Millhiser, talk about Dobbs. Their arguments focused on things—stare decisis and public opinion—which couldn’t have justified Roe in the first instance, and couldn’t justify a similarly sweeping decision today. You can state the basic conservative position quite simply, as you have, but it took a lot of work to drag the law away from the notion of judging as an exercise in applied philosophy.