3 ms·
> I think you're right. If I'm sitting on the court, I might accept whatever flimsy loophole the Executive Branch provides, and say, "Congress is free to clarif
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> I think you're right. If I'm sitting on the court, I might accept whatever flimsy loophole the Executive Branch provides, and say, "Congress is free to clarify their intentions at any time to resolve this impasse".
See, that's why you aren't on the Court.
What the kind of people that actually get put on the Court would mostly due to allow the action without endorsing its legality would be:
(1) Be sticklers about standing and other threshold issues (ripeness, mootness, etc, but standing is the big and most useful one here); almost no litigant other than Congress acting as a whole will have the kind of particularized injury to allege that would give them standing to challenge paying the debt (an actual creditor might have standing the other way, but that's not the scenario we’re concerned with.)
(2) If you really can’t kick the case for standing or other threshold issues (well, first, amateur, but...) then invoke the “political question doctrine” to avoid it anyway.
- function_seven 3y agoHaha. Well obviously that what I meant by my shorthand phrasing! But like, for other people who aren't so smart, thanks for detailing the mechanisms I would use :)
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> almost no litigant other than Congress acting as a whole The House as a whole would probably have standing.
- function_seven 3y agoOh you just gave me an idea for another hypothetical. If the House was unable to elect a Speaker during the time the debt ceiling was breached, would they even be capable of bringing any action before the Court? One stalemate averted by another!
- dragonwriter 3y agoIt is only a rule of the House that limits business that can't be done pending election of a speaker (and before the recent crisis was resolved, one of the solutions proposed was changing the House rules to allow more with an Acting Speaker), so, not in any way that the House itself couldn’t bypass, even without electing a Speaker.
- sanderjd 3y agoAgreed. I think it would most likely be "this is a political question, we aren't going to intervene".