4 ms·
I think there is another possible outcome than forcing everyone to "be on their best behaviour" all the time. Many things are today regarded as inappropriate t
by swombat 18y ago
I think there is another possible outcome than forcing everyone to "be on their best behaviour" all the time.
Many things are today regarded as inappropriate that are really not that important. Who cares whether such and such intern (or even CEO) once dressed up as a woman at a party. Only bigotry keeps people turning up their nose at such trivial nonsense.
As behaviour that was previously hidden and taboo becomes more and more visible, there are two possible outcomes:
1) (proposed by the article) the behaviour is eliminated because it cannot be tolerated. This would likely be the case for disastrous behaviours such as child abuse and conjugal violence, which, as they become more visible, are unlikely to be tolerated.
2) Social norms evolve and learn to tolerate that behaviour.
I think it is not unthinkable that in the near future many behaviours which are today still looked down upon will be accepted as normal and irrelevant to most considerations. In the inevitable collision between outdated laws/social norms and the huge masses of people who do the forbidden anyway, history tells us that the huge masses of people win.
(of course, do whatever you need to ensure you don't become roadkill on this march...)
- justindz 18y agoI tend to agree with you that we will become desensitized to less important behavior, overall, as people become more directly associated to their activities online. Most people who travel the world and eat "wacky" food become more accepting of experience they would previously regard as unusual. I see something similar happening. Of course, I'm speaking from the vantage point of someone who does silly stuff and has a fairly libertarian attitude. After the US elections, I was asking one of my gay friends what he thought about the defeat of Prop. 8 in California. I guess, not living in California, he could be more philosophical. He said that a lot of people who voted against it are going to feel awkward in 10 years when their kids are like "That was dumb. Who cares? What were you thinking?" I tend to agree that within free societies, as long as they remain free we'll move towards a point where repercussions only occur for online presentations of illegal activity, and then only if the illegal activity is also still taboo in the perpetrator's peer environment. One example might be illegal drug use, which could have serious, trivial or non-existent repercussions depending on where you work and who you run with. People will continue to only care about serious things, but the definition of "serious" will narrow on the old stuff and be newly set on brand new stuff (cloning ethics, or something).
- kaens 18y ago#2 is exactly what is happening, IMO. There has been a pretty huge influx of employers that just really don't care what their employees act like on their own time. Granted, a lot of this influx has been in the software development industry, but I really don't think that it's much of a leap to assume that it will also flow into other industries - especially considering that it is flowing through general acceptance by the average person in society. The optimistic part of me thinks that although it may have a bit of a rough transition, the next few generations after us will end up as being very open as far as accepting whatever behavior people indulge in with consenting parties.
- eru 18y agoThere was this paper about how competition eliminates the ability of employers to discriminate..
- fauigerzigerk 18y agoYes the huge masses win. The mob will win because it will be the mob that decides what is actually 2) and what is 1). Minorities lose because their (our?) behaviour may be suspicious to the masses. The judge is replaced the mob. But that's not all. Since the mob doesn't have a clear picture of everyone's actions, someone has to do the data integration and run algorithms to compute a simple number to express how suspicious someone's behaviour is. HR managers will no longer personally google for applicants. The whole thing will be outsourced and those affected will never know why they didn't get that job or that bride. Something suspicious, nobody will know what. The algorithms might use heuristics and random factors so nobody can ever find out why a particular decision was taken other than that the suspicion factor was too high.
- swombat 18y agoThat's the other side of the coin, for sure. And yet, I think worthwhile minorities (such as geniuses) will always find a way to bypass the majority rule to make their mark.
- fauigerzigerk 18y agoAnd being a true genius I'm not worried at all ;-)
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- dejb 18y ago> someone has to do the data integration and run algorithms to compute a simple number to express how suspicious someone's behaviour is. HR managers will no longer personally google for applicants. I think this is unlikely. If this 'simple number' was not an accurate measure of likely job performance then companies who relied on it would be at a huge disadvantage. Companies (and by extension their HR departments) who ignored it or incorporated their own information would tend to prevail.
- fauigerzigerk 18y ago