3 ms·
Perhaps, but USB-C is arguably the equivalent of the Lightning port. Broken TLS is not the functional equivalent of working TLS.
by kstrauser 3y ago
Perhaps, but USB-C is arguably the equivalent of the Lightning port. Broken TLS is not the functional equivalent of working TLS.
- immibis 3y agoYou think if the government issues certificates this breaks TLS? I had no idea it was so fragile. Here's what's happening - the government wants a unified framework for digital identity. They're not saying you have to use it, but they want the framework to be there. Part of the framework is that you can get a certificate with your name on it, signed by the government saying this is officially you, and you can put this on a website to digitally sign the website. Obviously the government-issued certificate is going to have certain parameters, and they want browsers to accept these parameters so these websites will work. How else would you possibly do this, than publishing the certificate parameters and saying browsers must accept these? I don't think they prohibited the browser from saying "this is an EU identity certificate", did they? I imagine it appears as an EV green box showing the person's name and country code. I don't know why I'd ever want that to appear on my website, but I guess some people do.
- kstrauser 3y ago> You think if the government issues certificates this breaks TLS? I had no idea it was so fragile. Nice strawman. The actual situation is that the government wants to require browsers to accept signatures from CAs that the government selects, and ban them from validating the security of the certs signed by those CAs. In other words, they want the ability to be able to issue their own cert for example.com and forbid the browser from telling you that it's signed by a .gov rather than, say, Comodo. With this idiotic, mandated arrangement, it would be impossible for an end user to tell whether they were speaking directly to example.com or to the government's MITM proxy.
- immibis 3y agoWell, yes? Part of the government issuing certificates for people is that those certificates shall be accepted as proof of identity, including in browsers. I'm not sure how else you'd like to do that. Maybe they issue certificates but nobody accepts them? No, that way is madness. > and ban them from validating the security of the certs signed by those CAs. I'm going to need a source on that one, chief. Are you talking about this part? > To that end, web-browsers should ensure support and interoperability with Qualified certificates for website authentication pursuant to Regulation (EU) No 910/2014. They should recognise and display Qualified certificates for website authentication to provide a high level of assurance, allowing website owners to assert their identity as owners of a website and users to identify the website owners with a high degree of certainty. Maybe you are talking about this? > For those purposes web-browsers shall ensure that the identity data provided using any of the methods is displayed in a user friendly manner. Frankly, displaying the fact that a government issued identity certificate is used seems to me to be the exact opposite of a MITM, but what do I know? Where does it say that if google.com has Angela Merkel's personal certificate instead of Google's one, the browser shall present it as a secure connection?
- phendrenad2 3y agoI recommend reading the eff.org article linked above. It states: "Article 45 forbids browsers from enforcing modern security requirements on certain CAs without the approval of an EU member government. Which CAs? Specifically the CAs that were appointed by the government, which in some cases will be owned or operated by that selfsame government." and: "The current text of Article 45 requires that browsers trust CAs appointed by governments, and prohibits browsers from enforcing any security requirements on those CAs beyond what is approved by ETSI. In other words, it sets an upper bar on how much security browsers can require of CAs" and: "This upper bar on security may even ban browsers from enforcing Certificate Transparency" If you can't connect the dots and understand why people are upset, I can't help you.
- immibis 3y agoDoesn't this also apply, say, to certificates on government websites?
- immibis 3y agoGovernment-issued identity verification is at least as good as private-entity-issued identity verification, since, you know, the government is the one with the databases of identities.