2 ms·
I need to clarify. I was using "the EU thinks" as shorthand for "the strong consensus view of the people running the EU". I thought (obviously wrongly) that thi
by graemep 3y ago
I need to clarify. I was using "the EU thinks" as shorthand for "the strong consensus view of the people running the EU". I thought (obviously wrongly) that this was obvious because an organisation cannot think.
I think it is safe to assume that the majority of people running the EU share the aim of "ever closer union" enshrined in EU treaties, which implies aiming to put the interests of the EU above national interests, which I took to be what the comment I was replying to meant by being "one big happy family"
- nonrandomstring 3y ago> I was using "the EU thinks" as shorthand for "the strong consensus view of the people running the EU". Understood. And I was questioning the concept of "consensus" in that frame. > I thought (obviously wrongly) that this was obvious Not at all. I don't think that is obvious. Interestingly some are raising GPT as a metaphor for emergent organisational "thinking". Is it a good analogy? I don't know, but we do see similar phenomena in networks whether they be human brains, machines or other organisms. And one feature is that we are not sure how to locate "consensus". There's lot more than weighted sums at play. And despite official structures and protocols, that's not really how things work, I think we all know. Thus the emergent identity gets a lot attributed to it, which it may not be "aware of" in large parts of itself. For minds we have the concept of the unconscious. Perhaps in neural networks we will come to recognise something similar. But the concept seems sadly lacking in organisational dynamics where it might help us to stop talking about ideas such as "What Google says" or "What the market demands". > because an organisation cannot think. And yet we so often talk as if they can. We see Searle's "Chinese Room" everywhere and wish to encapsulate and name too readily. The "EU" is "mentally unhealthy" in that sense. in that it's simply too big and disparate to be coherent and consistent. The article about snooping on web TLS certificates could not more clearly contradict other strongly held "beliefs" within the organism about "privacy".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]