3 ms·
> Jurors cannot be tried for their findings. True, but not the issue here. > A juror is free to infer that you are guilty when you plead the fifth, No, they
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Jurors cannot be tried for their findings.
True, but not the issue here.
> A juror is free to infer that you are guilty when you plead the fifth,
No, they aren't, which is why:
(1) If the trial judge decides before the case goes to the jury that a reasonable jury could not convict the defendant without making such a prohibited inference, the judge can dismiss the case, either in response to a defense motion or on their own, without even sending it to the jury,
(2) If the trial judge makes the same determination after the jury returns a conviction, the judge can toss the verdict and and acquit the defendant (which they could not do with a jury acquittal), and
(3) If an appeals court reaches the same decision after the trial judge has accepted the jury verdict and entered a conviction, the appeals court can reverse the conviction (which they could not do for an acquittal.)
Criminal acquittals are a constitutional special case of jury freedom in the US, as a special protection against imposition of criminal punishment by the government. The freedom juries have to ignore the law and facts and acquit because they feel like it in criminal cases is neither symmetrically reflected in a similar freedom to criminally convict, nor manifest, in either direction, in civil cases.